Snug, old-school Italian eatery serving pasta & pizza, including whole-wheat & gluten-free options. Based on 724 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
W63N688 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012
Phone: (262) 377-7630
Website: http://www.tomasoscedarburg.com/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
William Bryant
Never been to this restaurant before. Expected to have a great experience but was not expecting to be seated in a tight corner. If you are looking for a waiter/waitress to serve you here then look elsewhere as you have to order at the bar. When the food appears at the bar you have to go and get it yourself. Salad was a little yellowish for me but the ranch was the best part of it. I ordered the Lasagna and when it arrived with a roll for the bread instead of garlic bread I was dissatisfied. The lasagna was in a bowl that was hot and thankfully I was told it was while it was also placed on a plate for me to carry across the room to my table. Did not taste the garlic that I would like to see in this dish. A bit sweet the sauce was. Looked like lasagna but did not taste like one. Watched the waiter clean a few tables and noticed he put the silver pizza racks that sit on the tables get put on the floor then back on a clean table. There were leftover pizza sauce left on them and were not wiped down. Very tight fitting place here. Just think it would be better with a few less tables and waiting staff plus better tasting food considering it’s Italian food you would think they would be garlic basil oregano things like that in your food, but I did not taste that overall not a great Italian restaurant.
… more
William Alexander
My first time here and when I walked in and smelled that fresh aroma of garlic I knew I was in for a treat!! I’ll cut to the chase. The pizza was the best I’ve had in a long, long time. Thin cracker crust that held up. A slight buttery flavor to it. The sauce, which is on top of the cheese not vise versa, was sweet and fresh. Sausage, mushrooms and onions were also fresh and added to the abundance of flavor. I honestly can’t find one thing to nit pick about. The pizza was flawless. Garlic bread was fantastic and left you craving more. Wonderful ambiance. It had that old school Italian restaurant vibe. Service was fast and very friendly. Prices are extremely fair. I had such a great time here that I will definitely be a repeat customer no matter how high the gas prices get. Salute!!
… more
raversmiracle2
This tiny pizza place in the heart of Cedarburg has some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. They have a unique method of putting the cheese on top of the crust before the sauce so that the crust stays crispy longer.
… more
Alex Phinney
Best pizza anywhere. Dine bar is small but staff is always friendly and drinks aren’t to pricey. Been going here for years the deep dish is simply fantastic.
… more
Latrez H
This pizza is the best I mean when I tell you the best the best this is crazy. I wish they had one downtown Milwaukee they’ll take over everything downtown but I don’t mind driving to their location. It’s definitely worth it.
… more
Scott Campbell
Best pizza around, great staff and owners. Wonderful atmosphere and very clean.
… more
Gary F
A local said this was his favor lunch spot so that was good enough for us. This smallish place has order at the counter ambience, but was packed when we sat down during the lunch rush. Looking at other people’s orders it seemed to be roughly half sandwiches and half pizzas. The pizzas we ordered had thin crusts, a pleasing sauce and an ample amount of toppings. What isn’t there to love?
… more
Nick Lundbohm
Always a pleasure to dine here. Even after a festival day we were able to be seated in about 20-30 minutes. We’ve always enjoyed the pizza here for take out, so we decided it was time to try the pasta. My daughter inhaled her kids spaghetti with red sauce and my wife and I both thoroughly enjoyed our specialty pasta. Her spicy chicken and spinach cavatappi had it all; spice, flavor, meat, and just enough sauce. I had the chicken carbonara with mushrooms, onion, bacon and a delicious cream sauce that wasn’t overwhelming or too rich. For the price, this is a great dining experience with a friendly atmosphere.
… more
Yashima Gardner
Every year doing Strawberry Fest it is a tradition me my daughter and family friend eat at Tomaso, pizza it is so delicious we love it. The service there is awesome
… more
Myron Robinson
The food and service was awesome. Nice small restaurant with big flavor. One thing that was a little different was having to go to the bar to order and pick up the food, but the food make up for it. I would definitely recommend the spinach artichoke pizza with white sauce, and the calamari with aioli.
… more
… View more