Based on 128 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
5805 Chillicothe Lancaster Rd SW, Amanda, OH 43102
Phone: (740) 969-4969
Hours
| Wednesday | 2–9 PM |
| Thursday | 2–9 PM |
| Friday | 1–10 PM |
| Saturday | 1–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 2–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 2–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Bill
When I read some of these reviews, I can clearly see you hired a review company to place false reviews to increase your business because there’s something wrong with your establishment. Varney family needs to get back to customers first and run your business like God intended you to run this shop when you started years ago. If you need to hire reviewers, then there’s something definitely wrong within the business. You can do better than this.
… more
Ann Cooper
We just moved to the area and this is now our go to dinner place many times a month they are all super helpful and courteous The food is Hot and ready when they say it will be. Someone told us this place used to be open inside before COVID and Boy I sure hope they bring that back .
… more
Resting Bitchface
Great little place with good sauce. Yummy dough. Hard working staff that was also very kind.
… more
Rachel Smith
Pizza is pretty alright, but a bit greasy in my opinion when it comes to the pepperoni pizza. The ‘all the way pizza’ was delicious, though! Perfect every time I order! I personally haven’t had anything to complain about in all of my orders from there. I hope and wish the best for this pizza place when it comes to finding and having the right employees so as to insure quality and good service.
… more
david scurlock
Just go and try it if you live in the area you know it’s the closest pizza place around
… more
Nate Burge
Grabbed a pizza there tonight and it was amazing! Lexx, Toni, and Dylan were fantastic!
… more
Ian Jobes
It was an impromptu visit as we were recommended to go there by a gentleman at a local gas station. I was pleasantly surprised and enjoyed every bit. The lady at the front desk took her time listened to our story and made sure that she took care of us during a rough day and made our pizza ” in what ever way made our day better” small town shop with amazing flavor. If we are ever in the area again I would order again in a heartbeat. That’s for the extra care.
… more
shanette smith
Pizza was horrible tonight. I got a cauliflower crust and it was extremely burnt. My husbands pizza was extremely cold and burnt also. This is very not like them.
… more
Kevin Numbers
I can’t figure out what makes this pizza so desirable and so tasty. The flavor of the crust is just like grandma’s, the sauce, vegetables, meats and cheese are fresh and top notch. The care in making each pizza is obvious in the very first bite. Aside from the importance of the taste of the food, is the quality of service. The owner actually works in the kitchen, greets the customers with a smile and is genuinely friendly and sincere. The other employees are always friendly and greet you with a smile. I highly recommend Tommy Wayne’s Pizza and will continue to be a valued customer for many years to come.
… more
Ron Fowler
Family owned and they take pride in each of their offerings! My wife loves the All The Way Pizza minus the Onions and Green Peppers! I’m a fan of the Super Sub…. 20+ years of ordering here – same quality since our first order and friendly service as well. NOT A NATIONAL CHAIN AND IT SHOWS! Super clean facility.
… more
… View more