Based on 198 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
Address:
101 N Mill St, Shepherdstown, WV 25443
Phone: (304) 876-2577
Website: https://m.facebook.com/pages/Tommys-Pizza/205174429506197
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tom Owens
Ordered a small cheese pizza for carry out. Pizza was not properly cut and the cheese was globbed in the center. Ordinarily not a problem but I was in a hotel so no access to cutters, etc. A little attention to detail is needed.
… more
Gene Baker
Great pizza! I was told by another customer that the ingredients are all homemade, I didn’t ask the owner but the man that told me worked there years ago. Nice atmosphere and the staff was very friendly. This was the best pizza I’ve had in a long time, we will be back for more!
… more
Kevin Tsuneishi
Just the smell of my pizza is five stars. I think it is funny, I see a few people from out of town giving low ratings, and complain about the old guy working there. He’s the owner, and he is super old-school. The way he is, is actually one of the quarks that make this place special. I enjoy going there, and supporting his business. Great food, and straight to the point. Buy food, eat food, get out. Then come back and do it again!
… more
Michael Norman
I’m from out of the area and went to Tommy’s since it had decent reviews about the pizza. When I got there the old gentleman that works there never greeted myself or the other patron in line, instead gave us looks of annoyance. Myself and the other customer walked out due to poor customer service and he never bothered to ask for any of our orders after standing around for close to 10 minutes. I ended up going to King’s Pizza instead where myself and the other patron was greeted and welcomed!
… more
Jordan O’Dea
I’ve driven by this place for years thinking man I need to try that place, don’t be like me! We finally tried this place tonight and it is some of the best pizza I’ve ever had New York or anywhere. The other joints in the area don’t even compare. Definitely gonna be a regular
… more
Julian Bhuwalka
Terrible place! Absolutely worst pizza I’ve ever had. Saw the reviews and thought it would be great! Dough taste like old dust and the cheese (if you could call it that) was so greasy, it would have caused an acne breakout at every high school! What a shame to cook pizza that way ♂️
… more
Karen Brown
Great, fast pizza every time for generations of satisfied customers! My favorite pizza anywhere. Great price. They also have delicious subs etc. Eat in or take to the C&O canal or the Morgans Grove park for a lovely picnic. The chain restaurants can’t compete!
… more
Gabrielle “Gabby” Flanary
Went here a couple of years ago on a high school trip. It was around 8 at night and a group of us decided we wanted pizza. When we got there, the gentleman (who I’m assuming was the manager), told us he wasn’t doing individual orders for each of us kids. So the chaperones had to end up buying 3 pizzas for all of us since they were too unwilling to listen to their customers. The pizza was pretty good, but they lacked any customer service skills.
… more
Gabriel Jennier
I love their pizzas. I go there every so often, but it would be courteous if he could be more polite over the phone. Apparently, i “prank called” him, when really, i asked if he had good greasy pizzas. They are delicious, but he also shouldnt just hang up on people. Its not courteous
… more
Adam Miller
One of my favorite spots for decades. As a kid, we’d pool our change together for a bag of fries, or if we were lucky we’d have enough to split a pizza. Nowadays I prefer the hamburgers and like that they have a few refrigerated beer and soda cases. It’s usually a quiet place for a quick bite to eat and one of the best grab and go places in Shepherdstown. No frills, no hassles, delivery is sometimes available.
… more
… View more