Inventive pies, gourmet slices & classic Italian dishes offered in an airy cafe with a patio. Based on 431 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
88-90 Old Riverhead Rd, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978
Phone: (631) 288-5211
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Vanessa Leggard
My favorite pizza in the Hamptons. Cheese is fresh, crust is not to doughy and the sauce is delicious. I love the margarita pizza. Delivery options as well.
… more
ellen mayo
Staff are friendly. They greet you as you enter. All their food is good over the years. This time I got the pepperoni slice stuffed with buffalo chicken. The name says it all: It’s a monster! The buffalo is not too hot. If I wanted wings, I’d want it hotter, but in the slice it’s just right.
… more
Aida Wetzel
On 8-22-23 we ordered a full tray of salad plus garlic breads and 2 pizzas. We were very surprised that the salad we got, mostly lettuce with a strip of shredded carrots and chopped up black olives was $95 plus tax. I did speak to Tony on the phone and he seemed to have all the answers to why it is that much. After the fact, I found out that similar trays could be gotten for $50 and up to $65. Our son lives in a place that Tonino’s is the closest to him and so, he purchased it without realizing it till after it was delivered. Sorry to give Tonino’s of West Hampton not such a good review but some of your customers do work hard for their money as some of your workers and you do too, but still the price for this salad is really set up much too high for what was in it. No tomatoes, onions, radishes, maybe 5 slices of cucumbers and nothing more execpt for the decorative carrots and black olives. Sincerely Aida Wetzel
… more
Breanna Michaud
Always great service, amazing food and even better employees!! The music they have on the weekend is great!! Will always come back for their great food and desserts! Highly recommended
… more
Michael LeFort
Just went for the first time yesterday…. My entire family loved it in there I might be driving great distances to pick up those pizza from where I live 🙂
… more
Jessy Bedoya
I ordered a grilled chicken wrap and the chicken was just cooked… hahaha it had no roast flavor… it was even cold. They don’t listen to You.
… more
Quintin May
They can’t make a pizza for the life of them. The hero’s other then the meatball are all tasteless junk. Got a Philly and essentially got a sandwich made out of vegetables. With little to no meat. And some of the meat was green and purple like mold
… more
kim mulgrew
atmosphere from start to finish was weird, was rushed into ordering and after telling them my mom was deaf they still didn’t accommodate or even try to communicate properly with her. pizza looked good but didn’t taste as fresh. would not recommend plus the owner i think? rushed a group of people not even. 3 mins after they sat down like .. not the best time but pizza was semi pretty
… more
Dom
Great pizza, huge portions, amazing prices? What’s not to love here? Clean facilities, friendly staff, a great lunch experience. Definitely recommend it.
… more
Joe Arnold Sr.
In town for work, this is an amazing establishment! Staff is friendly and knowledgeable! Pizza is great too!!
… more
… View more