Based on 293 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
325 N 10th St #100, Lewisburg, PA 17837
Phone: (570) 768-4225
Hours
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Trypp Adams
They had cheese and Margherita slices when I rolled in late around 8pm. I had them add some pepperoni to the cheese and they popped them in the oven in typical New York fashion. The slices where good, hit the spot. Need to come mid day when they have more slices or just order a pizza
… more
Andy Crawford
First time we visited 7/30/2020. They have a great menu. Large variety of foods to choose from. The service was exceptional. Very helpful it describing the different entrees. We started with an appetizer of fried ravioli. Delicious. My wife had their traditional spaghetti and meat balls. I had their chicken parmigiana with penne pasta. Both were very good. We finished with a cannoli. Yum! Prices are very reasonable. Well worth another visit.
… more
W L
Avoid the margherita pizza at all costs. I felt bad for this pie as it seemed very unloved, I don’t know how else to explain it. In review of google however, I found out that many have shared similar pains. I found out too late. Not sure if they read their reviews but they should take a look at the comments for the margarita concoction. My experience is no different. There is a considerable amount of awkwardly chopped tomatoes with the core included. When they took it out of the oven the gentleman actually tipped it to its side to drain the water…….. gotta be a sign something has gone awry. Cheese was NOT melted and basil was absent for the trip. Also, there was no sauce to be found. If they are insistent this be a menu item then pls change the name….. this is the ugly stepchild of Margherita and I’m sure she does not appreciate it. I wish the owners all the best, really. We will try the traditional cheese next time. Review to follow.
… more
Edward Witkowski
Awful experience. We ordered two pizzas. The hot honey chicken, which was amazing. Then we ordered the margarita pizza. What we got, I didn’t even recognize. Cubed tomatoes from the grocery store that were raw on top of an already cooked pizza that had chunks of mozzarella thrown on it. No basil. It had some dried sprinkling of oregano. It was literally the worst pizza I have ever ordered from a non-chain restaurant. I’m not a picky eater, and never return food. I asked them politely to please make us another pizza, which they told me I would have to pay for. I told them this didn’t even resemble the description of the pizza or a margarita pizza that I have ever seen. They didn’t care. I asked him to point out the basil that was in the description. He brought me some bruised up nasty basil to toss on the top of this gross pizza. It wasn’t even on the pizza before. I won’t be back to this place. Please note that the photo I added below has no sauce, and was $20!! The hot honey chicken was $19.50. That was worth it. What I got in the margarita pizza was not worth it for even a moment.
… more
Cassandra Bessasparis
We have ordered cheese pizza before and been satisfied. However, today we decided to order their “gourmet” margherita pizza. Disappointed is an understatement. It was incredibly soggy, so much so that the box was soaked through. It is also supposed to have fresh basil, whereas this pizza had dried basil, like from a plastic container. Thankfully we grow basil in our garden and could salvage it but I will definitely not be ordering here again.
… more
sheryl trautman
Had excellent cheesesteaks here. I’m staying at a hotel so thought a panini would be easier. After choking on a couple of bone dry bites, checked it to see it was meat, a couple onions, no cheese. The “panini” was basically soggy bread. I was so hungry and disappointed.
… more
Liz Knelly
Ordered the Chicken Caesar Wrap and a pizza and mozzarella sticks. Pizza was ok, mozz sticks could have been cooked longer. The wrap turned out to be a panini and well, it was not great. Lettuce does not do well in hot food, which i know this because i was ordering a wrap or so i thought. It was extremely dry as what little caesar dressing they had on it soaked in to the hot sandwich. If it was a menu mistake and that is how it is supposed to be prepared, i’d take it off the menu. If it was just an accident and it was not supposed to be panini pressed then fine, just watch what you are doing please! Not everyone has time to come back and get things fixed over their lunch break from work.
… more
Michael Walls
Hands down best pizza in town! Always tasty, consistent, with fresh, quality ingredients. Good ratio of toppings on a perfectly thin, crispy crust. Never greasy or soggy or rubbery like some others here. We’re from the Philly suburbs and Toninos is just like home. Good job guys and girls!
… more
Crystal James
Horrible..Only go here if u want to pay for horrible service and food..they want to charge u full price but give u half your food who does that?..Called to say something about it and the women hung up on….But its cool the workers in there are rude and nasty anyways…Who ever the person is at the time taking orders for food are picking up touching their cell phones then dealing with your food afterwards without washing their hands SO I CAN IMAGINEWHAT ELSE THEIR TOUCHING WHEN THEY WALK OFF AND COME BACK…NO GLOVES ON..I’ve have seen that with my own eyes and have heard about it several times so at this point its ok for me to eat some where else cleaner…To many pizza shops around for me to deal with nasty customer service and nastyness…thanks for sending me some where else I appreciate it…
… more
Samantha Killiany
Love Tonino’s food… Once they get it right for once. Ate inside for the first time in a while and they made the wrong entree for one person in the party and never brought out a simple single slice of pizza for an hour after the rest of the table got their food. All they said was sorry and that was it after they gave attitude about them being in the wrong. Just ordered pizza about two months after this interaction and they gave us one completely wrong pie (which was way cheaper than the one we paid for) and one that didn’t have the extra $8 of toppings. Wish they cared more about their customers since the food is good.
… more
… View more