Based on 43 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
Address:
1191 Rte 9W, Marlboro, NY 12542
Phone: (845) 236-9658
Website: https://www.facebook.com/tonysitalianrestaurantmarlboro/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Aurora Porto
Ordered some take out of shrimp parmigiana. Food was good. It might a little bit more pricey but quality is worth it. I enjoyed this meal.
… more
Heather Peterson
This restaurant is my absolute favorite spot in town. For any occasion I bring my family & friends here knowing it will always be a fantastic meal! The service is 10/10- the kindest staff makes you feel very welcome and the owner Tony is always walking around making sure the food is perfect and everyone is happy. Highly recommend if you’re in search of the best Italian food!!
… more
Veronica Haley
Stopped here with my family on the way home traveling from the Poconos to CT for no reason, just hungry and saw it while driving by. This was the most attentive service I’ve had in a long time. Our waitress (Sue I believe she said) brought items to our table without us needing to ask, refilled our drinks with no issues, and was overall so kind, esp to my 11 month old.
… more
Samantha Ayoub
I usually go here twice a week if I can. Let me tell you! THE SERVICE IS AMAZING AND SO IS THE WAITRESS IZZY! Hands on the best restaurant I’ve been to. Very nice people and food is always good and comes out on time. Definitely try if you around in the area!
… more
Deborah Valentino Short
It was our first time at Tony’s and it was warm and cozy. A Quaint little Italian restaurant. The food was delicious , service was awesome and we will be back..
… more
Simona Golea-Hosein
Our first times here, but we definitely will be back
… more
Maurice Marsilla
Amazing food, amazing staff, amazing chef! If you want amazing Italian food plus more go here, you will not be disappointed at all. The food portions are huge too ! Prices are amazing. I come all the way from New Jersey to have this restaurant highly recommend !
… more
Mr. Spock
This used to be Suzi’s. Now it’s an “Italian Restaurant”. This is the FARTHEST THING from an Italian restaurant I’ve ever had the displeasure of eating at. The menu had no pasta dishes. One of the specials was ravioli… which had more cheese on top than a LARGE pizza. The sauce tasted canned. I’m so sorry I came here. The only good thing was the soda… Pepsi for me, Sprite for mom. For 2 ravioli parm dinners and 2 drinks… $56. I could’ve gone to a steakhouse, had 2 decent steaks for less than that
… more
Jackie Eller
If it was possible to give Tony’s Italian Restaurant more than 5 stars, I definitely would. My family and myself have never had anything less than fantastic. The meals are delicious, the atmosphere is very welcoming, and the service is top notch. Whether you are a party of one, or are looking for a great place to have a party, definitely consider Tony’s. You won’t be disappointed.
… more
hammer Sanchez
I was passing by this town and happened to stop for dinner. This place is fantastic! The servers are welcoming, attentive and very friendly. Sue was my server and she was great! The food is full of flavor, and large portions are served. I had the mussels, vegetable soup and grilled salmon – all delicious!!!
… more
… View more