Italian classics, including homemade pastas & seafood dishes, in an upscale-casual space with a bar. Based on 556 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
16 W Beck St, Columbus, OH 43215
Phone: (614) 224-8669
Hours
| Wednesday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 4:30–10 PM |
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4:30–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Reviews
Dkay
Its our first time dining here and we love it. The food is tasty and delicious. Dessert is perfectly made where its not overly sweet. Its such a pretty and relaxing place to dine in. We had a really nice server and a great experience dining here. We will have to come back.
… more
Michelle Frost
My family and I have been going to Tony’s for 20 years and we know that we can always count on a wonderful experience. Tony, the owner, is almost always present and checking into every detail to make sure your visit is a good one. It has the feeling of an old school neighborhood restaurant with upscale touches and excellent food. I’d love to comment on the whole menu but I always get Tony’s fettuccine and I so look forward to it that I never get anything else! But I know family members have sampled different dishes and loved them all. I’m so glad we found this little gem so many years ago.
… more
King Of Spades
This restaurant is amazing. We loved how it wasn’t located in the heart of the hustle and bustle areas of downtown. It’s in the German village district. This restaurant also has a parking lot available too..food and service was great. Very reasonably priced. Great size portions. Nice romantic restaurant. It can be a bit loud but all in all it’s a very nice restaurant.
… more
Christy Beegle
We had an early reservation…5pm on a Thursday. So, besides another couple at the bar, we were the only diners when we arrived. Loved the atmosphere and decor. The service was great and the food was delicious. Unsure about the parking due to us walking from our hotel. I’m sure it’s behind the building. Just not sure how big the lot is. Also, main entrance is on the side on Beck St.
… more
Carlos
If you’re looking for old school Italian this is the place! Food was good and a decent value! The only real negative was that the corner I was in was a little musty. Kinda like being in Nona’s house that’s over a hundred years old. Bottom line good old school Italian at a reasonable price it’s a good stop
… more
Rachel Kees
We originally went out for burgers and the atmosphere at that restaurant was smoky and questionable so we ended up at Tony’s and talk about a night and day difference! Promptly greeted and sat, restaurant is absolutely gorgeous and these guys pay great attention to detail. They had a lobster ravioli on special and my friend got a chicken tortellini dish. The food was absolutely incredible and the owner should be proud of his cooking and wait staff because these guys are the cream of the crop. This is an incredible price value for the experience of the restaurant, quality of food served, and attentiveness of wait staff. I read some reviews about portions and honestly these portions are just right. If you want to pork out on mass produced Italian go to Olive Garden for endless pasta. If you want an authentic experience and thoughtfully prepared dishes, come to Tony’s.
… more
Hay Shafer
Absolutely wonderful. I’ve read some ignorant reviews & I know I cannot speak for other people, but the service here is WONDERFUL. You can really tell the owner cares about his customers. This is my go to Italian restaurant here in Columbus. Great food, service, and atmosphere!
… more
Melanie Hancock
Worst Experience EVER!!! I was literally served SPOILED meat. The chef and waiter admitted it was spoiled and still placed it on the meal on my bill and yet to credit it back. Service was ok. Other guest said their food was just ok. Still disputing charging. Was literally physically ill that evening from the little I ate. Will NEVER return. No apologies from management or anything. I Have Never!!! Yet I still tipped my server as it wasn’t his fault.
… more
Amanda Bell
My husband and I love this place. We’ve only been to Tony’s a couple of times, but it has been wonderful. I have to recommended the lasagna. It’s layered so perfectly with flavor and great amount of cheese. I love it.
… more
CK Sexton
Racist restaurant and just don’t it’s a bad vibe all around. They had us wait 5 minutes for our reservation that we had nade online for us to just walk out. It was awkward and rude to experience this place. went to mid city garage and had a delicious meal! No side of racism at all
… more
… View more