Based on 162 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
302 W Main St, Middletown, PA 17057
Phone: (717) 616-8141
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ravec22
These guys just stole my business from any other pizza joint in town. Anyone rating this place less than 5 stars doesn’t know what real Italian food is. Meat Stromoli was AMAZING! Homemade sub rolls are huge, perfectly baked. Possibly the best veal parmesan sub I’ve ever eaten, not processed. Breaded mushrooms, cooked to perfection. I won’t order from anyone else from here on out. I would have payed double for the quality of food I just got. 10/10 hands down
… more
Gene L
This has been my go-to pizza place in Middletown since 2019. It’s 2023, and that hasn’t changed. The sub rolls are fresh, soft, and delicious, and they for SURE don’t skimp on the meat. I’ve had most all of their specialty slices, and they’ve all been stellar. I recently had them provide pizzas for a pizza party at my warehouse, and it was a smash hit. If you’re anywhere near Middletown and looking for good Italian, you’ll want to head to Tony’s!
… more
Rachel D
I placed an order online for pickup. The food was ready quickly, which was great, and the size of the pizza was very large. However, the taste of the pizza was just awful. I ordered the steak pizza, and it was so disgusting. Whole slices of the yellow American cheese were on it. Not even ranch could save it. I paid for onions to be added and there were no onions. I would not order from here again.
… more
Kekis Khan
Just got food from here. Now I’ve had alot and I mean alot of pizza from all over middletown. It all has been kind of mediocre. This place isn’t really any exception. I read the reviews before coming here to and I honestly should have listened. However I didn’t experience any rude social interaction what truly matters is that the food speaks for itself that’s the voice of your business. I think they should invest in higher quality ingredients and shrink portion sizes. It wasn’t the worst thing I’d ever eaten but I don’t think i would’ve spent what I did now knowing what the food tastes like. To the owners, times are rough I understand that completely, but I would seriously recommend completely changing how the pizza is made. Do not take this as a bash, take it as a learning experience and something to improve upon. Hope you all have a good evening.
… more
Kyle Reed
I have been to many pizza shops.. this is on my top 3 now. By far the best crust I’ve had. Only thing I suggest Is change up the decor.. bit odd walking in and seeing toys everywhere.
… more
Beatriz Garcia
Very good food, had me an Italian sub toasted , the sub was nice and warm to my liking, and a slice of buffalo chicken pizza . Will recommend for quick bite to eat
… more
ronald feldman
Very tasty LARGE Italian sub. Very good bread. Great sauce and cheese on their pizza! Will definitely go back.
… more
Jeremiah Gipe
We had $40 for a $25 order and needed change back but the delivery person had no change and told us it’s our fault for not having the exact amount and that we still needed to pay. We called the restaurant to talk to the boss but he was no help and basically argued with us! It makes me feel like we got scammed. Lost out on $15
… more
Troy Baker
Some menu prices are higher than what is shown on google and Facebook. It’s probably an honest oversight, but the employees made no effort to take responsibility and correct their mistake.
… more
Journey Through Life
I’ve been in the area for several weeks for training. I’ve eaten here on several occasions and have always really enjoyed my meal. The staff is very friendly and the food is great! Keep up the good work guys.
… more
… View more