Based on 316 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
Address:
2771 Paterson Hamburg Turnpike, Stockholm, NJ 07460
Phone: (973) 697-5680
Website: http://tonyson23.hrpos.heartland.us/
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Victoria T
Tony’s is my family’s local pizza restaurant that serves more than pizza. I love to get prime rib dinners there. BUT after today’s experience, they have lost customers for good.
… more
Becky LG
Always a treat The service is always friendly fast and attentive. Food is always on point the mothers days specials were delightful. One special was an appetizer called crab melts. They were so delicious i ordered the appetizer for dinner. Oh i highly recommend the chicken Parmigiano and any of the steaks.
… more
Krylon Kidd
Steve’s steamed clams were in an amazing buttery, garlicy sauce that was out of this world and the vida dolce was cooked to perection. It is my new favorite restaurant! The waitress melanie was awesome too!
… more
John Culotta
Pizza is bangin here. Plain pie, thin crust, well done – thank me later.
… more
Richard Filippone
This place hands down top 5 pizzerias in north jersey and it’s in Sussex county! This place still tastes like food did in the 90’s, pride in ownership from humble owners make this place so special! Where else do they still make the soups from scratch and not from the old chicken that they have to get rid of?! GET THE GRANDMA YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT! WORTH ANY DRIVE!
… more
Tiffany Marsh
Waitress was so nice! Wings though!!! We got honey bbq and Daytona I would eat those wings every day!
… more
Jessica O’Brien
The food is ok, nothing great. The staff are just plain rude. I tried to order 3 slices of pizza at the pizza counter and I was greeted with an eye roll from the guy behind the counter and was told to take a seat and order from the menu (I don’t even think pizza by the slice is listed on the menu). Then the owner followed me to the table and proceeded to tell me, very loud for all to hear, that “you people” (meaning those of us that come from the next door skating rink between hockey games) are not welcome. We come in large groups and they don’t know how to handle the crowd (it’s usually maybe a group of 10 people). Meanwhile the restaurant is never filled to capacity, we are always treated like dirt and they were very rude to all the kids many times, the orders are almost always wrong, even when we call ahead and just order plain pizzas, and the food takes forever to come out. Once they served mozzarella sticks that were still frozen. Long story short, go to TJs about 5 minutes down the road, they have a much nicer staff and the food is amazing. The 3 people in my family along with 10 others from the ice rink left before we ordered and will not return.
… more
L G
Pickup order. Used to live closer. Now it’s about 25 minutes away. But husband prefers the pizza here.
… more
Kevin Carroll
The food is very good at Tony’s. The place was very busy, always a good sign. The service was as good as the food. Our waitress Brianna was very friendly and awesome at her job. pleasurable experience
… more
Matt Becker
Great place! Had an excellent salad! Dressing was homemade.
… more
… View more