Italian Steak House proudly serving food prepared fresh daily with only the finest ingredients, incorporating local and organic products to our offerings.
Indoor and outdoor dining available.
Private event rooms can accommodate up to 150 guests for your next party.
Based on 49 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
3275 Byron St, Wantagh, NY 11793
Phone: (516) 783-6484
Website: http://www.totosrestaurantli.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–11 PM |
| Saturday | 1–11 PM |
| Sunday | 1–9:30 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
V Caz
Would have never been on my list of places to go. Hidden area near park and nothing pretty on the outside. Decided to try it last night with family for my son’s birthday because I heard the food was good. Well….. what an amazing experience!! Food was excellent as was our waiter. Octopus Bronzino osabuco T-bone steak all delicious. Waiter even offered us all a complimentary after dinner drink. Will definitely be back
… more
Mike S
Food was delicious. Went with a dozen people and we all loved it. I had the gnocchi ragout. Phenomenal. The only problem was the waiter who disappeared for 45 minutes when we wanted the bill. When he graced us with his presence, he had an attitude and a smart mouth. They should get rid of that old man if he doesn’t want to be there.
… more
Sareeta Dyal
Beautiful and very warm restaurant.
… more
Lisa G
Juan (our waiter) was fantastic, the food was delicious, the music was great. The people at the table around us were incredible. We will be back soon.
… more
Nicolas Oliveros
Hidden gem, you do not foresee the place is an excellent Italian restaurant… I guess locals know very well but as a traveler from Europe it came as a total surprise. We had excellent food (suitable for all tastes), received impeccable service and enjoyed live music from a charming lady (on a Thursday). Do not miss it if you have the opportunity.
… more
Martin G Miller
A lovely high class place. Nice decor, quiet background music and a very attentive and friendly wait staff. My wife’s lamb chops were superb. All the food was excellent. Beautiful presentation. Creamy mushroom soup was very flavorful. Highly recommended.
… more
Julian Ross Imaging
What a gem! I had the octopus starter. It’s so easy to mess up cooking octopus but it was smooth and firm, full of flavour. The pairing of garlic, chilli peppers, capers and broccoli was perfect. My main was a pepper coated seared tuna. Again cooked to perfection; tasty searing but a melt in your mouth core of raw tuna. The pepper very present but not over powering. The ginger-soy glaze a perfect complement. The genuine Italian staff are attentive, yet not over powering. I have to admit to having Tiramisu too. The pictures can’t lie 😉 May I give it 6 stars?!
… more
Sierra Hajdu
Ate a delicious steak dinner at Toto’s with my family! The owners are the same as Villa de Aqua in Bellmore, another family favorite for us. Not only was the food tasty and cooked to perfection, but the service was superb and the server did not skip a beat – our water and wine glasses were never empty! The ambiance was cozy and more traditional. We got the burrata salad, both types of calamari (the fried appetizer & the grilled special), a porterhouse & the ribeye steak special, with mashed potatoes & broccoli as our sides. If we had to change anything in our order, we’d probably order 2 grilled calamari specials because it was so flavorful! We will 100% be coming back to Toto’s!
… more
Ben Canarick
Unbelievable service, food and atmosphere! Amazing drink menu to follow to one of the most amazing steaks I have ever had. Will definitely be back for more!
… more
Debbie Dananberg
Awesome food and service! The staff was very attentive – my water glass was always full and I drink a lot of water! I had a filet mignon cooked perfectly – medium rare like I ordered. The sides were separate and large servings (definitely recommend you share these) – all the sides I tasted were great especially the broccoli and steamed spinach. The atmosphere was great – there was a man playing keyboard and singing. Highly recommend Totos which has now become my go-to place for steaks. Oh, and they do have other options like fish and pasta.
… more
… View more