Trophy Pizza is a legit pie and slice joint making Cincinnati’s best authentic New York style pizza as well as gourmet, fresh salads and to-die-for prepared meals for takeaway.
– Grab a fresh slice for a fast lunch
– Bring dinner home to your family
– Feed the office with a stack of pies
– Get hot pizza delivered to your door
– Cater your next party or event
We can’t wait to share our love for truly great pizza with you. See you soon!
Based on 133 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
10325 Reading Rd # 102, Cincinnati, OH 45241
Phone: (513) 769-1111
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alana Jenkins
My husband and I went here a few weeks ago and I can’t believe I didn’t write a review for it. This got a fantastic ride up in the Cincinnati Enquirer about it being the best New York style pizza in Cincinnati and that is accurate. We were only planning on trying a slice each and leaving. We ended up getting two slices each and would have done three had we not also gotten the cheesecake. The pepperoni pizza is heavenly and my husband enjoyed the one with ranch immensely. The cheesecake is also incredible and even he enjoyed it and he’s not a big cheesecake fan. I would go back just for that too.
… more
Kenneth Wolfer
Has been on my “Pizza Hit List” for a while based off friend’s recommendations and was finally in area and took advantage of the opportunity. Got there just after lunch rush, so by-the-slice selection was limited. Went with cheese, sausage/pepperoni, and pepperoni. Nice crunch to crust with just the right chew, all excellent! Definitely looking forward to stopping back with wife to get a whole pie!
… more
Scott Hegman
One of the best in the greater Cincinnati area. Truly great and goes toe to toe with any pizza I’ve ever tried. The sauce portion is generous, the crust is fantastic, and the cheese is good. I ordered plain cheese as I always do. I ate inside and felt well taken care of. The staff was very friendly and accommodating. They were also very interested in whether the pizza was to my liking or not. I will definitely be back and recommend this to anyone visiting nearby.
… more
Mike Holbrook
Fresh pies, buy by the slice or order the whole thing.
… more
shawn ferguson
Highly recommend Trophy Pizza. Got a half cheese half pep well done. Nice crisp crust/undercarriage. Was very good and neat inside. Definitely will be back.
… more
Mitch
One of the best slices in cincy. The dough is phenomenal, nice and crisp…fresh and no flop at all. Sauce and cheese is great as well.
… more
Erin Hogg
We tried Trophy pizza last night at the recommendation of a ton of people on Chowdown Cincinnati and it did not disappoint! The best pizza we’ve had in a long time! We also tried their Sicilian Grandma pizza by the slice that isn’t pictured and honestly it was to die for. I probably would have eaten a whole pizza of it! Their portion sizes are huge, we have leftovers for days but we’re okay with that haha
… more
Gayle Cabello
The White was the best! The Cheese was amazing. Beautiful crunch on the bottom of the slice in every bite! #STOPHERE
… more
Steve Brown
Called Trophy Pizza at 5:50 to place a timed order for 6:45, so that our family could try the Peppery Pig signature pizza. The girl on the phone said that the timed order was fine. I arrived 10 minutes early (6:35) only to find that my pizza was already boxed up and sitting on top of the pizza oven. Not sure how long it had been sitting there, but needless to say that it was not warm. I paid for the pizza and brought it home. The pizza at least looked good, so we were still excited to to try it. My 11year old daughter isn’t a fan of caramelized onions, so she started picking them off of her slice. While she was picking them off, she asked me why there were bugs on her pizza. I looked down and noticed the slimy bug on her pizza where she just removed the onion. I did call and was refunded after driving back to the store location. This was our second and last visit to Trophy Pizza.
… more
Suchit Patel
Ordered Margherita pizza to go and disappointed in the amount of cheese on the pizza for the price you pay. Also, because of lack of cheese, I got to taste lot more of sauce which was also lacking flavor. Sauce tasted like one of those of the shelf stuff you buy from grocery stores.
… more
… View more