Located in the heart of Short Pump, next to Regal Cinema, sits the best New York Style Pizza in RVA, if you can believe our loyal customers, many who have relocated from New York and New Jersey. That said, we all know what awesome pizza tastes like right? Making our dough and pizza sauce fresh every day, using the finest mozzarella cheese money can buy, and placing all the extra toppings you need to make each bite delicious, will make any pizza lover’s mouth water! Come see what all the fuss is about!! Look forward to seeing you on your next visit! Joel and the Two Guys Team! 11/8/22
Chill hangout providing NYC-style pizza, sandwiches & craft beer on tap, plus TVs & outdoor seating. Based on 377 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
11636 W Broad St, Henrico, VA 23233
Phone: (804) 360-3720
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
mike kolthoff
Best pizza in the area by far! (4.3.stars out of 5). Typical NY style pie: big slices, thin, soft crust, foldable pizza! Better than any chain pizza, and beats any other mom and pop pizza place in a 50 mile radius (I added crushed red peppers and parmesan cheese, they don’t come that way). Service is always good, competitive prices, and good menu selection. A must try for pizza lovers! Please excuse the pictures. I started eating before I remembered to take photos.
… more
Lyssa
Garlic knots are amazing! Got a half spinach half cheese pizza right before going to see the Barbie movie. Very convenient placement in short pump and nice, cozy atmosphere.
… more
Chuck Wingfield
This is THE best pizza in Richmond! And they have great service and a great location. Has been my family’s favorite for over a dozen years! Highly recommend a slice or 2 on the way to Regal cinemas next door!
… more
Howard Smith
Pizza was okay, not the best. We called to place order and it was a little difficult understanding the woman that took our order. When we arrived, we did contactless payment by tapping card on their card payment device. The woman that took our order was wearing a mask and gloves. After making our payment, the woman told us that the pizza would be ready in a few minutes, she went back in the kitchen and then came back near the front desk and pulled our pizza off of the shelf near the front desk. Seems like the pizza was already ready when we arrived.
… more
Rainbow Willard
Great pepperoni pizza and fast friendly service. Excellent find in short pump!
… more
Gillian Palomo
This place has become out go-to pizza place. It reminds us of New York pizza and our kids always ask to go here! We never leave disappointed and always leave with our bellies full! Great pizza, great service and convenient location!
… more
Matt Shirazi
I planned to watch a movie and eat with my son but their computer systems were down. I tried using their app like they suggested and it took me to a completely different store. I went in to ask them about it they basically said we can’t help you get out the way I have other orders to make. I will never give these guys a try and now we are going into a 3 hour movie hungry.
… more
Susan Drew
Ordered delivery for our first time ever eating here. Pizza was ok, decent. Wings are heavily breaded but ok. A calzone advertised as traditional mozzarella and ricotta had maybe a teaspoon of ricotta in it. I ordered an italian sub. Due to still having Covid nose and not great at smelling bad odors, my taste is off too. After 2 bites my partner asked for a bite and he spit it out instantly, rinsing his mouth at the sink. I had thought it tasted a little different but he was horrified saying the meat was clearly spoiled. It didn’t take an hour for my body to prove him right. Sick, nauseous and in bed. I’m not lactose intolerant and I’m that person that blots grease off pizza so it isn’t that. I also worked in restaurant management and hesitate to ever blame food poisoning without some real proof.
… more
Derrick Pendergrass
Always had a good experience but just came from there with 30 min left to close and it was a bad experience kept me waiting 3-5 min while she finished cleaning the oven before she recognized me. Ordered a slice of Pep, she put in the oven and cashed me out. 3 min later I wanted the last piece of cheese, she put it in the oven for 30 sec and took out with the pep and was like “I put both in the oven” asked her to let it sit for a couple minutes and she reiterated, I put both in. They close at 9 mind you and it was 835. They may as well close at 830. There was 2 pep, 1 cheese and garlic knot on one pan when I walked in, thank God I wasn’t trying to be picky, nothing would have been made tonight.
… more
Christina Alaniz
Great place to bring the family. The outdoor area is kid friendly and really nice after a day at the river. We’re not vegetarian but we still loved the food. Our 5, 6, and 7 year old had no problems eating the food. We will definitely be back next time we’re n town!
… more
… View more