Based on 442 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
7516 E Main St, Reynoldsburg, OH 43068
Phone: (614) 322-9587
Website: https://www.tylerspizzeriaandbakery.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
TJ
The pizza is the best in Reynoldsburg. We eat a ton of pizza and everywhere around is so bland or way too sweet. Tyler’s has that charred crust which really adds to the flavor
… more
Robenus Tolesa
Wow just wow! I can’t believe I haven’t been to this place. This place is amazing, the kitchen is very pretty that was my first impression. Had the half chicken and half pepperoni and they were delicious . Definitely only pizza spot I will go to from now on. Thanks for the delicious
… more
Mike Mendola
Terrific food, treats, atmosphere and importantly, fantastic owners. It can be hard to find authentic kind people nowadays, however if that’s what you’re looking for along with great pizza and baked goods, you’ll find it here! Can’t say enough good things!
… more
Robb Ryan
Mom and Pop place, so you already know it’s going to be a plus, then the smell of the shop hits you before walking in. Delicious fresh ingredients and also a bakery! Only had a pizza and the rustic bread, but both were World Class. I’m definitely going back. I just wish I lived closer than Worthington.
… more
Joshua Fisher
The dough is really different than any other pizza place around here that I have experienced, I mean this in a good way. The dough has a great texture and consistency to it. The sauce is a little on the sweeter side which isn’t my preference exactly, but was still enjoyable. Tried a large cheese and a large pepperoni. My only complaint is that the pizza wasn’t cut well, I’m guessing the pizza cutter needs sharpened. The pizza wasn’t cut all the way through on the middle and made a bit of a mess trying to get a slice off. It was also a tad ‘wet’ and kinda soggy like and floppy which makes it harder for children to eat with their hands.
… more
Alex Furst
Tyler’s has the best wood-fired pizza in town and some of the best baked goods I have ever eaten. You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu. The staff are always incredibly friendly.
… more
James Pion
I absolutely love this place! We live in Colorado but when I travel out here to see family this is a must stop spot for any type of baked goods bread pizza croissantsand sweet treats. This place is amazing and Tyler treats it like it’s his home kitchen. If you go to Tyler’s you will not leave disappointed!!!!!
… more
MRBARBQ 1
Stopped in for a little dessert. Had some blueberry bars which were loaded with blueberries, had a lot of an oatmeal taste also. Also got a cinnamon roll which had a nice frosting on top of crusty pastries that was wrapped around some cinnamon. Yummy. This is also a pizza shop. You need to check out both. Great stuff.
… more
Regina Hunter
The first time I tried half Paupers Pie with pep, half 3 Cheese Begeezus. The second time I got a full Pauper’s Pie, add pepperoni, a cheese danish and a chocolate croissant. VERY good pie! The bakery items were TO DIE FOR. Best cheese danish I have EVER had. I will start going here Tuesdays when their large single toppings are 2 for $22.
… more
Alan F
Great Pizzeria and Bakery!
… more
… View more