Upside Pizza Menu – New York, NY

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : New York, NY

’90s-inspired pizza slice specialist created by Roberta’s alum with limited seating. Based on 926 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Upside Pizza 10018

Address:
598 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018

Phone: (646) 484-5244

Website: https://www.upsidepizza.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Thursday 10:30 AM–3 AM
Friday 10:30 AM–3 AM
Saturday 10:30 AM–3 AM
Sunday 10:30 AM–12 AM
Monday 10:30 AM–12 AM
Tuesday 10:30 AM–12 AM
Wednesday 10:30 AM–12 AM

Menu

18′ Pies
Pepperoni Papi Pie $32.00
Cheese Pie $24.00
Fuzzy Dunlop Pie
House Pickled Peppers, Berkshire Pork, Splotched Sauce & Mozzarella – A little kick but nothing to crazy on the spice scale. A truly magnificent slice.
$32.00
Falcowitz Pie $32.00
Tomato Pie (Vegan) $18.00
50/50 $30.00
Spicy Vodka $32.00
Sicilian Pies
Upside Pep $40.00
Upside Don $32.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Samad Kadri
The sourdough crust adds an awesome texture. They use high quality sauces and cheese. When it’s good, it my favorite slice in NYC.

… more

Taylor Snipes
Had a softball game nearby and stopped by for a quick slice after. Went with the classic pepperoni slice and it was delicious. It was absolutely huge and the pepperonis were cooked perfectly to where they had the cups. The crust was just the right crisp to my liking and it wasn’t too greasy. I need to go back and try some of the other varieties because they have a bunch.

… more

Ivette Ruelle
Very fast service, really good NY style pizza. It was very hard to get a side of sauce, I love to dip it in sauce. They didn’t want to give me the sauce even though I said that I would pay extra.

… more

Jake Williams
Truly a great pizza place. Not too far from Times Square, offering authentic New York pizza by the slice. Each slice costing $5. We went back for more after our first slices of the pepperoni, great with any of the herbs or chilli flakes they offer in house. The staff are friendly and more then happy to help with questions or issues, our order came with a coke but we ordered a lemonade, they switched it out without any stress. Definitely recommend for a slice of New York pizza! fyi they do not have any seating options, only tables.

… more

keith k
great spot for a quick delicious bit of pizza and more. Watch the world go by at the bar counter.

… more

Brian Ferdman
Hearty, solid slices are served quickly in this postage stamp-sized store. The “spicy” sausage isn’t spicy, but they probably have to cater to tourist palates. Nevertheless, it’s flavorful pizza and the best slice option in the area. The only drawback is trying to eat your slice while sharing one of two tiny sidewalk high-top tables with everyone else standing around doing the same thing.

… more

Sarah Thompson
Great slices of pizza… much better than a place on the same street a few down. I don’t know how that one has great reviews… we tried this after that other place and it was great. Crunchy -yet chewy, thin, and tasty. Quick service, cheap eats and one the taste was great. Much appreciated after the long exhausting days!

… more

Greg Williams
Crispy and tender crust,

… more

Daniel Pincus
First of all, they use sourdough, which is why it seems to go down so easily. Tasty. Crispy on the bottom, which is one of my criteria for truly great pizza. Price – great. Expert pizza artisans at work with a great recipe. You won’t regret coming here. Only one standing table right now. They deserve your business.

… more

Ananya Gupta
Vegetarian review: The Sicilian pizza here is based on a sourdough base and it is sooo tasty! Fear not – even though the bread looks thick it is extremely soft and fluffy with so much sauce on it to give it flavor and wetness.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions