No-frills Italian longtimer with a yellow awning serving brick-oven pizzas, salads, subs & pasta. Based on 139 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
2197 Murray Hill Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106
Phone: (216) 795-0463
Website: http://valentinospizzacleveland.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Alex Zaddach
My favorite pizza in Cleveland. This is still American-style pizza – if you’re looking for thin crust Neapolitan style cooked at 1000 degrees, head elsewhere. But this is miles better than any chain pizza place. Excellent crust with a good balance of crispiness and chewiness with just a little bit of char on the bottom from being cooked in a real oven rather than a conveyor belt. Sauce and toppings are all high quality.
… more
Pat Clarke
Amazing locally owned pizza shop. Great owners , great food.. you HAVE to try the salad dressing . House made by the wife, fantastic. I always ask for extra. The pizza is out of this world. You can watch Mike make it from scratch. Good people, GREAT food. Subs pizza pasta salads, all amazing.
… more
Jakob Rubin
When it’s good, it’s pretty good, but recently they’ve been putting less and less cheese on their pizzas. It’s sad, because they have one of the best pizza sauces (at least for a takeout) in Little Italy, but I shouldn’t need to specify extra cheese to get more than a small handful. Be prepared to pay extra for your cheese, making this a more expensive pizza than its competitors.
… more
Karla Hanley
Fresh and friendly! !! Ordered the white artichoke with black olives and it was the best pizza ever. Ordered a regular red sauce with pepperoni and Canadian bacon and my kids raved over it!!!! Very good! Forgot to say, I even ate the crust!!! I never eat the crust! Ever!
… more
Ryan Alexander
Average food with sub-par service. You are better off going across the street to La Pizzeria or any one of the dozens of Italian restaurants in Little Italy. I made an online order at 9pm and it was supposed to be ready at 9:45. I showed up at Valentino’s at 9:30 and it was closed. Website said they were open until 10 allowed me to place an order. I am looking forward to taking my business elsewhere the next time I am eating in Little Italy and I strongly recommend that you do the same!
… more
Ryan Eckstein
Great pizza and great location for pizza in Cleveland, Little Italy. Everytime I come home to Cleveland to visit i try to grab a pie from here. The staff is friendly and the prices are reasonable given that’s its a small mom and pop enterprise that has been in business for quite some time.
… more
Cory Roberts
Valentino’s is my favorite pizza place in Little Italy. They use quality ingredients; the cheese and tomatoes are fresh and taste great. The owner is very nice too, one of the times I went there he gave me a free slice of pizza while I was waiting for my pizza. The subs there are also good, and a good value too. Their large subs are good enough for two meals and are under $8. All in all, good service, and good food. Give it a try, you won’t be disappointed.
… more
Ben Guengerich
Best pizza in town! There’s something special about the crust and the tomato sauce that I haven’t tasted anywhere else. The eggplant parmesan dinner is also an excellent choice. I highly recommend checking out Valentino’s if you’re in the area.
… more
John Huss
There is a debate in our house over which pizza is better: Valentino’s or Marotta’s. I am in the Valentino’s camp. I would describe the tomato sauce as “tangy.” If to you, that equals acidic, you may not like their pizza. But the crust is crisp, and the mozzarella is good, overall the pizza has a somewhat smoky flavor, and I like the tangy sauce. I have never once had bad service there, and a large cheese pizza costs $9, which I think is quite reasonable. Mike, the owner, is friendly, and in fact once simply gave me two pizzas because their credit card reader was down. When we have visitors in from out of town, and order out for pizza, it is always Valentino’s, and they always like it.
… more
Craig Bourne
A frequent first choice of my beloved for our lunch together on a workday. Be it on their patio in season, or their tasty takeout– the food is great, the workers friendly, and the cost does not break the bank. In fact, I’ll head there as soon as I send this review to pick up our lunch for today: white pizza with herself’s favorite toppings. Her review? “Yum!!?
… more
… View more