Water St. Cafe Menu – Geneva, NY

Type : Diner

Location : Geneva, NY

Easygoing local cafe for hearty American breakfast & lunch plates such as eggs, burgers & coffee. Based on 678 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Water St. Cafe 14456

Address:
467 S Exchange St, Geneva, NY 14456

Phone: (315) 789-2560

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 6 AM–2 PM
Wednesday 6 AM–2 PM
Thursday 6 AM–2 PM
Friday 6 AM–2 PM
Saturday 6 AM–1 PM
Sunday 6 AM–1 PM
Monday 6 AM–2 PM

Menu

Water St. Breakfast Favorites
Garbage Plate
Scrambled Eggs, Hash, Homefries & Toast Topped with Sausage Gravy
(50 Cent Container Charge Included in price with All To-Gos)		 $11.75
Statesman Platter
2 Eggs, 2 Slices of French Toast, 2 Strips of Bacon & Homefries.
(50 Cent Container Charge Included in price with All To-Gos)		 $10.40
Heron Platter
1 Egg, 1 piece of French Toast, 1 Strip of Bacon, 1/2 order of Homefries		 $7.65
Corn Beef Hash, Eggs &Toast
Corn Beef Hash, 2 Eggs & Toast		 $9.58
Frittata
Eggs mixed with Homefries, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Carrots, Green Beans, Cauliflower, Pepperoni, Ham, Italian & Breakfast Sausage, with Toast		 $11.50
1/2 Frittata
Half Order of: Eggs mixed with Homefries, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Carrots, Green Beans, Cauliflower, Pepperoni, Ham, Italian & Breakfast Sausage, with Toast		 $9.30
Sausage Biscuits & Gravy
Fresh Baked Biscuits, covered in Homemade Sausage Gravy,		 $8.20
1/2 Order Sausage Biscuits & Gravy
1 Fresh Baked Biscuit, Covered in Sausage Gravy		 $6.55
Steak & Eggs
Steak, 2 Eggs, Home fries & Toast.
(50 Cent Container Fee Included in pricing for all To-Gos)		 $17.00
T-Shirts “It’s Worth the Wait”
Black “It’s Worth The Wait” T-Shirts
Black T-Shirt “It’s Worth the Wait” Design 		$22.00
Pink “It’s Worth The Wait” T-Shirts $22.00
Blue “It’s Worth The Wait” T-Shirt $22.00
Hoodies “It’s Worth the Wait” Design
Black Hoodies “It’s Worth The Wait Design”
“It’s Worth the Wait” Hoodies 		$34.00
Blue Hoodies “It’s Worth The Wait”
Blue, it’s worth the wait Hoodie		 $34.00
Pink “It’s Worth The Wait” Hoodie
Pink Hoodie “it’s worth the wait” Hoodie		 $34.00
Early Bird Specials
#1
2 Eggs, Homefries, & Toast		 $6.55
#2
2 Eggs, Homefries, (Ham, Bacon or Sausage) & Toast		 $9.85
#3
Homestyle: Scrambled Eggs mixed with Homefries & Toast		 $8.95
#4
2 Eggs, Choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage Patties/Links & Toast		 $9.03
1 Egg & Toast $3.50
2 Egg & Toast $4.00
Weekly Breakfast Specials
French Toast Breakfast Sandwich
Two pieces of French Toast, Egg, Cheese and choice of Meat: Bacon or Sausage. Served with Homefries.		 $12.50
Loaded Breakfast Fries
Battered Fries, Topped with 2 eggs, Bacon and Cheddar Cheese.
Add more Meats or Veggies in the Modifications. If you want double Bacon, just choose Bacon under “Basic Meat Choices”		 $13.15
French Toast Roll Ups
3 Sausage links, wrapped in 3 pieces of French Toast, with Homefries on the side. 		$12.33
The Big Garry
In Memory of Garry H. 3 Over Easy Eggs, 2 Sausage Patties, Homefries, and 3 piece of Italian Toast.
No Substitutions.		 $13.65
Buffalo Chicken Omelette
Omelette stuffed with Shredded Buffalo Chicken and Blue Cheese crumbles. With Homefries & Toast 		$11.50
Country Benedict
Open faced Biscuit Sandwich, 2 Eggs, 2 Sausage Patties, and American Cheese, with Homefries, All Smothered in Sausage Gravy. 		$13.25
Breakfast Sandwiches
Build Your Own Breakfast Sandwich
1 Egg Included		 $2.75
Specialty Omelettes
Cheese Omelette
(American, Cheddar, Swiss or Provolone)		 $7.65
Meat Lovers
Ham, Bacon, Sausage & Cheese		 $12.60
Northern
Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers & Feta Cheese		 $11.78
Western
Peppers, Onions, Ham & Cheese		 $11.50
Southwestern
Hot Peppers, Sausage, Avocado & Cheddar Cheese		 $11.78
Denver
Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Ham & Cheese		 $11.78
Veggie
Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Spinach, Cheese		 $11.50
Sloppy
Ham/Sausage/Bacon OR Pepperoni, & Cheese		 $10.40
Water Street Omelette
Roasted Red Peppers & Provolone Cheese		 $10.40
Farmers
Sausage, Cheese, Homefries, Topped with Sausage Gravy		 $12.60
Hash Lovers
Corn Beef Hash & Cheese		 $11.50
Omelette Bar Creations
3 Egg Omelette
Comes with Toasts
Add a side of Homefries for $3.25
Make with Egg Whites for $2.27		 $5.45
2 Egg Omelette
Comes with Toasts
Add a side of Homefries for $1.50
Make with Egg Whites for $1.00		 $4.90
Breakfast Burritos
Denver Burrito
Scrambled eggs, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Ham & Cheese.		 $11.78
Farmer’s Burrito
Scrambled Eggs, Cheese, Sausage, and Homefries all stuffed into a Burrito, and Smothered in Sausage Gravy		 $12.60
Northern Burrito
Scrambled Eggs, Spinach, Roasted Red, Peppers & Feta Cheese.		 $11.78
Meat Lover’s Burrito
BIGGER & BETTER, Scrambled Eggs, Sausage, Ham, Bacon & Cheese. 		$17.60
South Western Burrito
Scrambled Eggs, Hot Peppers, Sausage, Avocado & Cheddar Cheese.		 $11.78
Hash Lovers Burrito
Scrambled Eggs, Corn Beef Hash, and Cheese. 		$11.50
Western Burrito
Scrambled eggs, Peppers, Onions and Ham 		$11.50
Veggie Lover Burrito
Scrambled Eggs, Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms, Spinach & Cheese.		 $11.50
Build Your Own Burrito
Build Your Own Breakfast Burrito.		 $5.50
Pancakes
Single Pancake $4.75
Short Stack Of Pancakes $6.75
Full Stack Of Pancakes $10.25
Specialty Pancakes
Short Stack Specialty Pancakes
Short Stack (2) Specialty Pancakes		 $8.80
Single Specialty Pancake $5.65
Full Stack Specialty Pancakes
Full Stack (3) Specialty Pancakes		 $12.50
French Toast
Full Stack French Toast
Full Stack (3) French Toast		 $6.25
Short Stack French Toast
Short Stack (2) French Toast		 $5.73
Single French Toast $2.75
Specialty French Toast
Specialty FT Single
1 Slice		 $4.35
Specialty FT Short Stack
2 Slices		 $7.93
Specialty FT Full Stack
3 Slices		 $9.58
A La Carte Breakfast
Homefries
Side plate of Homefries		 $3.00
Oatmeal Cup
Cup of fresh made Oatmeal, to order.		 $3.50
Oatmeal Bowl
Bowl of fresh made Oatmeal, to order.		 $3.75
Avocado Add To Toast $3.80
Muffins
Water St. Baked in House Muffins		 $4.08
Melon
Sliced Cantaloupe		 $2.75
Whole Banana $1.25
Side Of Avocado
Side of sliced Avocado		 $3.30
White/Wheat Toast
Side of Toast, Buttered		 $1.30
English Muffin
English Muffin, buttered		 $3.25
Rye Toast
Buttered		 $3.25
Italian Toast
Buttered		 $3.25
Sour Dough Toast
Home Baked Fresh In House
Buttered		 $3.80
Raisin Toast
Fresh Home Baked Raisin Bread made in House
Buttered		 $3.80
Bagel
Toasted Bagel with butter		 $3.25
Cream Cheese
Can be added to any menu item		 $1.00
Sour Cream
Can be added to any menu item		 $1.00
Salsa
Can be added to any menu item		 $1.00
Add An Egg $1.65
Breakfast Meat Choices
Bacon $5.75
Ham Steak $5.75
Sausage Links $5.75
Sausage Patties $5.75
Fresh Pork Sausage
Made Fresh in house, with Water St. Seasoning recipe.		 $6.25
Fresh Turkey Sausage $6.25
Turkey Bacon $6.25
Corn Beef Hash
Side of our Corn Beef Hash		 $6.25
Sausage Gravy $4.35
Signature Burgers
Classic Burger
with Fries		 $8.20
Mozzie Burger
1 (6oz Patty), American Cheese, Topped with 2 Mozzie Styx & Red Sauce and Parmesan Cheese. Served with Fries.		 $14.00
Whiskey Burger
Bacon, Onion, American Cheese & Whiskey Sauce, Comes with Fries		 $12.60
Rodeo Burger
Bacon, Onion Rings, American Cheese, BBQ Sauce, Comes with Fries		 $12.60
Southwest Burger
Avocado, Cheddar, Hot Peppers & Siracha Mayo. Comes with Fries		 $12.60
Cajun Burger
Cajun Seasoned Beef, Bacon & Crumbly Blue Cheese. Comes with Fries		 $12.60
Breakfast Burger
Over Easy Egg, Bacon, American Cheese. Comes with Fries.		 $12.88
Quickie Cheese Burger
Cheeseburger & Fries with Gravy All Over		 $12.60
Rueben Burger
Swiss, Sauerkraut, Corn Beef & Thousand Island Dressing. Comes with Fries.		 $12.60
California Burger
Avocado, Tomato, Provolone, Ranch Dressing, made with a Meatless Burger Patty. Comes with Fries.		 $13.70
Patty Melt
Grilled Rye Bread, 6oz Burger, Swiss Cheese & Grilled Onions. With Fries 		$12.60
Breakfast Quickie Burger
Bacon Cheese Burger, with a Over Easy Egg, and Sausage Gravy On Top. Comes with Fries		 $15.08
Flying Rodeo Burger
6oz Beef Patty, Cheese, Bacon, Fried Onion Ring, topped with BBQ Chicken Tenders. 		$14.80
Flying Buffalo Burger
Buffalo Wing Sauce Dipped Chicken Tender on top of a Burger, with Blue Cheese Crumbles and a side of Blue Cheese or Ranch dressing. Served with Fries.		 $14.80
Sandwiches
Western Egg
Scrambled Egg, Ham, Peppers & Onions, American Cheese on Toasted White Bread		 $7.50
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Tenders dipped in Buffalo Sauce, with American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion on a Grilled Kaiser Roll
**Try a Flavor Flip, with BBQ Sauce**		 $12.60
Cafe Chicken
Roasted Red Peppers, Provolone, with Grilled Chicken on a Grilled Kaiser Roll		 $11.23
Chicken Bacon Ranch
Bacon, Swiss & Ranch, with Grilled Chicken on a Grilled Kaiser Roll		 $11.50
Rueben
Turkey OR Corn Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss, Thousand Island on Grilled Rye		 $11.50
CLASSIC CLUB
Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon, Mayo, Cheese, with your Choice of Meat. Served with Fries		 $12.60
HOT TURKEY
Hot Turkey, Fries or Mash & Gravy Over All		 $10.95
Grilled Veggie
*Vegetarian* Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers, Mushrooms, Swiss on Grilled Italian Toast		 $10.40
Garden Wrap
Mixed Greens, Spinach, Roasted Red Peppers, Avocado and Feta Cheese. With Choice Dressing. 		$10.95
Zesty Crispy Bacon Chix Sandwich
Crispy Chicken Tenders, Bacon, American Cheese, Onion Rings and Zesty Sauce. Served with a Side of Fries		 $12.60
BLT
Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo on Italian Toast		 $10.95
Sandwich Maker
Create Your Own Sandwich Maker
Includes Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo or Mustard. Chips & Pickles		 $9.00
Weekly Lunch Specials
Fish Fry
Battered Fried Fish, on a sub roll served with French Fries, Apple Sauce, and Tartar Sauce.		 $12.60
Grilled Cheeses & Melts
Grilled Cheese
American Cheese grilled between white bread.		 $4.65
Grilled Cheese Plus
American Cheese, PLUS Bacon OR Ham, grilled between white bread.		 $7.65
Make Your Own Melt
Choose Your Bread, Cheese & Filling
ALL Melts Include Bacon, Tomato on Grilled Bread with Chips & Pickles		 $10.95
Grilled Cheese & Tomato
American Cheese & Tomato grilled between white bread.		 $7.10
Signature Salads
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Chicken Fingers tossed in Buffalo Sauce, Crumbly Blue Cheese, over Mixed Greens		 $12.60
Chicken Avocado
Grilled Chicken, Avocado, Candied Walnuts, Feta Cheese, Over mixed Greens & Choice of Dressing		 $12.60
Chef Salad
Ham, Turkey, American Cheese, Hard Boiled Egg, over mixed Greens		 $12.60
Cowboy Salad
Grilled Steak, Cheddar Cheese, Sunflower Seeds, over Mixed Greens		 $17.00
Side Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Onion & Pepperoni, over Mixed Greens		 $6.00
Cowgirl Salad
Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Hard boiled Egg, Over Mixed Greens with Choice Dressing		 $12.60
Soups
Bowl Of Soup
Comes with Saltine Crackers, 16 oz To-Go Cup		 $5.00
Cup Of Soup
Comes with Saltine Crackers
12 oz To-Go Cup		 $4.50
New England Clam Chowder
**FRIDAYS ONLY** Made from Scratch. Our Owner James Brown’s Famous New England Clam Chowder. *item has bacon*		 $5.20
Sides, Sauces, & Gravy
Fries $4.08
Onion Rings $5.00
Mozzie Styx $5.75
Chicken Fingers
3 Tenders		 $7.80
Mac Salad $3.10
Apple Sauce $3.10
Sauce Sides
Love Condiments As Much as We Do?		 $0.95
Brown Gravy
Side cup of Brown Gravy		 $2.30
Beverages
Coffee
16oz To-Go Cup		 $2.75
Hot Tea
16 oz To-Go Cup		 $2.75
Cappuccino
12oz To-Go Cup		 $3.30
Hot Chocolate
12oz To-Go Cup		 $3.30
Juices
12oz To-Go Cup		 $4.40
Milk
12oz To-Go Cup		 $2.75
Chocolate Milk
12oz To-Go Cup		 $3.60
Sodas
16oz To-Go Cup		 $3.25
Raspberry Ice Tea
Brisk Raspberry Ice Tea		 $3.65
English Toffee Cappuccino

$3.00
Sweets & Treats
Chocolate Chip Cookie
House Fresh Baked Chocolate Chip Cookies		 $1.80
Peanut Butter Cookies
House Fresh Baked Peanutbutter Cookies with Peanutbutter Chips		 $1.80
Cinnamon Roll
Fresh Baked, and grilled Cinnamon Roll topped, with sugar glaze.		 $4.00
Gluten Free
GLUTEN FREE Pancakes
Gluten Free		 $6.50
GLUTEN FREE French Toast
Gluten Free		 $4.35
GLUTEN FREE Muffin $4.90
Gluten Free White Toast
Gluten Free White toast, add to any meal for $2.50		 $3.60
Make My Meal Gluten Free
Must be selected for each meal, you desire to be made gluten free.		 $3.75
Gluten Free Whole Grain Toast
Gluten Free Whole Grain Toast, add to any meal for $2.50		 $3.25
Kids Menu
Kids Oatmeal
Fresh made Oatmeal, and a side of Apple Sauce.		 $3.50
Kids Burger Or Hot Dog
Choose a Burger or a Hot Dog. Served with Chips		 $5.50
Kids Chicken Fingers
2 Chicken Fingers & Chips		 $5.20
Kids Grilled Cheese
Grilled Cheese on White Bread, served with Chips.		 $4.50
Mickey Pancake
House Pancake, made in a Mickey Mouse Shape!		 $4.25
Kids French Toast
2 pieces of French Toast		 $4.25
Kids PB & J
Classic Peanut butter & Jelly. Served with Chips		 $2.90
Kids Scrambled Eggs & Toast
2 Eggs Scrambled & Toast		 $4.25

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Jeff Seamans
Food was fantastic, the staff was quick and very friendly. I had The Statesman Breakfast. You get bacon, eggs, potatoes, and French toast and it was really good. The best part of all is that it was extremely cheap. Definitely recommend.

… more

Johanna Houseknecht
Stopped in during a staycation after reading some great reviews.

… more

Amy Alexander
Excellent food, great service, and a whole lot of community.

… more

Forrest Black
The food was priced well and the service was fantastic! It’s a little tight when it’s full but overall it’s a fantastic place to snag breakfast

… more

Dan Sauder
This place was one of our best discoveries on our recent trip to the Finger Lakes. An absolute delight to eat there we went back several times. If you like breakfast this is the place for you! And Sarah and Lexi, our servers, were an absolute joy to talk with and get to know. I highly recommend!

… more

Dan Hess
Food was great, servers were excellent, cooks were very efficient! I had the Cajun burger (delicious), also the sausage patties are top-tier. Coffee was the perfect icing on the cake! Well worth the short wait to get a table.

… more

Derek Bryant
Had the #2 breakfast and everything was great. Server was quick and polite, and the food was cooked fast and tasted great. We were able to get in and out super fast.

… more

Justin Rogers-Cooper
Lovely breakfast here with delicious plates and kind service.

… more

C Cab
I ALWAYS get breakfast but decided to try lunch (it was lunch time) sooooo good!! They have cool mugs that you can buy! Corned beef hamburger I substituted onion rings (I can not have FF) also unfortunately I can not have lettuce, tomatoes so I had mine with mayo but I’m sure with lettuce and tomatoes would have been a bit better but just as I had it was AWSOME!!

… more

Talisha Doyle
Our waitress was so nice. My class enjoyed her. She even took a last day of school photo for us. The food was amazing great atmosphere. I love the outside sitting area. I will be returning.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch