Based on 197 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2405 William St, Buffalo, NY 14206
Phone: (716) 893-0408
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
John Szczygiel
Take a look at the New York Pizza pictures I posted. If your looking for legit, New York, grease dripping, slice folding Pizza, this it the best in the the area! I’m 6’1″ and my hand isn’t small.
… more
M G
If you like overpaying for toppings and not getting any toppings on your pizza..this is your place. $1.50 for mushrooms and each slice had 3 tiny slivers of mushrooms. Theres too many pizza spots to settle for that.
… more
Lanique Ruffin
I’m a little skeptical about trying new pizza but I decided to give them a try. I have no regrets. Their pizza is seasoned to perfection with the perfect amount of cheese and sauce. Oh, and their wings, they’re the best I’ve had in a while. My family and I will definitely be going back.
… more
Laurie Vegas
Bought a sheet pizza and a bucket of mild wings. Pizza box had so much grease on top from wings it seeped through the pizza box as well. I called the owner and apparently this is normal i should get the mild sauce on the side. Pizza wasnt bad or the wings once u got past the grease.
… more
Kelsey Regan
Great pizza! We work next door (I own Mane Haus salon) they have great lunch options for us. The salads are huge! We love the cheesecake too. Thanks guys! Just do a gluten-free crust for meeee.
… more
Tony Stackpole
This place is horrible, pizza and wings delivered 2 hours late, it was cold, wings weren’t even right, the pizza sauce was just tomato sauce no flavor at all. Called to see where order was and they hung up on my wife. They wouldn’t cancel order still charged me. And wouldn’t issue refund. HORRIBLE HORRIBLE SERVICE. OLD.OWNERS WERE WONDERFUL!!! These NEW owners ARE DISGUSTING AND SHOULDNT OWN A COMPANY.
… more
Sophiaplus Adgate
Excellent everything Great prices,variety . Great pizza always done perfect. Absolutely no complaints. My new to go to spot. Large menu need to try more.
… more
William Donohue
The service here is terrible, I called to order two subs and while ordering the man on the phone was very abrupt and unfriendly. He did not let me finish my sentence but I went through with the order anyway because I wanted to give him a chance. While I was on my way to pick it up he called me back twice from a random number and when I answered he yelled in my ear that my food was ready. I told him to keep the food to which he replied that I’m an a-hole. So I ordered from Poplar Pizza down the street. I hope he was just having a bad day, but I cannot give this business my money. Terrible service!!!
… more
Geraldine O’Sullivan
Absolutely the best antipasti salad! The meats and cheese were plentiful, the iceberg lettuce crisp. A refreshing way to finish a slice of pizza. I would highly recommend the dish.
… more
Kristie Kotecki
I heard good things about this place so I was super excited to try it. The gentleman who took my order was polite but in the middle of my order he put the phone down to take another persons order without saying anything to me to hold. The phone was set down and I heard everything on the other end. The food took an HOUR and 45 minutes to be delivered. My food was then cold when it arrived. The pizza had barely any toppings and barely any cheese. The bread on my sub was hard like it was stale. I usually do second chances for places but I won’t be returning.
… more
… View more