Based on 853 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
7639 Southeastern Ave Suite B, Indianapolis, IN 46239
Phone: (317) 862-2960
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
9 AM–12 PM, 4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 9 AM–12 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 9 AM–12 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–12 PM, 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–12 PM, 3–10 PM |
| Saturday | 3–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mrs. Todd Jr
Yalllll!!! I will NOT EAT ANYONES PIZZA AGAINNNN!! this is absolutely xtrordinaryy pizza. We tried it for the first time at our nephews’ open house. Pizza should be full of meat, cheese and sauce and this did not disappoint. My favorite part is that it re- heats good and still tastes great as left overs! I’m hooked!! Nomore of the other guys. Wish they come to Avon but until then, we will continue to drive 40 minutes to get this magnificent pizza!
… more
Crystal Jennett
Ordered a pizza here today and ended up with a seat full of grease! In my new car! We called and tried to just tell them the pizza was extremely greasy and the employees were SUPER RUDE about it! Tried to say it was from the vegetables on the pizza.. WE DID NOT HAVE VEGETABLES ON OUR PIZZA! So if you like extremely greasy pizza this is your spot! Don’t think they care.. they don’t! I will not go back here again! If I could give zero stars I would!
… more
Jeffery Coomer
Insanely delicious and loaded to the top! When people ask about the best pizza in the city people better put some respect on their name
… more
Eric V McHenry Sr
We came from Noblesville to get pizza that was recommended from our camping group on Facebook. The website said they closed at 10. They changed the hours, and we tried constantly called for 45 minutes. and they took the phone off the hook. The lady was extremely rude. She said they were closed and it was in the menu, and I told her that they needed to change the website. Never again will I step foot in this place again. If they are that rude and can’t change the website, then they don’t deserve my business. I will let my camping recommendation know how horrible customer service is and how rude they are, and it is not worth my time. Can’t answer the phones or put on a voice mail stating they are closed?. Poorly managed!! Not all lost, though. We ended up at a real pizza shop on Midhoeffer called Just Pizza, and their customer service was awesome. and the pizza was great! So, not all was lost!!
… more
Ada Gray
This may be the best pizza I have ever had! Generous, thick toppings, but still good amount of sauce, and excellent seasonings. My husband and myself got the large pizza first time ordering and we thought the box weighed 10 lbs. when carrying out to our vehicle.
… more
Indy Amanda
Even delicious on day 3! I just reheated the last bit of my leftovers, and it tasted just like the first day. Happy to know that they are maintaining the same delicious, piled-high pizza while everyone else is focused on cutting costs!
… more
Sandy Ryan
I ordered for delivery. The pizza is AMAZING! Best I’ve had since my last trip to Chicago and Gino’s Pizza. I’m stuffed after 1 piece!
… more
Kyle Miller
Came here a half hour before they were supposed to close, and they had the open sign on and another car was there getting food, but right as we were coming up a girl ran to the door and turned the open sign off. So we tried to call and the girl said sorry we are closed and hung up. So needless to say we left and thankfully ended up at Old Bethel Ordinary Pizza, which ended up being fantastic pizza and service!
… more
Daniel Lusk
We had a 5-star experience. We were driving thru the area and looked up food places and gave it a try. They do not have dining in though. We did place an order at the counter and waited in the car. They have a speaker and called out our name. We got 2 of the personal pizzas and loved them. I actually made two meals out of it. So many toppings which were great and the breadsticks were awesome! The wait time was not long and we would go back.
… more
Connie Lee
I ordered a pizza from Xtrordinary Pizza and picked it up on my way home from work. I was tempted to grabbed a slice for the drive back home, but decided to be patient. I swear it was worth waiting till I got home to fully enjoy all of this deliciousness! Their pizzas are full of flavor and was worth the drive. Their customer service was pretty good too. This is one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time!
… more
… View more