We’re Y-Not Pizza, and we’ve been a local pizza restaurant here in New Palestine, IN, since 2004. We believe in great food and excellent service, offering sandwiches, appetizers, and pizza. We started this business to provide our community with an affordable and convenient hometown restaurant. We’re looking forward to growing our business to continue to serve New Palestine and the surrounding areas. We’d like to personally invite you to stop in today for pizza, wings, nachos, fries, stromboli, burgers, and so much more!
Based on 159 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
45 E Main St, New Palestine, IN 46163
Phone: (317) 861-5225
Website: https://ynotpizzanp.com/
Hours
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
2:30–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Thursday | 2:30–10 PM |
| Friday | 2:30 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 2:30 PM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Scott Folck
I live in walking distance, I asked for one simple request. No onions.. they put onions on the sandwich I ordered. So I walked there, and tipped.. which is crazy on my end. And they did apologize.. which is great.. but they lied and told me they had got super busy in the 20 minutes that I ordered the sandwich. I can literally see this place from my back porch. And they decided to lie instead of owning up to a mistake or making it better. I gotta say, that was disappointing. Very disappointing. Hopefully management can learn how to take an order, or simply make a customer (that lives basically next door) a little more satisfied. What a waste of $17.. can’t believe I threw them a tip. They just lost a customer. I mean they couldn’t even communicate when they switched the phone to the manager. Smh.. wow. Oh, I almost forgot jalapenos are included upon request, of course they forgot that. And don’t get nachos. Apparently they have a cheese shortage. What an incompetent place. And yes, I’m going to complain a whole $17 worth.. maybe they digest this post better than the food I ate. I threw it away half way through. Again..wow.
… more
Seth R
Man the pizza is amazing the service though always sucks. And the building itself is like falling apart in places.
… more
Rick Farmer
This has the feel of a little mom & pop hole in the wall that seems to cater to local regulars. It looked old and tired. Our marginal food was served in paper lined plastic baskets, justified by somewhat reasonable prices.
… more
Adam Smith
Kitchen was closing, pulled in starving after a long work day in the cold rain. Manager opened the grill back up to make sure we didn’t go home hungry. Can’t tell you how much that means and I want others to know this small town pizza joint is the place to go. 5 out of 5!!!!
… more
Eon.001
Can’t get a simple pizza order right and waited 30 mins to call and tell us they didn’t have our order details. We told them again and when we got our pizza it was burned to a crisp and poorly made. Chicken bacon ranch? I’d say burned bacon ranch.
… more
Colton Alexander
Took down my last one because owner wanted to leave a reply that is not true we were treated awfully at the bar by a female bartender he said we were overly intoxicated but we had a few beers across the street rest of our party was served but not us. Owner if you want to know what really happened not ur disrespectful employees version reach out to me directly she had no idea how many drinks we had across the street we showed no signs of being overly intoxicated we sat in the back and had quiet conversation she offered to serve us after we showed Id but we refused because we were upset with the way she talked to us. 20 minutes later our friend offered to buy us a drink to cheer us up and she refused to serve then don’t claim to know anything about that night she was rude and lost you business! upon us walking out everyone knew we had done nothing wrong we were quiet and sober by the point of her refusing to serve
… more
Paul Warner
Megan was our beer tender, was very nice.
… more
Robert brown
Never answer the phone. Call someone else.
… more
kerstin paulson
Fresh hot soooo good! Looks like they’re making some changes also hope they stay open for much longer
… more
John N
Walked in and ordered a pizza and breadsticks. There is a Pac Man machine that plays for free in the dining room area. There is a bar through the doorways, but, I just waited for my food. Quick service and free Pacman, I had fun.
… more
… View more