Based on 25 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 5.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1045 St Gregory St, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: (513) 381-1888
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 1–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ray Mills Media
Excellent pizza in the heart of Mt. Adams in Cincinnati. Small & cozy with only four two-person tables and about eight stools at a bar. The garlic knots were so good with the rich garlic butter sauce. The pizza came out hot and tasted so good. Great first stop on our two days in Cincy.
… more
Muffy Baines
I have visited 2 weeks in a row! This place is craveable! The Shiesty is better than it looks. There is a simple complexity to it, that keeps drawing you in for another bite. The “Mom” of the restaurant was so sweet and friendly! I can’t wait to go back!
… more
A J
We went on opening day Friday 4/20 and the pizza was so delicious! We walked in and ordered a pizza togo and it came out very quickly. We had high hopes and they exceeded our expectations. We ordered The Shiesty and it was cooked perfectly. Love the hot honey! We will be back many times to try more. Definitely recommend!
… more
Bryant McDonnell
It’s delish!!! 10” is the perfect diameter pizza for one person!!! Great vibes and the staff members are great.
… more
Connor Catalano
Thoroughly enjoyed The Sheisty. Small relaxed place. Has bar seating for 5 and a couple small tables for 2. Definitely mostly a carryout place but you can eat in if you get there before it fills up. Pizza was very good. It could be a bit crispier on the bottom just to firm up the middle a bit. Was a bit droopy but very good. Has a nice chew to the crust that reminded me of Dewey’s in a way (had similar blisters and taste/ texture) but this is more NY style. Hope they do good business but also kinda hope they don’t blow up so I can keep getting in there easy.
… more
Irwin Gill
Great thin crust style pizza with ample amount of toppings. Inside of restaurant has nice decor and feels welcoming, just how a neighborhood pizza shop should feel like. Happy that it’s walking distance from our place and extra happy that the food tastes great! Expect to see us back multiple times per month.
… more
Naomi Manaster
Such good pizza!!! Went for the first time today and got a Bianca (and added sausage), it was such good pizza!!! Also got cannolis – so delicious. So happy to have this place in Mt. Adam’s and definitely will be back.
… more
Nicklaus Roach
Wonderful pizza, loved the black and white cookie too! Staff were also kind and personable, and the pizza was ready right on time! Really happy to have a good pizza place in Mount Adams, will definitely be a regular visit on the weekends!
… more
Toria Beagle
LOVE the place! Such great atmosphere and pizza. LOVE the freshness of the ingredients. My favorite was the Bianca pizza and garlic knots. We’ll definitely be back!
… more
Ben Shutters
ABSOLUTLEY AMAZING!!!
… more
… View more