Your Pie Pizza Restaurant of St. Augustine uses hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, homemade pizza sauces and salad dressings. We offer vegan pizza, vegetarian pizza, gluten-free pizza, keto-friendly pizza, as well as traditional pizzas & pasta. Our pizza restaurant of Palencia FL serves our customers’ craft series favorites, or you can build your own personal pizza or large pizza with free toppings. Try our Italian-inspired gelato! Order now for pizza delivery or carryout. You can also dine-in with us in the St. Augustine neighborhood. We are open for lunch and dinner. If you are looking for a delicious brick-oven pizza restaurant that serves craft beer and wine in Palencia FL, stop by Your Pie Pizza today.
Diners choose their dough, sauce, cheese & toppings at this pizzeria chain with gelato & microbrews. Based on 214 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
389 Paseo Reyes Dr Suite 205, St. Augustine, FL 32095
Phone: (904) 547-2437
Website:
Hours
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tomas Garcia
For someone that doesn’t like pizza… I must say this was a very enjoyable lunch!!!. I really enjoyed my individual veggie pizza.
… more
Morgan Keene
Super awesome service and great options for food. The place is very well kept and you can tell the manager and owner really put their time and effort into creating a pleasurable guest experience from the food to the environment. They have a super wide range of toppings for your pizza and pasta; even having different specials each season! It’s great having not only food options, but desserts and drinks as well. Definitely adds to the dining experience. Don’t let the bad reviews turn you away, you can really tell it was before they switched owners. Make sure to stop in whenever you’re craving your own custom pizza, pasta, or salad!
… more
Ashlee Avery
Cute little place with a small seating area at the bar too! Food was cooked to perfection. Crispy crust but not burnt or all the extra flour on bottom. The owner came over to make sure all was well and was very kind. Highly recommend eating here.
… more
lign Good
Removing two stars from my original review because they close early. Asked if we wanted it for here or to go then said they are closing. Then they turned away the next couple that came in almost 10 minutes before closing. NOT COOL. My original 5-star review follows: Good pizza that can be customized in front of you like Subway sandwiches. Nice fresh ingredients with healthier options including whole wheat crust and cauliflower crust. Not the most expensive nor the cheapest. Glad they are here and convenient!
… more
Michael Dixon
Awesome super tasty pizzas. The ingredients are very fresh and flavorful! New owners friendly and inviting.
… more
Ryan
Good pizza, but this is constructive criticism because they do a good job. For us, don’t sell a garlic bread that has 50-60% cheese and the rest bread. Choose a better way to serve your customers full cheese and full garlic on every piece of bread.
… more
Gregory Frenette
Ordered 3 large build your own pizzas. Over $70 wasted on cardboard with sauce. Delivered cold and the all meat pizza was missing several toppings. I have never eaten worse pizza! One star is too generous!!!
… more
Sickminds 187
We had the Great White pizza, it was excellent. We also had the butterfinger gelato, it was excellent as well. Lexie was awesome, she made our pizza. She was very attentive, kept checking to make sure everything was good. Would definitely recommend to everyone. Meet the new owner, very nice man, with very nice staff.
… more
Martha Kuntz
Pie crust made in front of you, white, wheat, gluten free. You select your toppings. Fresh and vegan (+others non vegan). And vegan ice cream and others for those not vegan.
… more
Jessica Markham
Pizza, pastas, and salads on the regular menu would please anybody. Their seasonal offerings for pizza and salads puts this place over the top. I highly recommend.
… more
… View more
