Your Pie Pizza Restaurant of Fleming Island, FL uses hand-tossed dough, fresh ingredients, homemade pizza sauces and salad dressings. We offer vegan pizza, vegetarian pizza, gluten-free pizza, keto-friendly pizza, as well as traditional pizzas & pasta. Our pizza restaurant of Fleming Island, FL serves our customers’ craft series favorites, or you can build your own personal pizza or large pizza with free toppings. Try our Italian-inspired gelato! Order now for pizza delivery or carryout. You can also dine-in with us in Fleming Island, FL. We are open for lunch and dinner. If you are looking for a delicious brick-oven pizza restaurant that serves craft beer and wine in Fleming Island, FL, stop by Your Pie Pizza today.
Diners choose their dough, sauce, cheese & toppings at this pizzeria chain with gelato & microbrews. Based on 603 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1545 County Rd 220 Ste. 125, Fleming Island, FL 32003
Phone: (904) 375-9771
Website:
Hours
| Saturday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jae De Vera
Been wanting to try this place for a while and finally got the chance. It was way better than I expected. It was probably the best supreme pizza I’ve ever had. It was perfectly cooked and the veggies weren’t over done. I could tell they use a good quality cheese and to me that’s the most important ingredient in a good pizza .The crust was so good! I will definitely be back soon.
… more
Terry Griffin
We took our 1 1/2 year old granddaughter to dinner. We were greeted with by a very friendly and happy group on employees. I wanted to point out a couple of very wonderful people. Mason and Brianna were just great. They both checked on us a couple times during our meal. They both spoke to our granddaughter and made sure we were happy.
… more
Heather Ratliff
So unfortunately this is my second and last time trying to order over the phone. What’s unfortunate is the pizza is really good, however some older folks like myself do not have apps, or are old school and prefer to talk to a person when ordering.
… more
Joseph Evans
I ordered Nat’s Chicken Pesto on a cauliflower crust, and it was absolutely amazing! The staff was welcoming and joked around with us as they were making pizzas. Highly recommend trying this place out.
… more
William Bryant (Jay)
This is my 4th pizza from Your Pie. So far I have not once had a bad pizza. I have tried the gluten free and the white dough. Made all different types of pizza and they have been delicious. The ingredients are fresh and the staff is friendly and helpful. If you are tired of Pizza Hut and Papa…this is a new pizza place to try
… more
Ji-Ho Song
So I ordered a build your own salad in a bread bowl… Ordered it via GrubHub. Waited 40 minutes and all I got was a dang bread bowl. Tried to be fair in when requesting my refund but I only got half back. So I paid 6.02 got a dang bread bowl that’s cold and doesn’t even taste good. So better Your Pie.
… more
Adam J Hamersky
Very disappointed with the customer service. Didn’t feel welcomed at all. I felt rushed about what I wanted on my pizza. I’d rather go to MOD pizza. They offer fig sauce. Their customer service is on point. They know my name when I walk in there. I’m a residual customer. I just felt happier eating there. Not a warm feeling here at your pie. Not a lot of customer relationships are being made as I’m observing. Not a good way to build retention and repeat business. Got to have a good team of workers who are passionate about what they’re doing not just here to make a check. Find new workers. Great pizza. Not great customer service. Wish I had a better experience here. Too much grease. Pizza flops.
… more
Daymond Westergard
This place is amazing. They have lots of options from salad to Pizza. I got the ten inch and loaded my pizza up with all the goodies I like. Neat experience to be able to custom make my pizza. Clean booths and lots of drink options too. You have to experience this place for yourself.
… more
S Nunna
Regular here. I go maybe 2 times a month. Ingredients are always fresh. People are always very nice. Sometimes though they don’t cook the pizza as much as they should, so I always ask for well done and that seems to have hit the sweet spot. All in all, very good place for a subway style make your own pizza at a single price.
… more
Trinity Rodriguez
Amazing pizza! Tastes fresh and is made right in front of people so we know exactly how our pizza is made! The best pizza place I’ve ever been to.
… more
… View more
