Athena Greek Restaurant Menu – Amityville, NY

Type : Greek restaurant

Location : Amityville, NY

Based on 142 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout

Athena Greek Restaurant 11701

Address:
65 Merrick Rd, Amityville, NY 11701

Phone: (631) 691-4607

Website:

Hours

Tuesday 4–8:30 PM
Wednesday 4–8:30 PM
Thursday 4–8:30 PM
Friday 4–9:30 PM
Saturday 4–9:30 PM
Sunday Closed
Monday 4–8:30 PM

Photo Gallery

Reviews

James Cipriano
As a first time customer and having read many of the reviews…. I agree with the foods flavor (chicken Slovaki) being great. The unfortunate part was when my simple request of asking “can the chicken be chopped smaller please”, I was met with “that’s not possible, the size is how it’s prepared and nothing can be done about that”….. I went there because of great reviews….Good food bad Service

… more

Patti Maragliano
Delicious food. I love the Greek salad, Scordalia, Chicken Diane, hummus, veal souvlaki. Everything is fresh and wonderful!!!

… more

Harold Jamison
IM GONNA PUT IT WHERE THE GOATS CAN GET IT- THAT MEANS,TELL IT LIKE IT IS:I BEEN GOING TO THIS PLACE FOR OVER 20YRS AND NOTHING HAS CHANGED FOOD IS AS GOOD AS EVER,THEY DESERVE A 5***** STAR RATING- I BEEN ALL THOSE EXPENSIVE STEAKHOUSES ON LONG ISLAND WHERE THE FOOD SUCKS AND THE BILL IS $200-$400 FOR DOG FOOD!

… more

Amy Krinner
First time grabbing takeout. Excellent food from the salad to the rice to the entrée. Can’t wait to go back.

… more

Charlie
Best food. Always friendly, fresh. Love it.

… more

Annelise M
Consistently amazing. The Greek salads and hummus sampler are our favorites!

… more

Michelle W
Love this little GEM! Small place with very good quality food and price is really good as well. We have come here many many times as we live close and we have tried many choices on the menu. We have never had a bad meal here. It’s as if it’s home cooking even though it’s a restaurant. The food takes time to be cooked and the experience is always a treat. We relax and drink our wine have an appetizer and then enjoy our meal. We never feel rushed. The service may seem slow at times if it’s super busy but their food is worth the wait. Eggplant, almost every chicken dish, specials, soup, salad, gyro, kebabs, dolma, & HUMMUS, all of these things are off the charts delicious.

… more

Susan Peterson-Redmond
I’ve been coming to this restaurant for about 20 years now, and it’s always been very good. Unfortunately yesterday I went there and discovered that the gyro meat had changed. The texture was completely different, softer and more like ground beef. The flavor was good but my daughter and I wished they hadn’t changed it. Sorry, Athena, but you lost my daughter to this sad change!

… more

Kimberly Morasse
Small restaurant, but AMAZING Greek food. From the soup and salad, to the lamb and seafood everything was full of flavor and plenty of food. Great service and very clean as well. A must try if you haven’t been yet!

… more

Anthony Altamura
While I’ve never dined in before, the take out is incredible. The lamb kebab is perfectly seasoned and cooked every time, hummus is authentic as it gets and the gyros can’t be beat. Salads are always fresh and the pitas are hot and soft. Finally found incredible authentic Greek food nearby.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions