Big Papa’s Menu – Canisteo, NY

Type : Grill

Location : Canisteo, NY

Based on 67 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Big Papa's 14823

121 Greenwood St, Canisteo, NY 14823

Phone: (607) 698-4481



Tuesday 11 AM–8 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–8 PM
Thursday 11 AM–8 PM
Friday 11 AM–8 PM
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Monday 11 AM–8 PM

Photo Gallery


Absolutely abysmal experience. Not only did the person taking my order on the phone need me to repeat myself multiple times, my food was wrong and they closed by the time i got home and i live in hornell. Its over priced and the food is the very definition of better than nothing, the fries, burger, and fish were all completely unseasoned. Its sad there isnt much else in the area because i cannot come back here if im going to get something so bland and overpriced, if i even get what i ordered.

… more

Tommi Bragge
Got fish fry, which was absolutely awesome. Also got few different burgers for rest of the family and they were absolutely amazing. Even the kids loved everything they had. As far as fish and burgers go, this is the best place anywhere near. I have not tried other foods, but have no reason to expect anything different. Highly recommended.

… more

Doc Magi
I used to eat the fish fry and it was ok. Last time in though I ordered an ice tea and they served me one in a little glass and when I asked for a refill they told me I would have to buy another one. The place has gotten too cheap and the food has went downhill. Will not eat there again and it is a shame that they have gotten so bad that they are choosing to take this approach to customers. Used to be a nice family place now not so much.

… more

Patrick Meagher
Food was very tasty and delivered in a timely manner. Service was a little slow but we did go as a group of 20+ people all at once and only one server. She and the kitchen did well and was very accurate on orders. I had chicken and biscuits.

… more

Le Icon
Its not the honest conversations with the staff. Its not Big Papa’s owner Chris’s delicious signature beer battered haddock. Its the feeling you get when just finished your 9 hour shift and walk through those doors; hungry, exhausted, and yearnin for that familiar sentiment that only Mom and Big Papas can deliver.

… more

Seana Gloss
Fish fry was well above average, they were great about all our special orders…didn’t have time for dessert as it was so close to close, but otherwise a very good experience

… more

MaryBeth Fuhrman
Haddock fish fry was incredible. Restaurant was clean, staff was friendly!

… more

Matthew Hodge
The food is still as I remember it 20 year’s ago…mmmm

… more

james howard
Excellent food awesome service great prices

… more

Tammie Mitchell
They never have what is printed in their menu. My chicken was under cooked. It isn’t just this visit.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions