Best Pizza in Niagara Falls New York! Since 1992 we have been serving the best Pizza and Wings just minutes away from the beautiful Niagara Falls State Park. Pick up or Order in. We even offer delivery to your doorstep, hotel, business meeting or personal event. Pizza, Wings, Submarine Sandwiches, Spaghetti Dinners, and MORE!
Pizza in Niagara Falls
Pizzeria in Niagara Falls
Best Pizza in Niagara Falls
Best Wings in Niagara Falls
Best Chicken Wings in Niagara Falls
Understated outfit offering classic pizzas, plus wings, calzones & subs for dine-in or delivery. Based on 580 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
745 W Market St, Niagara Falls, NY 14301
Phone: (716) 285-8448
Website: http://goodfellaspizzanf.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Morgan Munroe
We heard from a local that they had great wings. They were the best wings I ever had. The pizza was good. Our server Angie (not 100% on her name) was fabulous. It had a great family atmosphere. You could tell the staff had worked together forever and they knew their customers. We were treated like we belonged. Thank you for a great experience!
… more
J Hunt
Haven’t been here in years, but when I did use to come the pizza was good. Well after all these years the pizza is still good, especially their char pitted wings. This pizza is the thicker (doughy) type crust that some people love or just hate it. I really enjoy it. You can eat inside the restaurant, but I strongly suggest you order out. As many others stated, this place is old and run down. I honestly believe, the only ones eating inside here is friends and family. There is also a bar area to catch a drink or two.
… more
helene Crepeault
The most disgusting pizza and wings I ever had in my life. I called to complain and the woman on the phone was awesome said I had to give back pizza and wings for full refund I told her I’m keeping the drinks and everything was good. They closed up shop at 11 pm. Man showed up different then the delivery driver I gave him the food he asked if he could come in my hotel room for a minute I said no. Asked him if he was the driver of the car he said no he was the owner of the restaurant. He was very intoxicated and said where are the pops.. I said I was keeping the pops..he proceeded to deduct it from my bill. If I was the owner and this had happened everything would have been at no charge. Very very pathetic that he would even show his face in that kind of drunken state..pizza looks like someone took a slice…wings were so dry…it’s was the most disgusting thing I’ve ever tried to eat
… more
Eric Cervantes
The place overall could use a little fixing up. But we were there for the food. And may I say it was dang good! Miss Keri awesome! Great service! Very friendly! The pizza was really good. The cheese they use was freaking great! Their cheese steaks are also among the best I’ve ever had.
… more
Dustin Soule
We’re on a road trip from FL to Michigan to Maine and home to FL. After visiting the falls we googled a pizza place and this place came up. We were hesitant but decided to go in anyway. Holy goodness the food was awesome. All of it. 3 of us ordered a half tray( cookie sheet of pizza) logs, cheese sticks, beef on weck, chicken tenders, steak and cheese, and cheesey garlic bread. Way more than we could eat but we wanted to try it all. It was all good. And the service was super awesome and nice. I forgot to get her name but she was super nice. Definitely recommend this place. Just wow.
… more
Aspen King
Really good pizza and wings. I love the steak and cheese pizza. Wings (medium) are delicious! The building does not do the business justice, don’t be put off by the exterior because internally it’s great!
… more
Barry Reeher
Had pizza and taco salad bowl. Wow was really good hot and delivery was quick.
… more
Ruben Cauley
I was double charge and called, she was rude and could care less. I tried to explain what the issue was and it didn’t matter. I will never order from this place again. Not to mention their food was sub par. I live in the Falls and will order else where…
… more
Elizabeth Lawson
Very unhappy. We ordered pizza and wings while on vacation. Spent over $70 for pizza that tastes like cardboard and wings that were so over cooked and dry. Absolutely disappointed.
… more
Cory Laws
It’s Sunday, and we wanted a good Niagara Falls pizza. My wife grew up here. Pizza is a deeply held passion, with opinions running high. Two other places weren’t open till 4 and 2. We were looking for a place to have a beer and turned into the Market to see what we could find. There was Goodfellas. On entering, we found 8 other family members. The pizza was awesome, and so were the wings. There was a special, so we got half a tray and 20 wings for $26. Who can argue with that? The pizza toppings were very generous. The wings were char-grilled, large, crispy, and well sauced. A winner!
… more
… View more