Based on 117 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
9235 E 141st St, Fishers, IN 46038
Phone: (317) 678-8097
Hours
| Sunday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 9 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Gregory Pierce
Absolutely amazing pizza, our new favorite place. We’ve been looking for a local place that had NY Style Pizza, and none of them could live up to the expectation, except Maestro’s. The crust is perfect, the cheese and toppings are plentiful. This is our third time ordering (multiple pizzas at a time) and each one has been the definition of perfect.
… more
Hany Rahahleh (هاني رحاحلة)
They have a fantastic delicious large pizzas
… more
Muted Xpressions
First visit we ordered barbecue chicken pizza with Greek salad and a few chicken wings, definitely was not a family meal but it was our first time trying out the place, oh and it came with a few fries. Not too shabby fast forward 2 weeks later, My children wanted a pepperoni pizza and we were making a purchase from the restaurant near by so it was convenient to just go ahead and pick up a simple pepperoni pizza. My children love pepperoni pizza but unfortunately they were underwhelmed by maestro’s Pizza, my daughter commented that she it reminded her of store-bought Pizza better and my son just didn’t think that it hit the mark, in fact he found Costco’s simple cheese pizza to be even better than Maestro’s. I don’t think we need a tie breaker.
… more
Abdelhamid Azzaz
I have to say that I really enjoy their pizza, the crust isn’t too thick or too thin, crispy from the bottom and edges, soft from the inside.
… more
Spicy Zing
I really wanted to try this place out since my brother really raved about it. I went ahead and got myself a small personal Chicken Tandoori pizza and the 1/2 wings. Pizza is actually a lot bigger than I expected! I’m used it a small pan pizza but it’s the same size as the to go containers! Gotta say the pizza was phenomenal! Amazing flavors, and they stuff the ingredients in the sauce as well which I really enjoy! Wings aren’t too bad but they are small for being $10 for a 6 piece. Fries were also undercooked so that is a shame. I’d recommend the pizza, wings eh, subpar along with the fries.
… more
Anna H Dawson
Fast and reasonably priced! The steak and pepper pizza is fantastic! Nice crust, the white sauce is creamy and not too salty, and the toppings are nicely cooked and seasoned. Idk what the seasoning is on the mozzarella sticks, but it’s really good, too!
… more
A A
This place is equivalent to a fish and chicken spot youd find in an inner city which is NOT a bad thing. The suburbs need a place like this!
… more
Maria Khan
Great Zabiha halal pizza option. Tried the Steak and Cheese along with Butter Chicken. Enjoyed the Butter Chicken, although it could have more spice for my taste. Steak and Cheese was not my favorite (a little too greasy) but I know it’s a popular option here. Service was very kind. Prices are relatively expensive, but in line with the other halal pizza options in Indy (Magoos, Pizza Pizza). Also I appreciate that the Pizza has a different flavor profile than Magoos and isn’t a knock-off (although it is white sauce pizza too).
… more
Keegan Nichols
Great pizza place prices aren’t bad at all I got a 24 slice for like 20 bucks that would be like 30~ at Jett’s or papa John’s. Owners and employees are super nice and pizza is great quality
… more
Robin Hellalat
This was my first time ordering food. It was Absolutely the best Shawarma that I’ve ever tried; with fast friendly service. I got a huge sandwich with lots of fries. Can’t wait to try other menu items!
… more
… View more