Based on 139 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
333 Dayton St, Mayville, WI 53050
Phone: (920) 644-2199
Website: http://atwellspub.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–8 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nicole Voss
Sounds like they are just getting started. Talked with the owner today. Limited menus on Friday. Great Fish Fry. Said everything is prepped there, trying to give a great value with excellent flavor. Still setting things up and working on menus. Said they are really trying to listen to the feedback as they are getting things started and in order.
… more
steve lockwood
For me The Pub has the best fish fry around this area. A very light batter that lets you taste the fish. We have only gone on Friday for their family style fish and chicken. You get all you want to eat, the waitress have always come back to your table often to ask if you want more of anything. The Pub is an awesome place to go for fish. I have never had their pizza bit heard it’s really good also.
… more
ashley mcfarlane
Would have loved to support new business but sadly it was extremely poor service. Waited in front of a podium of 3 people for 10 minutes before anyone even greeted us, was told by the wait staff to get a drink at the bar and someone would come get our name, proceeded to wait another 10 minutes at the bar before a girl who didn’t even work here just jumped behind the bar to help, she made me us the wrong drinks but since she isn’t an employee I can’t hold that against the establishment, it took another 15 minutes before we were greeted and seated. At this point looking around to see all the tables still waiting for food with the EXTREMELY LIMITED Friday menu, we decided to pay for our drinks an leave. Based on the comments from the customers we talked to, the service wasn’t just an issue for us tonight.. we won’t return. Short staffing is a poor excuse for bad service with the limited menu along with all the available seating they had. The old owners were always packed with more options and the service was much better..
… more
Steven Nelson
I was very happy to see they reopened! Awesome food!
… more
Melissa Staniszewski
Had the best experience here as an out of towner. Felt very welcomed with a super friendly staff. They had a relaxed atmosphere. Great drinks and the food was amazing – I had the stuffed chicken breast special by recommendation of the bartender! She did not steer me wrong. My boyfriend had a burger that he thought was great also!
… more
Kaylene McLaughlin
Update hours because dining service doesn’t start until 4:30.
… more
Leigh Warner
The BEST Fish Fry all year round! Been going for decades; have Never disappointed my expectations. AYCE Fish and Chicken – Family Style. Wear your stretchy pants!
… more
Amy Bonack
We love the pizza always amazing! My husband goes every Friday for lunch and is always happy! (He is working his way through the menu) get staff super friendly!
… more
Wendy Bertrand
The food ( fish fry) was fantastic. Other wise being newly open it was Chaotic
… more
Tricia Souder
Nice old school atmosphere. Makes a good stiff drink. Food was hot and fresh. Served quick. Friendly staff. Love the Friday fish and chicken.
… more
… View more