Based on 665 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
8917 Oak Ridge Hwy, Knoxville, TN 37931
Phone: (865) 896-0125
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 12–6 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Megan Crowder
We did a large pepperoni pizza and some knots. Food was OK.
… more
melo
Stuffed shells are amazing, as well as the anti pasta. Pizza is phenomenal, come try soon you won’t be disappointed! Authentic and very surprised at the amazing taste and customer service. Will be back!
… more
Kenneth Woods
Finally stopped by this little pizza place after passing it for years. I ordered a simple pepperoni pizza and the wife had the stuffed shells. Both were absolutely amazing. Can’t believe it took us so long to try it but we will be back in for sure.
… more
bryan baer
I am from NY born and raised. My family moved here a couple of years ago as well as friends and family keep visiting and moving here! Little Nicky’s is the real deal! For anyone that doubts that has never been to a real family owned pizzeria in NY. The atmosphere is spot on, the food quality is spot on, the deli is amazing, the desserts are to die for nothing even close in the aspect of taste, quality, and style anywhere near here. Must try everything on the menu! I’m getting there as this is our go to spot bringing us back to the roots of our home town and growing up! The owners and staff are the nicest people you’ll meet treating you like family, feeding you like your at your nonnas house for Sunday dinner, I promise you’ll leave full and satisfied! I have nothing bad to say about this place and I highly recommend trying everything they got you won’t be disappointed!
… more
Dinah Burke
We had the pleasure of dining at Little Nicky’s Pizza a few days ago and we had the Bronx Bomber which is one of my favorite pizzas plus we had a fabulous salad. This was an awesome homemade pizza that was prepared fresh and loaded with cheese. Just the way I like it. Little Nicky’s is a local mom and pop business and the pizza is superbly prepared fresh every day. Oh and the deserts will knock your socks off. Also, the owners of Little Nicky’s are very active in our community and contribute to many of our local groups including veterans. Which we appreciate since my husband is a veteran. I’m not sure what the moose guy above who left the bad review for my favorite pizza is even talking about. Apparently he doesn’t like TN. OK Fuhgeddaboudit. This place is absolutely great. Go there !
… more
Caleb Demster
Hey Mr. Nicky just want to say thank you for the great pepperoni pie and the cannolis were delicious as well. Happy I finally found a good mom and pop shop that reminds me of my little hometown of Niagara Falls, NY. It was fun talking with you and Mr. Robert. I know you said you’re not a big fan of being out in the sticks in Tennessee but if you like fishing there’s alot of good spots in Dandridge and Rutledge areas. Lol
… more
Z M.
I have been looking for good pizza since I’ve moved to TN from CA. Little Nicky’s is the best I’ve had after trying multiple places! Great chewy crust, fresh toppings, and very nice staff. Will definitely be going back! Ordered Denton Boys pizza with added mushrooms and garlic knots. So happy to have found this place!
… more
Krista Asp
Great NY style pizza. This shop is a little hole in the wall joint and I would not expect anything from the outside. However the pizza and calzones are huge and there is a great variety of dessert options all of which look amazing.
… more
Gabriella Del Bene
Moved down to TN from from NY and being Italian, finding quality pizza and Italian food/pastries was hard to find until I came across Little Nicky’s. The owners are from NY and reminds me of home. By far their food is the best around. Everything is absolutely delicious!
… more
Marco Pérez
We took a two-hour drive Oak Ridge to watch my nephew on his last rowing competition. On the way over we went past this little hole in the wall which we stopped at on the back. I have just had the best all-around NY pizza and dessert experience in TN. The owner is from Brooklyn, his wife from the Bronx and the cashier from Staten Island. It’s the real deal.
… more
… View more