American fare & a full bar in an upbeat space with racing memorabilia, TVs & frequent live music. Based on 682 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
9755 Fall Creek Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46256
Phone: (317) 842-2087
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kourtney Neville
This was our first time dining here. My father in-law and I ordered the fish and chips, my hubby had tenders w/ fries and my mother-in-law had the tuna melt which had a bit too much mayo. Overall the food was really good, the portion sizes are more than enough. Good service.
… more
Brian J
Okay so now I’m kicking myself for never coming here before now. It’s definitely not just a bar but after the food I’ve had today I have to call it a restaurant.
… more
Kelvin Johnson
Food was really great so was the service and atmosphere. This was our first time going there and we will be going back
… more
Mike Treat
Incredible food, legendary drinks and really cool wait staff. 5 stars!
… more
Joe Sprunger
The tuna ahi bowl was amazing. Fresh and full of flavor. I haven’t had a bad dish yet.
… more
Brian Fedje
We has tried AJ’s several years ago and had a bad service experience so never returned. After getting good feedback from friends and online we decided to try it again. Service was excellent and the food was very good. I tried beef stroganoff at the suggestion of the waitress. My wife had the fish taco. The menu has a nice variety so we will definitely be back.
… more
D.W. Everett
UPDATE!!- FALL CREEK RD IS NOW OPEN FROM SHADELAND TO 79TH STREET. SEE YA AT AJs!!We were driving up Fall Creek road and found this jem. We were looking for good fish and chips and found it right here. From the perfect head of foam on the Guiness to the great service it was a very nice dining experience. The fish was just right and the fries are great too. Try the fried green beans! You’ll be glad you did.
… more
Leonard Caponegro
We recently had dinner at AJ’S. We started off our dinner with the Grilled Cheeses Wedges. The Grilled Cheeses Wedges were good but could use a bit more cheese for it to have that true grilled cheese taste. The tomato bisque dipping sauce had an interestingly warm mouth feel to it. The Chef Paul Prudhomme’s Cajun Meatloaf was the perfect comfort meal. The meatloaf had a good spicy flavor that was a great flavor balance for the meal. Meaty, comforting and very warm from the spices. The Fried Green Beans were extremely addictive. Perfectly cooked and crunchy, and tasted even better when dipped in the homemade ranch sauce. The mashed potatoes were creamy and a bit chunky, and tasted very good with the gravy. My son loved his Chicken & Cheese Tacos. Before we knew it he had finished all three. My wife liked the Pittsburgh Style Ribeye Steak, but found it to have far too much fat. A bit surprised that for the price that the additional fat on the outside of the steak wasn’t trimmed enough prior to cooking it. My wife loved the flavors from the herbs and brown butter sauce. The Grilled Asparagus was surprisingly tender for the size, and had a good amount of spices and flavor. Also, the Garlic Mashed Potatoes were delicious. For dessert I enjoyed the warm, spiced flavorful Apple Crisp that was chock full of apples. I liked that it was more apples than the granola, and because of that a great balance between the two. The ice cream was a great way to cool off the hot apple crisp and add a level of creaminess to the dessert. My son and wife enjoyed Cheesecake for dessert. My wife enjoyed the Raspberry Cheesecake while my son enjoyed the Turtle Cheesecake. They loved the creamy and richness of the Cheesecake.
… more
Debbie Stone
I ordered the grilled tenderloin sandwich online for pick up. Having never been to this establishment I looked around to locate where to pick up take-out. I didn’t see any sign so I went to the bar. The bartender was busy and I had to wait at least 10 minutes before I could get her attention to see where to pick up the food. She came from behind the bar and went ttowards the front of the bar and came back with my order. Once home, I was looking forward to having my meal and was sadly quite disappointed. There was absolutely no flavor whatsoever. The loin was pounded out very thin to just bun size (no overhang). It was accompanied by some kettle chips, which was actually the best part of the meal. I’d be embarrassed to have this on the menu as the bar owner and to charge $14 is a total rip off.
… more
N Odell
Fun atmosphere. Nice variety of foods. Fun waitress. Lots of TVs to watch.
… more
… View more