Casual pizza place with quirky decor known for huge thin-crust slices & pies, plus late hours. Based on 433 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
Address:
913 W Main St, Charlottesville, VA 22903
Phone: (434) 245-4007
Social Profile: 
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kaylie Powell
This pizza is amazing! Not only does it taste great, but the price you pay includes great entertainment for the size of the pizza. This pizza will be sure to deliver happy grins from the great taste to the bulging eyes of how it even made it out of the door, into the car and through the door frame at home. Giggles will be heard at the size of the box, pie and slice! Worth every penny!
… more
Farzana Yasmin Ahmad
The place seems aesthetic to me in a different way. It looks like my grandparents home back in Bangladesh.
… more
Ben Frecker
I came here after finishing the Skyline Drive, and I’ve got to say this place was amazing. All around good vibes: not packed, friendly and fast service, and amazing pizza. It’s history and cozy wood design topped it off. It’s tucked away in a cool part of town, but not hard to reach. I highly recommend for anyone looking to get some good chow.
… more
S
I was here on June 9th and just received the best service. You could tell the pizza chef loved making these massive pizza pies and was excited for the new move to the store closer to campus. The food was great. Service was stellar. I love going to all the Benny’s and this one is definitely top tier
… more
Maverick
Haven’t been here in a couple years. Fond memories of grabbing a whole pizza and heading across the street to the brewery. I was expecting the prices to be higher, as they were, but the pizza just wasn’t the same. Ordered a couple different slices and had to send them back to finish cooking. Still a little doughy inside but starting burn on the bottom. Benny’s never was cheese-heavy, but cheese was barely noticeable visually or taste-wise. Hoping it was just a bad day. Heard there might be a new brewery across the street and would like to relive the past.
… more
Ryan Grover
Massive Pizza Slices for $5 and gargantuan 28” whole pizzas!
… more
Chelsea Marie
The person who took our order was having a profanity-laced cell phone conversation while we were trying to order AND openly drinking a beer. There was another person–unclear if they were an employee- blasting music over the sound system. The cook making the pizza seemed to be the only person actually working but was eating a lollipop and holding the wet lollipop in her hand touching the dough which was yuck. It took 30 minutes to for 2 slices to come out. Last visit.
… more
Kevin W.
Delicious pizza slices larger than most people’s heads and for a pretty decent price. They have thin crust pizzas with a tasty sauce. Clean bathrooms. I am almost ready to attempt the Benny’s challenge… Eat a whole pizza in a hour and get $500 and a shirt :0 Thanks for a great lunch, we all enjoyed it!!
… more
Geo Q
Never saw slices soooooo big. I tried two but pepperoni waa delicious. I gave 4 stars because my friend and I for some reason both had indigestion/reflux after eating this pizza
… more
Benjamin Altman
Great pizza, friendly people, good value. I thought the sausage and pepperoni were tasty, and they had a good ratio of cheese to sauce. However I would definitely recommend asking to see what size the pizza is, because this was FAR too much food!
… more
… View more