Pizza Paul's Menu - Lakeville, NY

Based on 178 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Pizza Paul's 14480

Address:
5808 Big Tree Rd, Lakeville, NY 14480

Phone: (585) 346-2680

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday	11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11 AM–9 PM
Friday	11 AM–10 PM
Saturday	11 AM–10 PM
Sunday	11 AM–9 PM
Monday	11 AM–9 PM

Lakeville – Menu Ordering
Regular Wings 6	$7.40
Regular Wings 12	$14.70
Regular Wings 18	$21.11
Regular Wings 24	$28.16
Regular Wings 36	$42.22
Regular Wings 48	$56.29
Boneless Wings 6	$6.50
Boneless Wings 12	$12.99
Boneless Wings 18	$19.53
Boneless Wings 24	$26.00
Boneless Wings 48	$51.96
Breaded Wings 6	$8.15
Breaded Wings 12	$15.30
Breaded Wings 18	$21.84
Breaded Wings 24	$30.60
Breaded Wings 48	$61.18
Battered Mushrooms	$6.46
Buffalo Blue Fries Chicken covered in Buffalo Blue sauce	$10.40
Canadian Inspired Poutine Cheddar cheese curd and light gravy	$10.40
Cauliflower	$6.46
Cheddar Tots	$6.46
Cheese Ravioli	$9.50
Cheesy Bacon Fries Bacon and lots of cheese	$10.40
Chicken Fingers (No Fries)	$9.50
Chicken Fingers With Fries	$13.24
Greek Fries Feta, olives, tomato and house dressing	$10.40
Mozzarella Sticks	$9.50
Munchie Mix 2 Pizza logs, 3 Mozzarella Sticks, Cheddar Tots and Battered Mushrooms	$13.37
Onion Rings	$6.46
Philly Cheese Steak Fries Steak, onion, peppers, cheese sauce and Paul’s steak sauce	$10.40
Pizza Fries Diced pepperoni, cheese served with pizza sauce	$10.40
Pizza Logs	$9.50
Straight Cut Fries	$6.74
Taco Fries Beef, salsa, olives and sour cream	$10.40
Cowboy Bites	$6.46
Bacon Sub
Capicolla Sub
Cheese Sub
Cheeseburger Sub
Chicken Finger Parm Sub
Chicken Finger Sub
Grilled Chicken Parm Sub
Grilled Chicken Sub
Ham Sub
Italian Sub
Meatball Sub
Pizza Sub
Roast Beef Sub
Salami Sub
Steak Sub
Tuna Sub
Turkey Sub
Veggie Sub
Bacon Subzone	$14.69
Capicolla Subzone	$14.69
Salami Subzone	$14.69
Ham Subzone	$14.69
Italian Subzone	$14.69
Meatball Subzone	$14.69
Turkey Subzone	$14.69
Roast Beef Subzone	$14.69
Steak Subzone	$14.69
Cheeseburger Subzone	$14.69
Grilled Chicken Subzone	$14.69
Chicken Finger Subzone	$14.69
Assorted Piadina	$13.60
Bacon Piadina	$13.60
Capicolla Piadina	$13.60
Cheeseburger Piadina	$13.60
Chicken Finger Piadina	$13.60
Grilled Chicken Piadina	$13.60
Ham Piadina	$13.60
Italian Piadina	$13.60
Meatball Piadina	$13.60
Roast Beef Piadina	$13.60
Salami Piadina	$13.60
Steak Piadina	$13.60
Turkey Piadina	$13.60
Grilled Chicken Parm Piadina	$13.60
Chicken Finger Parm Piadina	$13.60
Buffalo Blue Wrap Blue sauce and grilled chicken	$10.67
Philly Steak Wrap Peppers, mushrooms, onions, steak sauce and mozzarella	$10.67
Western Grilled Chicken Wrap Salsa, sour cream and cheddar	$10.67
Turkey Club Wrap Bacon, turkey, mayo, cheddar, lettuce, tomato and onion	$10.67
Veggie Wrap Lettuce, tomato, onion, peppers, picjles and house dressing	$10.67
Bacon Wrap	$10.67
Capicolla Wrap	$10.67
Salami Wrap	$10.67
Ham Wrap	$10.67
Italian Wrap	$10.67
Tuna Wrap	$10.67
Meatball Wrap	$10.67
Turkey Wrap	$10.67
Roast Beef Wrap	$10.67
Steak Wrap	$10.67
Cheeseburger Wrap	$10.67
Grilled Chicken Wrap	$10.67
Chicken Finger Wrap	$10.67
Garden Salad	$7.14
Chef Salad Ham, turkey and provolone cheese	$9.66
Classic Club Bacon, cranberries, grilled chicken and ham	$9.66
Southwest Santa Fe Tortilla shell, grilled chicken, salsa, olives, cheddar & sour cream	$9.66
Taco Salad Tortilla shell, seasoned beef, sour cream, salsa, cheddat and olives	$9.66
Mediterranean Grilled chicken, olives and feta	$9.66
Cranberry Cape Cod Cranberries, mandarin oranges and feta	$9.66
Antipasta Salad	$9.66
Caesar	$9.66
Bread Sticks 6	$7.14
Bread Sticks 6 W/Cheese	$8.40
Cannoli	$4.77
Fried Dough	$4.77
Blueberry Pie	$4.86
Apple Pie	$4.86
Cherry Pie	$4.86
Brownie/Brookie	$4.86
Decadent Desserts	$6.00
2 Liter	$3.13
20 Oz	$2.19
Pure Leaf Tea	$2.19
Basic Ball Cheese & Garlic	$2.96
Cheesecake Ball Rolled in cinnamon and topped with cheesecake, then add raspberry or caramel sauce.	$2.96
Honey Butter Ball Rolled in cinnamon and honey butter.	$2.96
Side BC	$0.83
Chips	$1.10
Ranch	$0.83
Buffalo	$0.83
Boss	$0.83
Garlic	$0.83
BBQ	$0.83
Cauliflower Rice Bowl With Steak	$10.00
Rice Bowl With Chicken	$10.00
Bean Burger Puff Pastry	$8.00
Steak Puff Pastry	$8.00
Ham Puff Pastry	$8.00
Burrata With Tomato	$14.10
Peach Burrata	$14.10
Lakeville – Pizza and Calzones Ordering
Burrata With Tomato	$14.10
Peach Burrata	$14.10
Personal Pizza (10)	$10.95
Medium Pizza (13)	$15.93
Large Pizza (16)	$19.73
Extra Large Pizza (18)	$23.72
Sheet Pizza (16×24)	$28.80
Gluten Free	$10.95
Calzone	$10.95
Chicken Wing Personal Fingers and Buffalo blue cheese sauce	$14.37
Hawaiian Personal Ham & pineapple	$14.37
Meat Lovers Personal	$14.37
Mighty Bulldog Personal Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and olives	$14.37
New Yorker Personal Spinach, tomato and ricotta	$14.37
Philly Steak Personal Onion, peppers, mushrooms and white garlic sauce	$14.37
Veggie Lover Personal Mushrooms, black olives, onion, green peppers and tomato	$14.37
White Garlic Veggie Personal Broccoli, spinach and mushrooms	$14.37
Pickle Pizza Personal	$14.37
Hawaiian Medium Ham & pineapple	$21.00
Mighty Bulldog Medium Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and olives	$21.00
Chicken Wing Medium Fingers and Buffalo blue cheese sauce	$21.00
New Yorker Medium Spinach, tomato and ricotta	$21.00
White Garlic Veggie Medium Broccoli, spinach and mushrooms	$21.00
Veggie Lover Medium Mushrooms, black olives, onion, green peppers and tomato	$21.00
Philly Steak Medium Onion, peppers, mushrooms and white garlic sauce	$21.00
Meat Lovers Medium	$21.00
Pickle Pizza Medium	$21.00
Mighty Bulldog Large Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and olives	$25.47
Hawaiian Large Ham & pineapple	$25.47
Chicken Wing Large Fingers and Buffalo blue cheese sauce	$25.47
New Yorker Large Spinach, tomato and ricotta	$25.47
White Garlic Veggie Large Broccoli, spinach and mushrooms	$25.47
Veggie Lover Large Mushrooms, black olives, onion, green peppers and tomato	$25.47
Philly Steak Large Onion, peppers, mushrooms and white garlic sauce	$25.47
Meat Lovers Large	$25.47
Pickle Pizza Large	$25.47
Mighty Bulldog Extra Large Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and olives	$30.54
Hawaiian Extra Large Ham & pineapple	$30.54
Chicken Wing Extra Large Fingers and Buffalo blue cheese sauce	$30.54
New Yorker Extra Large Spinach, tomato and ricotta	$30.54
White Garlic Veggie Extra Large Broccoli, spinach and mushrooms	$30.54
Veggie Lover Extra Large Mushrooms, black olives, onion, green peppers and tomato	$30.54
Philly Steak Extra Large Onion, peppers, mushrooms and white garlic sauce	$30.54
Meat Lover Extra Large	$30.54
Pickle Pizza Extra Large	$30.54
Mighty Bulldog Sheet Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and olives	$41.25
Hawaiian Sheet Ham & pineapple	$41.25
Chicken Wing Sheet Fingers and Buffalo blue cheese sauce	$41.25
New Yorker Sheet Spinach, tomato and ricotta	$41.25
White Garlic Veggie Sheet Broccoli, spinach and mushrooms	$41.25
Veggie Lover Sheet Mushrooms, black olives, onion, green peppers and tomato	$41.25
Philly Steak Sheet Onion, peppers, mushrooms and white garlic sauce	$41.25
Meatlovers Sheet	$41.25
Pickle Pizza Sheet	$41.25
All Mighty Calzone Pepperoni, mushroom, black olives, green pepper & sausage	$14.69
BBQ Chicken Calzone Fingers, BBQ sauce, garlic & mozzarella	$14.68
Beef On Weck Calzone Roast Beef, cheddar, mozzarella. The top is coated	$14.68
Buffalo Blue Calzone Medium sauce, blue cheese, fingers & mozzarella	$14.68
Chicken And Biscuits Calzone Grilled chicken, gravy, fries & mozzarella	$14.68
Chicken Bacon Ranch Calzone Fingers, ranch, bacon, white garlic sauce & mozzarella	$14.68
Chicken Cordon Blue Calzone Ham, fingers, swiss, mozzarella and bleu cheese	$14.68
Chicken Wing Calzone Fingers and Buffalo blue cheese sauce	$14.68
Crazy Turkey Calzone Turkey, craisins, bacon, fresh tomato, American cheese & mozzarella	$14.68
Hawaiian Calzone Ham & pineapple	$14.68
Italian Lover Calzone Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Italian Salami, ham, mozzarella & red sauce	$14.68
Lasagna Calzone Ground beef, mozzarella, parmesan, red sauce & ricotta	$14.68
Meat Lover Calzone Pepperoni, ham & sausage	$14.68
Meatball Calzone Meatballs, marinara & mozzarella	$14.68
Mighty Bulldog Calzone Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, green peppers and olives	$14.68
New Yorker Calzone Spinach, tomato and ricotta	$14.68
Philly Steak Calzone Onion, peppers, mushrooms and white garlic sauce	$14.68
Pizza & Wing Calzone Chicken Fingers tossed in buffalo blue sauce, pepperoni, mozzarella & red sauce	$14.68
Reuben Calzone Corned Beef, sauerkraut, thousand island and swiss with caraway seeds.	$14.68
Southwest Calzone Grilled Chicken, salsa, mozzarella, black olives & sour cream	$14.68
Spinach Artichoke Calzone Spinach, artichoke, white garlic, ricotta & mozzarella	$14.68
Steak Bomber Calzone Grilled steak, mushrooms, peppers, onions, mozzarella & garlic steak sauce	$14.68
Taco Calzone Seasoned beef, cheddar, salsa & side of sour cream	$14.68
The Club Calzone Ham, turkey, bacon , American cheese, mozzarella, tomato & garlic sauce	$14.68
The Dry Martini Calzone White garlic sauce, ham, Italian salami, ricotta, provolone & green olives	$14.68
Veggie Lover Calzone Mushrooms, black olives, onion, green peppers and tomato	$14.68
White Garlic Veggie Calzone Broccoli, spinach and mushrooms	$14.68
Lakeville – New Items Ordering
Black Bean Puff	$8.00
Ham And Swiss Puff	$8.00
Steak And Pep Puff	$8.00
Steak Rice Bowl	$10.00
Chicken Rice Bowl	$10.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Debra Riley

Pizza Paul’s has the best pizza in Conesus. I love the crust. It’s between a thick and thin crust, just the way I like it. The sauce is great not overly zealous with the spices. They apply just the right amount of sauce so it doesn’t make a mess when you eat it. We highly recommend Pizza Paul’s. PS the fish fry is to die for.

… more

Rob

My review requires an update. I originally gave Pizza Paul’s 5 stars because it’s been my favorite for about 22 years. Evidently inflation has struck the pizza business. Slice used to be HUGE! Around $5.00 for a slice that took up a medium pizza box but now 2 slices for around $10.00 will fit in the same box. Too pricey for me.

… more

ani n

Authentic NY style experience! Absolutely delicious food and fantastic service! Don’t forget to try the cheese cake balls!

… more

Mike , Tampa Fl.

Very disappointed with today’s order . Did not mind it was very pricey. But then the mixup on the order and time of delivery was way off. It’s time to take a break from Paul’s. Usually order 15 to 20 orders in the summer months. And it’s been not bad until now.

… more

Conrado Caballero

First time getting a sub from here, and it was delicious. I wanted to save some for work for lunch, but it was so good I ate the whole thing in a sitting.

… more

Jeff Guldenschuh

Great visit. Walked in and placed order and it was ready very quickly. Staff was very friendly. Always good food!

… more

Jason Leclair

Probably the worst pizza and chicken wings I have ever gotten from anywhere. 2 pizzas and 24 chicken wings. 72 bucks. Will never order from them again. The price is high and garbage food

… more

Brittney Sage

We ordered for the first time and it’s very very very delicious and we will be going back. I got the pickle pizza and fried mushrooms.

… more

Sandy U

Ordered a large special, large pizza with pepperoni and two dozen well done wings. The pizza crust was very thick, the sauce, cheese and pepperoni left like 3 inches of crust on each slice of pizza! I ordered the wings well done and they were not the slightest bit crispy. Very disappointed with the meal tonight. It will be a while before I order from here again.

… more

KC Conti

I was very disappointed. Not only did the gentleman at the front desk overcharged me for an order I did not place, but the two subs that I ordered were absolutely terrible. The bread was the consistency of croutons. The lettuce was brown and wilted. $24 for two poor quality subs.

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Pizza Paul’s Menu – Lakeville, NY

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions