We’re excited to announce that this winter, we’re giving Main Street Pizza Company a complete makeover! Going forward you can enjoy all of your favorite authentic Italian classics & pizza at Main Street Italian Eatery. Get ready to indulge in your Italian favorites from our scratch kitchen. Everything from Main Street Italian Eatery is made completely from scratch and never frozen. Make your reservations now for a dinner experience that your taste buds will never forget. We are the home to the Farmingdale Pop Up events including Witchcraft, Christmas Club and The Wonder Pop Ups. Thanks to the support of our amazing customers and community we will be adding new and exciting venues in 2023!
Based on 95 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
302 Main St, Farmingdale, NY 11735
Phone: (516) 777-3600
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
12–9 PM |
| Monday |
Closed |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Erica Greco
I’m thrilled to give Main Street Italian Eatery a well-deserved five-star review! The Family Package was an absolute standout – the portions were just right for my family of four, and the variety was impressive. The food itself was incredibly delicious, and the customer service went above and beyond to ensure a fantastic dining experience. It’s a true blessing to have such a quality restaurant like this on Main Street in our wonderful town of Farmingdale. Looking forward to many more visits!
… more
George Cali
Went there for New Years Eve. They changed their catering area into a Christmas theme. It is called Christmas Club Pop-up Bar. Very festive decorations. The service and food was awesome. Definitely recommend.
… more
Joseph Lanzarotta
This place was really a true gem that I found via my food Instagram page from others sharing there amazing pics of there food. The Big Mac Pizza was absolutely amazing it tasted just like a big mac but I was pleasantly confused if i was eating a big mac or a pizza and I was eating both it was amazing and the rice balls in vodka sauce was so good great flavor in the sauce I will definitely be coming back this is one heck of a good place!
… more
nick santangelo
Absolutely amazing perfect food drinks great friendly staff Tyler out did himself the Grinch made my night excellent experience as a pop of Christmas event definitely recommended
… more
Craig Kearns
Place was great when the old restaurant manager John was there. He recently left and the place went to garbage. I won’t be going back.
… more
Shackwon Reid
Great pizza and the food is amazing! They have great drink options and the restaurant is beautiful. It was so beautiful I actually booked it for my wedding anniversary party. The owner David is such a down to earth type of guy. He went out his way and entertained my 5 year old twins. Recommended great food choices for us and we tried everything and nothing was a disappointment. And I love how hands on the owner is. So rather you stopping by for pizza or actual food I would 100% recommended this place and their brunch specials are amazing!
… more
N-dricks Saint Louis
Walk in there, waiting for some to help me with my order, they just walking around made eye contact with me say nothing to me then they go and help people that walk in after me.
… more
rob castaldo
I wanted to like this place , but they have cancelled 2 orders on me in a matter of a couple of months. Both times nowhere near closing. Other times trying to get some of there special pies they could not make them cause they didn’t have certain ingredients, but they call you back over a hour later to tell you.
… more
Ryan G.
The Alice in Wonderland experience was top notch and so was the food and drinks! The actors, and staff were all fantastic and we had a great time! Can’t wait to see what they do for Halloween!
… more
Metsfan 22
Sit back and relax and enjoy the show…
… more
… View more
