Old-school family-run trattoria with a bar & a large menu of traditional red-sauce dishes. Based on 928 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
99530 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037
Phone: (305) 451-4885
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: keylargo-cafelargo.comopentable.com
Reviews
Blayre Blooms
Went here for dinner. They were short staffed so a manager waited on us. Staff was hardworking but seemed stressed. Food was good and made fresh in house. Garlic rolls were good but not the best I’ve had. The lobster ravioli was a special that night and it was delicious. 3 humongous raviolis with delicious filling and a nice creamy tomato sauce. The house dressing on the salad is a creamy italian but is quite good. Hubby got the lobster mac and cheese which was a large portion and very delicious. The Iguana Bait beer is a local brew that my hubby really enjoyed. My drink, the Royal Hawaiian,was SO good. Really smooth. One of those dangerous drinks. They have some vegetarian options too. All in all we had a good time.
… more
Aaron Nicodemus
The food seems like it had great potential but I was really disappointed at the lack of salt in the two dishes I ordered. The ricotta in the manicotti tasted like it had no salt added, and the pasta and sauce were not salty enough to make up for it. The same was true for the other pasta dish, it tasted like the noodles were not cooked in well salted water. Not a great look for an Italian restaurant. Otherwise the garlic knots were awesome. I would consider coming back again, but I’ll definitely be trying other places as a priority in Key Largo.
… more
Stacy Klone
Our party of five enjoyed all that we ordered. We found the portions very generous and recommend sharing to experience more of the menu offering. Kathy our server was friendly and spent a lot of time spoiling our grandson.
… more
Aaron Bonewitz
My man! If your looking for real deal Italian in Key Largo stop! Ya stop here because this is the place. This Guy I know said this is the place and we checked it out and it’s the place. Meatballs &Ricotta with gravy is better than most peoples grandma made, we dipped the garlic rolls in it until we got the tomato basil soup then we used that. Amazing atmosphere with excellent service and flavor town 101 for sure. The main was a chef special seafood broil with cream sauce, perfectly cooked seafood, out of bonds sauce and an excellent meal. Great experience with great service at an excellent place. Check it out because it’s one of a kind real deal!
… more
Jon and Mary
We stopped here because it was open and walking distance from our lodging. We were seated immediately and Leah took great care of us throughout the meal. Our food was absolutely delicious. Wish we had had room for dessert!
… more
Nicole Brengel
Such a good service! We had soft drinks, a little side salad and the soup of the day to some Pasta. It was very much, but very delicious! We had great service, I think her name was Kathy, who told us everything we did not know. We even got our drinks do go after we paid. We can definitely recommend that restaurant. 🙂
… more
Trevor Shupe
Amazing food. The garlic knots were fantastic. We got the fried mozzarella for an appetizer and that was amazing as well. Great service from our waiter. Portion sizes were really good, we weren’t able to finish our food. Worth the visit from Idaho. My husband won’t stop talking about this place
… more
Plushkinglol
When we walked in we were seated almost immediately (Party of 2). Our server didn’t come to our table, so another server came over and served us after about 5-8 minutes of waiting. We also noticed a lack of busboys, as the tables around us were messy when we arrived and when we left. The food was pretty good, the garlic knots were awesome and came out quick. We got fried mozzarella for an appetizer, and a meatball pepperoni pizza split between us. The pizzas are 10”, and are a good size for 2 people. I recommend waiting a few minutes before touching the pizza, as the cheese slides right off when you first get it. Servers were very nice and refilled our drinks a few times. Overall 4/5, I recommend if you’re in the area and want a nice dinner for a good price.
… more
Tammy Shepherd
Incredible food!!! Started with the meatballs & ricotta, 3 large meatballs with whipped ricotta and delicious marinara. I had the lasagna, the portion was huge, the pasta was very light, cheesy and the sauce was great. My husband had the Ravioli, again large portion and awesome. Meal came with bread and side salad with their house creamy italian dressing which was the best I have ever had. We don’t usually get dessert but our server Kathy (who was extelemy friendly) suggested the cheesecake, it was to die for!!!
… more
myriah howard
My husband and I were blown away by the amazing flavors and freshness of everything we ordered! The fried mozzarella was homemade the best we’ve ever had! I enjoyed the chicken in a nest and my husband loved his 4 cheese ravioli. We Love the garlic bread too. All of it was beyond delicious. Highly recommend!
… more
… View more