Based on 161 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
N64 W24370 Main Street, Sussex, WI 53089
Phone: (262) 372-3003
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–9 PM |
| Saturday | 12–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 4–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Cole Vandermause
Pizza is a 3/5. Service and atmosphere, by comparison, need a lot of work. They made the wrong pizza. We ordered a Philly cheesesteak thin crust and received a mushroom, onion and green pepper thin crust. We didn’t notice the error until we had the pizza home, and it wasn’t worth the trip back to have it corrected. But, we did provide feedback on the error through the online ordering app. The response to our feedback had strong “you’re wrong” energy telling us “The meat is under the cheese in our pizzas.” In reality, our pizza most definitely didn’t have meat on it, on top or underneath the cheese. We reiterated that there aren’t mushrooms on the Philly cheesesteak pizza as listed in the menu. Instead of just admitting there was an error and apologizing, the person doing their reputation management responded by saying, “We are working to get our menu updated” … leading us to infer their Philly cheesesteak pizza doesn’t have steak on it and does have mushrooms.
… more
Greg Caine
I’ve been getting their pizza delivered or carry out for many years. It is the best pizza in Sussex like they say or anywhere. I always get the Sussex Supreme thin crust with no green peppers. I don’t understand all the negative reviews.
… more
Oliver Pugh
Amazing pizza. Got the Hawaiian, Chicken Bacon Ranch and a Cheese. All were delicious. The hand tossed could use a little crispier bottom but that’s all. Easily will eat here again.
… more
Ben K
Food is great. Picking it up feels awkward, like you just interrupted someone smoking a bowl. A 20 minute wait turned out to be more like 30. And when they forgot all the stuff to go with our chicken dinner, there was no refund available.
… more
Bridget Zignego
Amazing experience all around! Super nice server, generous with the toppings and fast service!! Pizza and cheese bread were amazing! We will definitely be back!!
… more
Nat Rodriguez
Got 4 LARGE Pizzas to feed an army. Very delicious, thin crust was perfect and so was the pan crust. Ordered over the phone and picked up with ease! Would definitely recommend for any party or occasion.
… more
Steveo Schenck
We Only get it Delivered
… more
DejaBOOM
Horrible service. We used to be all about their pizza and they were the best place in town we ordered pizza from, but we started noticing the service at the restaurant going downhill REAL fast over the past 6 months, especially.
… more
Mr. Mark
WOW! I had a very, very good cheeseburger and seasoned fries. The buffalo wings were meaty and fantastic. I had pizza and a slider on my last visit, also very,very good as wel. Check this place out , you will not be disappointed. Friendly staff and great service.
… more
Jeff K
Food was excellent. Best mushroom swiss burger I had in a long time. Took a while for our food though, and we were the only people in the restaurant.
… more
… View more