Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral Menu – Cape Coral, FL

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Cape Coral, FL

Serving Cape Coral for over 23 years, Paradise Pizza in Cape Coral, Florida serves the highest quality Italian Specialties around! Dough made from scratch daily, sauces made from family recipes and homemade meatballs are only a few examples of what makes Paradise so special. Full menu available for dine-in, carry-out and delivery. The name says it all, it’s just Paradise!

Low-key, sit-down pizza parlor boasting NYC-style pies plus pasta dishes, salads & sandwiches. Based on 900 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Paradise Pizza of Cape Coral 33904

Address:
842 Lafayette St, Cape Coral, FL 33904

Phone: (239) 945-1555

Website: https://paradisepizzafl.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Saturday 12–9 PM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
 Closed
Tuesday 12–9 PM
Wednesday 12–9 PM
Thursday 12–9 PM
Friday 12–9 PM

Menu

Appetizers
Garlic Bread
with cheese $4.00		 $3.00
French Fries $3.95
Cajun French Fries $4.95
Mozzarella Sticks $8.00
Toasted Ravioli $8.00
Mussels Marinara $12.95
Fried Mushrooms $8.00
10 Chicken Wings – Market Price
Mild, Medium, Hot, BBQ, Garlic Parmesan OR Glazed Teriyaki
Eggplant Rollatini $13.00
Buffalo Shrimp $15.75
Fried Calamari $12.95
Bruschetta $8.00
Arancinni (Rice Balls) $8.00
Salads
Garden Salad (Small)
Lettuce, Tomato, Black Olive, Cheese, Onion, Crouton | Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $4.00
Garden Salad (Large)
Lettuce, Tomato, Black Olive, Cheese, Onion, Crouton | Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $8.00
Caesar Salad (Large)
Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $8.00
Caesar Salad (Small)
Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $4.00
Italian Salad
Lettuce, Tomato, Black & Green Olives, Salami,Provolone and Pepperoni | Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $14.25
Antipasto Salad
Lettuce, tomato, black & green olives, salami, provolone, giardinaira, ham and capicola | Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $14.50
Chef Salad
Lettuce, tomato, black & green olives, turkey, ham, provolone and salami | Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $14.25
Greek Salad
Romaine, tomato, kalamata olives, red onion & feta cheese | Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $13.50
Chicken Tender Salad
Romaine, tomato, bacon, onion, mozzarella, olives & hand battered chicken fingers | Add Chicken $6.00 or Shrimp $9.00		 $16.50
Extra Dressing $1.00
Cheese Pizzas
Cheese Pizza (Small 12″)
TOPPINGS: $1.75/ea. Pepperoni – Green Peppers – Black Olives – Onion – Ham – Meatball – Mushroom – Jalapenos – Eggplant – Anchovies – Broccoli – Pineapple – Artichoke – Spinach – Sausage – Zucchini – Bacon – Garlic – Ricotta – Tomato – Bananna Peppers – Green Olives – Roasted Red Peppers – Feta		 $11.25
Cheese Pizza (Medium 14″)
TOPPINGS: $2.00/ea. Pepperoni – Green Peppers – Black Olives – Onion – Ham – Meatball – Mushroom – Jalapenos – Eggplant – Anchovies – Broccoli – Pineapple – Artichoke – Spinach – Sausage – Zucchini – Bacon – Garlic – Ricotta – Tomato – Bananna Peppers – Green Olives – Roasted Red Peppers – Feta		 $13.25
Cheese Pizza (Large 16″)
TOPPINGS: $2.50/ea. Pepperoni – Green Peppers – Black Olives – Onion – Ham – Meatball – Mushroom – Jalapenos – Eggplant – Anchovies – Broccoli – Pineapple – Artichoke – Spinach – Sausage – Zucchini – Bacon – Garlic – Ricotta – Tomato – Bananna Peppers – Green Olives – Roasted Red Peppers – Feta		 $14.50
Cheese Pizza (X-Large 20″)
TOPPINGS: $3.00/ea. Pepperoni – Green Peppers – Black Olives – Onion – Ham – Meatball – Mushroom – Jalapenos – Eggplant – Anchovies – Broccoli – Pineapple – Artichoke – Spinach – Sausage – Zucchini – Bacon – Garlic – Ricotta – Tomato – Bananna Peppers – Green Olives – Roasted Red Peppers – Feta		 $18.50
Deep Dish Sicilian Pizza (16″X16″)
TOPPINGS: $4.00/ea. Pepperoni – Green Peppers – Black Olives – Onion – Ham – Meatball – Mushroom – Jalapenos – Eggplant – Anchovies – Broccoli – Pineapple – Artichoke – Spinach – Sausage – Zucchini – Bacon – Garlic – Ricotta – Tomato – Bananna Peppers – Green Olives – Roasted Red Peppers – Feta		 $19.75
Gluten Free Pizza (10″)
TOPPINGS: $1.75/ea Pepperoni – Green Peppers – Black Olives – Onion – Ham – Meatball – Mushroom – Jalapenos – Eggplant – Anchovies – Broccoli – Pineapple – Artichoke – Spinach – Sausage – Zucchini – Bacon – Garlic – Ricotta – Tomato – Bananna Peppers – Green Olives – Roasted Red Peppers – Feta		 $11.25
Specialty Pizzas
Paradise Deluxe Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $21.75 | Large (16″) $24.25 | X-Large (20″) $28.25 | Sicilian (16″x16″) $29.95 | Pepperoni, ham, meatball, sausage, mushroom, onion, green pepper and black olive		 $18.75
Veggie Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $20.75 | Large (16″) $23.25 | X-Large (20″) $27.25 | Sicilian (16″x16″) $29.00 | Onion, mushroom, tomato, spinach, broccoli and zucchini		 $17.75
Meat Lovers Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $20.75 | Large (16″) $23.25 | X-Large (20″) $27.25 | Sicilian (16″x16″) $29.00 | Pepperoni, bacon, ham, meatball and Italian sausage		 $17.75
Sweet Meat Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $20.75 | Large (16″) $23.25 | X-Large (20″) $27.25 | Sicilian (16″x16″) $29.00 | Pepperoni, canned bacon, ham, meatball and Italian sausage		 $17.75
White Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $15.50 | Large (16″) $17.50 | X-Large (20″) $20.50 | Ricotta Base, Provolone, Mozzarella		 $13.95
Chicken Delight Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $18.50 | Large (16″) $21.00 | X-Large (20″ or 16″x16″) $24.50 | BBQ Chicken, Buffalo Chicken, Chicken + Bacon + Ranch		 $16.50
Garden Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $17.50 | Large (16″) $20.00 | X-Large (20″) $23.50 | Sicilian (16″x16″) $25.75 | Onion, green pepper, mushrooms and black olives		 $15.50
Hawaiian Pizza Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $17.50 | Large (16″) $20.00 | X-Large (20″) $23.50 | Sicilian (16″x16″) $25.75 | Ham, pineapple & bacon		 $15.50
Best Of Italy Small (10″ GF Or 12″)
Medium (14″) $20.75 | Large (16″) $23.25 | X-Large (20″) $27.25 | Sicilian (16″x16″) $29.25 | Marinara sauce, Spaghetti, Meatballs, Mozzarella		 $17.75
Calcone & Strombolis
House Calzone (One Size)
Ricotta and Mozzarella		 $13.00
Calzone Veggie (One Size)
Mushroom, onion, tomato, spinach, broccoli and zucchini		 $15.75
Chicken Parmesan Calzone
Ricotta, Mozzarella, Breaded Chicken and Marinara		 $16.95
House Stromboli (One Size)
Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Mushroom,Black Olives, Mozzarella & Marinara Sauce		 $15.00
BYO Stromboli
Mozzarella Cheese with choice up to 3 toppings Extra toppings $1.50 Extra Sauce $1.00 Chicken and Shrimp may include an upcharge		 $13.00
Pasta
Baked Ravioli
Served with Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50 | Add: Broccoli $3.00, Chicken $6.00, Shrimp $9.00, Meatballs or Sausage $7.00		 $14.95
Baked Ziti
Served with Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50 | Add: Broccoli $3.00, Chicken $6.00, Shrimp $9.00, Meatballs or Sausage $7.00		 $14.95
Lasagna
Served with Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50 | Add: Broccoli $3.00, Chicken $6.00, Shrimp $9.00, Meatballs or Sausage $7.00		 $16.95
Spaghetti With Meatballs Or Sausage
Served with Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50 | Add: Broccoli $3.00, Chicken $6.00, Shrimp $9.00, Meatballs or Sausage $7.00		 $16.00
Penne Alla Vodka
Tender pasta with spiked tomato vodka cream sauce & Parmesan cheese. Served with Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50 | Add: Broccoli $3.00, Chicken $6.00, Shrimp $9.00, Meatballs or Sausage $7.00		 $16.00
Fettuccine Alfredo
A classic with cream and Parmesan. Served with Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50 | Add: Broccoli $3.00, Chicken $6.00, Shrimp $9.00, Meatballs or Sausage $7.00		 $16.00
Dinners
Chicken Parmigiana
Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $19.50
Eggplant Parmigiana
Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $17.95
Chicken Valeria
Egg battered chicken sautéed with lemon and fine herbs topped with fresh tomatoes over pasta. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $19.50
Chicken Christy
Sauteéd with ham and mushrooms in sherry cream sauce with melted provolone. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $19.50
Eggplant Rollatini
Eggplant stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella and seasonings with melted cheese and a side of pasta. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $18.50
Mussels Marinara
Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $18.00
Chicken Marsala
Dipped in Parmesan egg batter and sautéed in a delicious marsala wine mushroom sauce over pasta. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $19.50
Cajun Chicken Pasta
Light cajun cream sauce with chicken served over penne. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $18.00
Fettuccini Paradise
Ground sausage, mushrooms, broccoli and a tangy, light tomato cream sauce served over fettuccini. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $18.00
Shrimp Valeria
Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $20.00
Shrimp Marinara
Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $20.00
Veal Parmigiana
What can I say? A classic topped with house marinara and melted mozzarella over pasta. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $25.00
Spaghetti Diablo
Shrimp with caramelized onions in a spicy garlic, tomato basil sauce served over spaghetti.. Served with Pasta and Garlic Rolls. Add a side salad for $2.50		 $19.25
Baskets
Broasted Chicken
Breast, Thigh, Leg and Wing. Served with Fries & Cole Slaw		 $16.00
Chicken Tenders
Hand breaded lightly fried chicken breast served with tangy honey mustard. Served with Fries & Cole Slaw		 $15.00
Fried Shrimp
7 jumbo fried shrimp with cocktail sauce. Served with Fries & Cole Slaw		 $15.50
Buffalo Shrimp
7 jumbo battered shrimp tossed in wing sauce with bleu cheese. Served with Fries & Cole Slaw		 $14.75
Chicken
Broasted Chicken Bucket (4pc.)
8pc. $21.00 | 12pc. $31.00 | 16pc. $39.00 | Served with Fries and Cole Slaw, Breast, Thigh, Leg and Wing		 $16.00
Cold Subs & Sandwiches
Italian Combo
Ham, salami, capicola, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and vinaigrette dressing		 $12.95
Custom Made Ham & Cheese $11.95
Custom Made Turkey & Cheese $11.95
Hot Subs & Sandwiches
Chicken Or Meatball Parmigiana Sub $11.00
Eggplant Parmigiana Sub $11.00
Shrimp Parmigiana Sub $14.00
Veal Parmigiana Sub $16.00
Chicken Club Sub
Bacon, ranch, mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomato		 $11.25
Turkey Club Sub
Baked with Bacon, Mozzarella, Mayo, Lettuce, Tomato		 $11.25
Buffalo Chicken Sub
Tossed in wing sauce with bleu cheese, mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomato		 $11.25
Spicy Italian Sub
Baked with ham, capicola, salami, pepperoni,jalapeños, cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion		 $12.95
Mouth Of The South Sub
Baked with ham, salami, turkey,mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomato		 $12.95
Sausage, Green Pepper, Onion Sub $11.25
Cheese Steak Sub
Custom made any way you like with Steak, Mozzarella and your choice of toppings (extra meat $4.00)		 $13.95
Steak Bomb Sub
Onion, green pepper, mushroom, pepperoni, marinara, cheese and steak, extra meat add $4.00		 $14.25
Cheeseburger In Paradise Sub
1/2lb burger on a large Kaiser bun served with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickle and a side of french fries		 $14.95
Homemade Desserts
Cannoli $6.95
Chocolate Cake $8.00
Alcohol & Soda
Draft Beer (Glass)
Budweiser, Bud Light, Michelob Ultra & Yuengling | Shock Top $4.65 per glass		 $4.25
Domestic Bottles
Bud, Bud Lite, Miller Lite, Michelob Ultra, Coors Light, AmberBock, Yuengling | 6-Pack $13.25 (Carry-out and Delivery only)		 $3.75
Imported Bottles
Corona, Stella, Funky Buddha, Hop Gun | 6-Pack $16.25 (Carry-out and Delivery only)		 $5.25
Wine (Glass)
Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Pinot Grigio, White Zinfandel & Chardonnay | Bottle $16.50		 $5.50
Soda (Fountain – Free Refills)
Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Orange Juice, Apple Juice, Root Beer | $2.00 cans | $3.25 2 Liter (to go only)		 $2.95

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Billy Bones
Really good pizza, we had it delivered on a Friday night and it showed up quick. I would definitely eat here again. 1 large pizza can easily feed 6 people. Posted is the smallest slice in the box and was still big. Amazing thin crust style pizza. Give them a try! The meat lover was soo good.

… more

Meredith Sage Kendall
As a previous pizza restaurant owner… Paradise Pizza is authentic. We will be back. The pizza was mounded with toppings. The crust was browned juR right from the brick oven. And their sauce was perfect.

… more

M A
Delicious pizza and really friendly service.

… more

Lauren Wilkinson
My first experience was a take-out XL mushroom pizza. It was fantastic, so hot and so fresh! The sauce is great and there was definitely fresh mushrooms on it! It was so good that I went there 3 days later for a dine-in experience and was super impressed again! The server was great and so friendly and the food was somehow even better in person!! I definitely recommend Paradise Pizza for your lunch or dinner (or even leftover for breakfast lol)

… more

Earle Judd
Order delivery and they delivered it next door to the Elks club. The pizza was hot and tasty delivery service was fast and friendly. As you can see, we finish it off and then we will be back again.

… more

Egidia Rackow
We have been coming to Paradise Pizza for years. We have always considered it the best pizza in the Cape. We started branching out with the appetizer of mussels marinara with the garlic knots. So good and you want to sop up all that delicious marinara with the garlic knots. My husband has always enjoyed their spaghetti and meatballs and I love the Spaghetti Diablo with huge shrimp and just the right amount of heat. Today my husband had the Seafood Italiano which he deemed Spectacular! His new absolute favorite, chock full of shrimp, mussels, clams, shrimp and calamari. The bad news is that because this comes with more warm garlic knots straight out of the oven and you want to get every bit of the sauce there’s no more room left, but you keep eating cause it’s so very good. Good news, delicious leftovers for tomorrow’s dinner. Don’t let this place fool you, though the pizza is very good and we very much enjoy it, go for the entrees. You won’t be disappointed! And if you get Emily for a server you’re in luck! She is friendly, knowledgeable and attentive.

… more

Erik Z
I’m a long time resident here in Cape Coral and I’ve eaten at a lot of pizzerias around here in that time. Recently, I’ve been diagnosed as celiac which means no more gluten for me. Now eating out is a very real challenge because so few restaurants will cater to folks with my issue. Paradise Pizza is not one of those restaurants. They have taken the brave step to offer a delicious gluten free pizza prepared with my medical condition in mind. They use a premade (non-cauliflower) crust, prepare the pie on a pan so there’s no cross contact in the oven, and use all fresh cleaned utensils in the process. I was very confident going into the meal, and I was rewarded with a delicious pizza that did not cause any gluten reactions within me. Thank you so much for taking those extra steps so folks like me can enjoy your amazing food. Our server was Lulu, and she was delightful. I am so glad to find a pizzeria in town that I can trust with my condition. I will definitely return and tell my friends.

… more

Jason Cleveland
Sooo good. This was a totally random pick. They forgot to make one of my pizzas, and I had to wait 10 minutes so they could cook it. That being said, the pizzas were absolutely delicious. All 8 of us agreed. They could have comped a 2 liter or a slice of cheese cake, but we’ll definitely eat here next time we’re in Cape Coral.

… more

Johnson “Big johnson” Brown
Hands down best pizza ! No flop and they get my order right every freaking time . Been going here for years and they got from what I seen the two best pizza cooks in Lee county,! Keep up the amazing work lady’s an gentleman!!

… more

Christopher Muylle
Went with my family for my wife’s birthday. Horrible service. Server took forever to take our order. She was chewing gum. Finally took our order. Brings out the wrong salad. Then took forever to get our pizza over an hour). Won’t be back. It’s a shame because the food is good.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch