Based on 123 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
18 Portland St, South Berwick, ME 03908
Phone: (207) 704-0382
Website: http://oddfellowsmaine.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 3–8 PM |
| Thursday | 3–8 PM |
| Friday | 3–8 PM |
| Saturday | 3–8 PM |
| Sunday | 3–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Virginia Chappell
Went on a Thursday, late afternoon, not busy. Odd pizza selections, gourmet-bougie but no basics (can’t get hamburger etc.). Pizza was WAY overcooked, I understand wood and coal-fired ovens. I also understand cooking the pizza until the cheese is tough as leather. My pepperoni half had exactly three slices of pepperoni, my husband’s half with bacon wasn’t as generously adorned. Not bad prices, but the workmanship in the kitchen needs improvement. Nice facilities, wait staff was super, so two out of three.
… more
Bobby Conlon
Tasty nachos and ricotta pizza! Mmmmmm tasty Larrys too! Great service, friendly waitress made a nice dinner!
… more
Carly Festervan
Odd Fellows Tavern is a must visit in southern Maine. Their menu is delicious, cozy, and everything you could want on a quintessential Maine evening. I was able to recently have my rehearsal dinner here and everything was so perfect. We did not give much notice since the weather changed a previously planned outdoor dinner to an indoor dinner, but Odd Fellows was extremely welcoming and allowed us to utilize a part of the restaruant space. From the food, to the staff, to the owners, to the location, Odd Fellows is a must try for those local and traveling. Good food, kind staff, and amazing drinks is simply the best and Odd Fellows does an amazing job.
… more
PierceHill Design
We worked with Gregg and Kristin to build their website. Odd Fellows Tavern is an excellent place to grab a beer and food with your friends. The ownership and staff are amazing, the food is fantastic and the atmosphere will keep you coming back!
… more
Tyler B
The food was pretty good. Pizza was ok. The fires are great, the flame oven wings are awesome. Fish and Chips was O.K kinda cold when we got home. So it most likely tasted better fresh at the restaurant.
… more
George
Cute little place that caught our eye. Glad we stopped in, friendly staff, bartender especially. 4 for food as we only got an appetizer of wings which were very good.
… more
Tom Hilfer
Food was good but we were our waitresses only table and she was a ghost. She only showed up to the table to take our order and hand us the check so we couldn’t order a second round of drinks until everyone was already done. The table across from us ordered, got drinks, got their food, and a second round before we got our first round of drinks. Might have just been the one person since the other table probably had a decent experience. Seems like a hit or miss dining spot depending on the staff and the night.
… more
Ginny Zavacky
I have to say the only 2 times I was there, it was horrible. First, I ordered a pizza to go, granted they were busy, but when I got it home, it was burnt. Literally, the cheese was hard and black bubbles. It took so long I never ordered a replacement. Inedible. The second time I went in for happy hour and got a margarita for my birthday. The bartender put the total of the bill as a tip, charging me double, I had given her 20%. When I noticed it on my credit statement, the manager (who after 1/2 hr someone finally picked up the phone) said she couldn’t do anything about it and the owner had the next 5 days off. He called after that, leaving a message for a partial refund. Not even the amount I authorized, so I’m still trying to get ahold of him. Obviously they’re short staffed and incompetent all the way around. Shocked at all the 4.25 stars….
… more
Ashley Desrosiers
One of my favorite local spots- amazing thin crust pizza (especially the drobish) and drinks including beer, wine, and margs. Love sitting out on the patio in the summertime.
… more
Makenna Lenzo
Absolutely delicious! The food was amazing literally some of the best pulled pork I’ve had in a while! My grandparents loved their shrimp & haddock. Our waitress was so nice! She was very helpful and friendly. The bathrooms were super clean as was the entire tavern. Pricing was also super reasonable!
… more
… View more