Based on 825 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
604 F St, Eureka, CA 95501
Phone: (707) 442-5800
Hours
| Friday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11:30 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Chris Dellis
Love the large pieces of pizza. I really dig the sauce and ample cheese. I could have used a little more pepperoni though. The vibe is chill but bustling with busyness. Lots too do in immediate area. Quick walk to anywhere in old town!
… more
K_McBass
I like their pizza here for lunch time. I had the “Rumble in da Bronx” and “New Amsterdam” slices. Both are awesome. The people who work there are cool. Always had a good time for a lunch break.
… more
Sarah Giles
We were in Eureka for only 2 nights and ate here 3 times. It’s that good! It’s the best New York style pizza I’ve had outside of NY!
… more
Aayumi
The staff was so lovely and the pizza was delicious!!! We got just a Hawaiian pizza, and the dough was perfect texture…a little crunchy but soft. The toppings were delicious and the sauce was zesty! Best way to eat it is definitely folding it like a taco! My boyfriend and I had some fun messing around on the ancient arcade machine while we waited…though it is definitely worse for wear and hardly worked. But I highly recommend the garlic knots! Those were delicious! All around great pizza place with friendly, casual staff
… more
Brice D.
We’re not from the area and we asked one of our friends that is, where the best pizza was in Eureka and he told us to check out Paul’s Live from New York!! Very open setting made for larger groups! You can order whole or by the slice pizzas! The have a special everyday that looks very appealing to the eye! The taste and the crunch was perfect!! I will be coming back when I visit again!!
… more
Ignacio Dominguez Davila
Had a bad experience in this place. The pizza is below average (had eaten better frozen pizzas). Go to Domino’s down the street. Had to wait 40 minutes. We went with a service dog and did not meet the ADA requirements. I am filing a complaint next. AVOID THIS PLACE
… more
Daniel de Llano
The pizza is just ok. The treat I received with my service dog is unacceptable. I had a person standing in front of me without moving, asking for a physical proof to prove that my dog is a service animal (that’s forbidden mr!). I didn’t want a fight, I thought I would eat a decent pizza… so I proceeded to look for the documents in my mobile phone. As it’s new it took me a bit, I offered the guy to give me a minute and I would reach out to him. He said no, and stood up right in front of me looking me in a bad way and making me feel anxious. My dog is a psychiatric service dog… I should’ve record the whole thing or called the police. Please do it if you go with your service dog and you are treated this way. The pizza wasn’t even good… a frozen one is better.
… more
Frank Hadley
Paul’s is the only pizza place I’ve been to in CA that could survive in New York. They’d do much better than survive though, this pizza is good as any slice I’ve had in NYC. And if my review doesn’t convince you, Paul has a stamp of approval from the goodfella himself, Henry Hill.
… more
Jeff Downing
Walked in here after attempting to go to 3 other restaurants that were all closed on a Saturday night. There was a line out the door and the smell of NY style pizza wafted in the air. Plenty of seating, large portions, pizza by the piece or size, and friendly staff. This joint is buzzing.
… more
Cindy Ruffner
Excellent pizza, and the garlic knots were unbelievable! Service was friendly, prices are fair. We do recommend Paul’s Pizza, it’s delicious!
… more
… View more