Take-out counter prepping made-to-order Italian sandwiches & other basic fare. Based on 663 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery ✔️ No dine-in
Address:
234 US-1, Scarborough, ME 04074
Phone: (207) 883-2402
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 9 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rachel Worthing
Got a chicken salad sandwich. It was incredible and the bread was so fresh and soft. Customer service was excellent and my food came out super quickly.
… more
Amaury S
It pains me to give this place a low rating. We are big fans of Amato’s but usually eat at the Portland India St location, and have always loved it. We’ve always been impressed with the quality of the food and fast and friendly service, but at this location we had a different experience.
… more
Kim Hatem
After ordering online and getting a wait time of 30-35 mins. I went in at 30 mins. only to find my order hadn’t been started. The workers beyond the counters looked dazed and confused and miserable. No one seemed to be in charge and no one seemed to know what was going on. Everyone looked like they hated their jobs. I then waited until 20 mins. before I asked again where my order was. At that point I was directed to the other side of the counter as the order was being wrapped up. The sandwiches were delicious but I won’t be going back in as the atmosphere just seemed so depressed and unhappy and no one wanted to be doing the job. Looks like a sad place to work.
… more
Aaron Brown
They were struggling to keep up. Very busy during lunch and lots of wasted labor standing around. If there are no hot foods being cooked, why not have the two on the hot line make cold sandwiches in between? Also, I’m pretty sure the double italian I ordered wasn’t double this time.
… more
Silas M
Ordered ahead during dinner hours. Showed up to pick up food and waited about 15 minutes past pick-up time before my food was brought to me. It’s a small place, and I noticed that my order was pulled from the completed order area, so it had been ready all along. The sandwich was soggy, while other food was so-so by the time I got it home and waited so long at the store. I think it would have been better if fresh.
… more
Evo IX (Anonymous)
Food is always great and the help is always exceptional. However it is not a good look having two employees, with company shirts on, taking dabs and getting high out front by the dumpster for all of your patrons to see when they pull into your parking area.
… more
Peter Googins
The employees love to talk and not pay attention when taking orders from customers. They got my order wrong, and wouldn’t surprise me if they got the other persons order.
… more
david carter
Went in mid afternoon when almost no other customers were there. Waited behind an employee buying food and after their transaction was complete the girl at the register just turned around and walked away. Everyone else behind the counter was just standing around chatting and it seemed as if I was invisible. I shrugged and left. I was looking forward to my overpriced mediocre sandwich but being ignored was enough to make me never want to return
… more
Denton Weimer
What can I say they make great Italian sandwiches and they cut all your veggies fresh. They are located all over the state of Maine and I really feel like they are more popular than subway in Maine. The only thing I wish was for their bread to be a little more fresh, I have had really fresh bread from other Amatos locations and we were really looking forward to this sandwich. Don’t get me wrong still really good however, the bread just needed a little work.
… more
Darshan Shah
Really fresh veggies. They cut the vegetables in front of you to put it on your sandwich. Great food and service. Loved it. The staff was very nice.
… more
… View more