Made in New York Pizza’s inaugural location on the Upper West Side is a pizza place less than a block away from Central Park West and the Museum of Natural History. We offer pizza, salad and an assortment of sides to deliver a world-renowned NYC pizza experience. Whether you’re looking to grab an early lunch, an evening dinner, or a late-night meal, we’re open and ready to serve you for dine-in, delivery or carryout. Next time you find yourself in the Upper West Side, whether you’re leisurely strolling the neighborhood, enjoying Central Park or visiting the Beacon Theatre, don’t hesitate to stop by for a New York slice.
Based on 744 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
421 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024
Phone: (646) 484-6200
Website:
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–11:45 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–11:45 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nicola Jordaan
This was probably the best pizza I have eaten since traveling in NY. Worth every penny.
… more
Samantha Taranto
Most delicious pizza in New York. I loved the vodka sauce slice and pepperoni slices. The dough is cooked to perfection. The service is also great the staff are all friendly and welcoming with quick service and great prices. Thank you for a delicious meal, can’t wait to go back again.
… more
A.L. Harris
My absolute favorite late night pizza place. Open until 11 on weekdays and 1 on weekends. Perfect place for a late night slice on your way home. Everything’s fresh and made with high end ingredients. Plenty of choices. There are a few of these in the city but this one’s the best. A few tables outside too.
… more
Heidi Soper
If you’re looking for a quick, but yummy place to try out NY pizza, this is the place to go! We got garlic knots, slice of pepperoni and cheese. The dough was so yummy and they heated it all up in a wood fired oven, so it was very fresh! We really enjoyed the food but noticed it was very warm inside the restaurant (keep in mind that it was the middle of July), everything else was great!
… more
Jessica A
We tried two pizza by the slice places while we were in NYC and this one was definitely the better option. It was recommended by one of the locals and she sure knew what she was talking about.
… more
Andy Ye
Great place to dine in at and great pizza. The pizza here is a lot different than the ones I eat from dominos here but the con is that the average full pie is around $30 each, which is something I’m not used too.
… more
Alan Varghese
Pretty good standard NY style pizza with a ton of square slices as well. Plenty of options, average prices, indoor and outdoor seating and as well.
… more
Sam M
This is my favorite new pizza find in the city for a good slice! It’s better than Joe’s and the other big name recognition spots. There is indoor and outdoor seating. They have one tray of toppings for the pizza which usually tourists who don’t understand how to act in a pizza shop… hoard at their table, even though they see 15 tables and only 1 topping container on the tray for each topping. Please be considerate and use the topping and return for others to use as well.
… more
Benjamin Wenisch
Had lunch at Made in New York Pizza and it didn’t disappoint. Their authentic New York style pizza was a real treat to-go – truly tasty! A must-try spot for pizza enthusiasts. Solid 4 stars for this iconic slice of the city.
… more
Josh Kass
Excellent NY ‘Za. In the West Side this place just mastered the perfect recipe. Great pie choices, and both thick and thin crust. Excellent food!! And away from all the noise of downtown.
… more
… View more
