Cozy trattoria serving pizza & Italian classics, decorated with a New York Little Italy theme. Based on 327 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
960 N Hwy A1A, Indialantic, FL 32903
Phone: (321) 953-6888
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jay Ball
I was visiting the area for a beach day with friends when we decided to order to go for late night food. I only wish there was a pizza place close to me that was this good! Everyone who had a slice was very satisfied! The staff was friendly, the price is reasonable and you don’t get cheated on the size of the pizza. Will definitely make a point to stop by next time I’m in the area!
… more
Andrew H
My family went here for some Italian food and were surprised by the amazing food, large portions, and fantastic service. Our waitress Lia was incredible and really took care of us. Strongly recommend the baked ziti and the lasagna…they were out of this world.
… more
Wilson Echevarria II
This is a great place to go for a romantic dinner with your significant other in a cozy booth for two, or as a good spot to take your extended family or friends for a gourmet pizza and beers.
… more
Leigh Ann M
I really hate giving 1 star reviews but this was truly a poor experience. We came in a group of 4 on a Friday night almost two weeks ago because my grandmother wanted Italian. The service was pleasant at first but extremely slow. Once our server dropped off the food, it was almost an hour before she appeared again. And she only appeared because I had to ask a passing server for boxes, the check, and for our server. Our server delivered the check but still didn’t have boxes. She then apologizes for “being short staffed”, but that doesn’t excuse such a wait time without drink refills or being checked on. The food for my whole group was all bland, cold, and very dry. The real kicker for me was when I heated up my food the next day, I found pieces of parchment paper in my eggplant. Needless to say it all went in the trash. I watched as many other tables were also displeased with poor service and long wait times. I witnessed two tables wait over 30 minutes after being seated to even be greeted by a server, let alone get drinks.
… more
Cesar Lopez
Came in here with high expectations based on reviews but left disappointed. Pasta and sauce had no flavor whatsoever the chicken tasted like cheap frozen chicken from any store. Could not finish plate.. Restaurant was empty and took a good 45 mins to get our plates. The garlic bread was the best part of the meal.
… more
Shannon B
Excellent authentic New York style pizza. Originally I was going to give this place a 2 star, because our server was so awful. But then I thought about it…the other servers were very attentive, and I also realized that the management took a chance on an inexperienced server, so mega-points for that. Also, the man at the oven, Rocco is the real-deal, I could tell his frustration with our server Kayla (sp), I could tell this man runs a tight ship…and makes a mean pie. So, all-in-all, Petrillo’s definitely earned a 5 star. Give them a shot, you will be impressed.
… more
Bill Knaffl
8/18/23 – tonight (friday at 7) the building was locked up tight. a few long term cars parked in the lot, but very few lights on and the doors were locked. Regretfully, I think that this business is closed – and the menu linked is no longer registered. Another one bites the dust?
… more
Helen Stengel
Travelers beware! We went here for a late evening meal 8:20. After they set us down they told us the kitchen was closed except for pizza. Why say you are open until 9:00 when you close the kitchen early. So we went toPizzaVola. Great service and friendly. The food was spectacular. Huge menu. Lasagna was very good and the Mussels were very good.
… more
Paul Giampa
The best Italian food on the east coast of Florida. I am also Italian and brought up in an Italian household. The wait staff was unbelievable and attentive. The smell and the aroma and the Ambiance is true Italian. Make sure you say hi to Shoni who is a great hostess, bartender with a beautiful smile that lights up a room. For the ultimate dining and show experience go there on Wednesday night between 6:30 and 8:30 to catch Sonny Petrillo singing and playing the saxophone and having fun with all the patrons in the dining room.
… more
Bianca Fulara
Avoid. My friend and I both ordered lasagna. The meat was off. It was described as having the meat your served in an elementary school cafeteria that the kids would avoid at all costs. Salad had too much dressing, ask for it on the side. One star is given for good bread. Service was slow. I would try another place. Around $17 down the drain for a bad meal.
… more
… View more