Based on 149 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
93 Windermere Ave, Greenwood Lake, NY 10925
Phone: (845) 595-1688
Website: http://greenwoodlakebagels.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Bailey Luder
Just visiting for the week, and this place was perfect for a quick bite; we had a bagel breakfast sandwich 4 days in a row! My personal favorite was the French toast bagel, with sausage, egg and cheese, but the egg-poppy bagel featured in the photo was a close second. Love this spot – thank you for taking care of our breakfast needs!
… more
Cady Donovan
I went the other day to get a BEC on a bagel and a HEC on a roll but my order was wrong and both of them were on rolls. I brought the sandwich labeled BEC so they can fix it but I was met with nothing but attitude. Apparently they were labeled wrong and I brought back the wrong sandwich for them to fix and they did nothing but blame me for it. They were so rude! I’ve only been here twice and won’t come back again!
… more
Edwin Lozada
One lady is nice the other is rude… My wife also went in there one time to get a bagel and the guy was extremely rude not welcoming and no manners whatsoever. Also the Chocolate milk I bought was expired and spoiled. I didn’t read the date and took a sip and then immediately spit it out as it was sour. It wasn’t cheap either. Waste of money. I Think the manager should really reconsider her staff, the reviews of them being rude are true. They should also check their products expiration dates regularly.
… more
Abhinav Swaminathan
Had a toasted everything bagel with eggs and cheese – hot and the right amount of crunch. Very helpful staff – must visit at Greenwood Lake
… more
Beachgirlk
Always delicious with friendly fast service.
… more
Rhiannon Pfeiffer
I want to love it here because everyone is so nice but my order is always wrong. My usual is an everything bagel with egg, cheese, a hash brown, with salt, pepper, and ketchup. The other times I was here and ordered this, they either forgot the cheese or ketchup, ok no big deal I guess. Today, they remembered the cheese and S,P,K but forgot the hash brown.
… more
Jessica Pauley
I was on the hunt for a special cake for a small gathering just a few days away when a friend tipped me off about GWL Bakery. Heather came through! She is easy to work with, knowledgeable about her options, creative, and committed. The cake came out both beautiful and delicious. It was a big hit and still good in the fridge for the days that followed the event. I would absolutely recommend GWL Bakery and Heather for anything you need. The prices are also reasonable. Thank you!
… more
Melissa S
They shouldn’t sign up with an organization and have a scheduled pickup between 3-3:30pm and when you get there the place is closed and door is locked. It’s not right when you come out of the area, looking forward to picking up the order.
… more
Melissa Koziel
The staff is always friendly and accommodating. The food is always delicious. They have a wonderful baked goods section which typically includes gluten free treats. Greenwood Lake Bagels is very supportive and involved in all the community events and are a true asset to GWL.
… more
Austin Evans
I wouldn’t trust the overall rating listed here. Go with your gut, and when you see reviews on how rude their staff is, you better believe it. I have never been here before, my family just moved up here so I was visiting. I decided to call in an order for my family on the drive there and the guy taking the call was very rude. How he speaks to potential customers would be absolutely unacceptable at any establishment that values their reputation and success for the business. The only way I see this place succeeds is because of the limited choice within the area for the residents. I decided to go across the street and I do not regret it for one second. They were extremely hands on and busy with the fact that they only had 2 employees working, but when I eventually had my order taken they were very respectful and kind. Their food was amazing too. I think if the Greenwood Lakes Bagel shop worked/trained more on their customer service etiquette, they would retain more business compared to whatever their customer base is like now.
… more
… View more