Pecado Mexican Menu – Bay Shore, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Bay Shore, NY

Based on 227 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Pecado Mexican 11706

Address:
49 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Phone: (631) 992-7717

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 4–10 PM
Wednesday 4–10 PM
Thursday 4–10 PM
Friday 11:30 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM
Sunday 11 AM–10 PM
Monday Closed

Menu

Items
Coconut Tres Leches
Flan
Churros

… View more

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Vonda
Went here with my girlfriends for a quick bite. We had reservations and we came late but we were still seated so that was great! Upon being seated we were immediately given water and chips with dip. The dip was really good. We waited however about 45 minutes just for appetizers and when the appetizer came out it was the wrong one, the waiter corrected the mistake and brought out the correct order which was great. My friends and I ordered each different kind of tacos, which I would note you cannot change any of the add ins you would like. (We tried the owner said no). The other waiter staff were great as well they kept coming around to change the chips and dip for us. We waited about 1hr 45 minutes from being seated for our tacos to come out .The drinks were really good and strong with great presentation. The ambience, vibe and decor were all amazing inside. The shrimp salad we ordered was amazing as well as the shrimp tacos , the chicken and beef tacos were okay. Overall I would recommend this restaurant it was just was a bit of a wait for our meals to come out

… more

Keri Tatro
We came for my brother’s birthday on a Friday night. We were told we would be seated in doors but when arrived, were told they had no seating in doors we would have to sit outside in the green house. It was nice in there, a bit chilly.

… more

Pat Scalise
Had dinner here last night in the outdoor patio which is decorated with beautiful greenery. The food and service was amazing, everything was very fresh. We ended the meal with Churros and Coconut Tres Leches, both were sooo delicious! The owner came over to say hello. We will definitely be back again.

… more

Mike “Bar.snobs” DeMarino
Really classy Mexican restaurant. Staff and service were exceptional. Food was out of this world. Steak burrito bowl was fresh and tasty and filling. The Mexican street corn app was so good, best I’ve had. Clarified Margarita was strong, sharp and clean. Love it, I’ll be back. Tell ’em Barsnobs sent ya!

… more

Isolina Yarde
Absolutely LOVED this place. First time coming and I don’t regret it. Super clean and I have OCD so trust me! The bathrooms were spotless!!! Ramsey was amazing.. great bartender. Loved him

… more

Rudy Scott
The food was very tasty and the service was just the right level. I enjoyed my chicken mole dish a lot. The level of seasoning was perfect for my palate and the portion was just right for me. My friend enjoyed her burrito immensely too. I won’t hesitate to return for another meal here.

… more

vr423
Went here for valentines day. Restaurant is extremely well kept and the staff is very friendly and inviting, even thru the chaos of the day. The food was brought out quickly and presented very nicely. The drinks were well made and paired well with the specials.

… more

Gina Pannone
Nice place, nice decor. Food was good but price is definitely more than other places that have equally as good food. Drinks were different than other places though and were very good. Our waitress was not good and I hope that she realized that by the tip left for her. It was a Thursday and there were only a few other tables filled in the restaurant. We had to look for her SEVERAL times… she was always at the bar/by the computers talking to another person. Never actually working while we were looking for her which was frustrating. In these times, waitstaff should be super attentive and on top of you, especially when paying higher prices than other restaurants in the area. We had to ask for her to get a 2nd drink (we were completely empty), ask for her to take our orders… etc. She never offered dessert (it was my birthday so I probably would have had something). I’d give her a 1 star if I could but the restaurant as a whole doesn’t deserve that. Hopefully management reads this and figures out who she is. We might go back but honestly, I’m not sure if it’s worth it for the higher price you pay per meal.

… more

Stephanie Zephirin
This was my 2nd time here and it was great. The food was amazing, the drinks were good but the staff was top notch. Our waitress Jasmine was super friendly and informative. We sat inside this time which was very nice, though the outside area is still my favorite. I will definitely be back

… more

Victoria Palumbo
We made a reservation for a Friday night for 6 people and were seated right away. Our waiter, Ramsey, was very attentive and friendly! He made sure we enjoyed our experience. We started a tradition of celebrating all of our birthdays on one night per year, and the staff sang to us to celebrate. The food was delicious, especially the nachos and the churros! We will be back again!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions