Chain pizzeria outlet for build-your-own Chicago-style deep-dish pies, plus wings & subs. Based on 408 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
350 S Van Buren St # C, Shipshewana, IN 46565
Phone: (260) 768-7272
Hours
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cliff Ferguson
Pizza was good ,but literally would not put fresh pizza out. Three families had shared 1 fresh pizza between us. 1 slice each. For 25$ Other pizzas on bar were dried out and had been there for awhile. I asked for some fresh pizzas the reply was buffet closes at 730. I can’t understand why you offer a buffet if you are not going to serve fresh food…..
… more
Laurel Hendrickson
We’ve been here many years ago and it’s still decent. Growing up in the Chicago area, we now what we like in pizzas. They are close and yummy.
… more
Erica Jo Byers Pelton
The best deep dish pizza our family has ever tried. We visited here when we were staying in Shipshewana and it is now a family favorite. The deep dish pizza is so good and the garlic cheese bread is amazing! We also love the Parm pops with marinara sauce. The prices are very reasonable and everything is always fresh. They also have a buffet but we were not there when it was running. If you go at lunchtime, they have the perfect size personal pizzas called flash pan pizza. Highly recommended! If we lived closer, this would be our go to pizza place!
… more
Gary Myers
Amazingly great tasting food! Pizza, that we consumed and was wanting more. Steak subs that melted in your mouth. Wings, spiced just right. Food was well prepared and the delivery team were kind and prompt and brought plates.
… more
Suzanne Millan
Delicious thin crust large veggie pizza! It was Sunday and we arrived late at our hotel and needed dinner — most places were closed but East of Chicago Pizza was thankfully open. We phoned in our order and they delivered it in about 40 min. Yay! Warm pizza with just the perfect amount of tomatoes, bell peppers, green and black olives, mushrooms, sauce, and cheese and delicious crust. Thank you, East of Chicago Pizza. Definitely recommend! ☺️
… more
kathy brewer
We were staying at the Shipshewana Campground and wanted something to eat close by and looked this place up! The pizza was delicious and very filling!
… more
Heather S
We enjoyed the buffet. It was a reasonable price and you could enjoy pop at a very low price compared to most establishments. The lettuce and salad toppings were fresh. The pizza was good. The dessert pizza was amazing! The staff kept a close eye on the buffet as the crowd increased for the supper rush. Our empty plates were promptly removed as we finished. This is a family friendly atmosphere and would work well if dining alone.
… more
Jorge Mora
Ordered thin crust 12 inch all pepperoni half sausage side of zesty garlic sauce.
… more
Northwest Michigan
The pizza was awesome, the cinnamon rolls where ugh nothing special. Just the right amount of sauce to crust ratio
… more
Sara Kub
Expected a little bit better quality pizza. It was still edible and the dessert pizzas were wonderful.
… more
… View more