The Old Mill Inn Menu – Alfred Station, NY

Type : American restaurant

Location : Alfred Station, NY

Based on 192 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

The Old Mill Inn 14803

Address:
1 Depot, Alfred Station, NY 14803

Phone: (607) 587-9060

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–10 PM
Thursday 11 AM–10 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–10 PM
Monday 11 AM–10 PM

Menu

FOOD
French Fries
Fresh cut to order in-house and fried golden brown		 $5.00
Cheese Fries
Fresh cut to order in-house and fried golden brown then coved in nacho cheese		 $5.75
Mill Fries
Our fresh cut fries tossed in our Mill Streak Seasoning		 $5.25
Cheesy Garlic Bread
A garlicky, buttery and cheesy flat bread cut into dippable strips and served with marinara sauce (for dipping)		 $12.00
Junior Sampler Platter
Two each of Jalapeno Poppers, Fried Raviolis, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Tenders, and some Onion Rings		 $12.50
Sampler Platter
Three each of Jalapeno Poppers, Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Tenders, and Fried Ravioli–plus a Soft Pretzel, a pile of Fries and Onion Rings, and a side of Nacho Cheese Sauce		 $24.00
Build Your Own Sampler Plate
Select three or more items to create your own Sampler Plate! 3.50 per item! (Limit 1 of each item)		 $15.00
Classic Hamburger
Our classic hand pressed, locally sourced burger, seasoned to perfection and topped with your choice of lettuce, tomato, onion, and cheese at no additional cost. Served with a side of our hand cut to order French fries.		 $10.75
All-American Burger
A bacon cheeseburger		 $12.50
Bacon And Blue Burger
A burger with onions, blue cheese crumbles, and bacon		 $13.25
Mushroom Swiss Burger
A burger with Swiss cheese and sauteed mushrooms		 $12.00
Roadhouse Burger
A burger topped with onion rings and barbecue sauce		 $12.00
Mill Stack Burger
A burger bun piled high with lettuce, pickles, chicken tenders, cheese, a quarter-pound burger, cheese again, bacon, onion rings, and another bun–served with a side of Garlic Parmesan French Fries		 $17.50
The Double Mill Stack Burger
A Mill Stack Burger stacked on top of a Mill Stack Burger—served with a side of Garlic Parmesan French Fries and a whole order of onion rings		 $34.50
Seafood Basket
Eight Yuengling-battered shrimp, plus breaded clam strips and fried calamari, served with an order of Cajun fries, cocktail sauce, coleslaw, and lemon wedges—perfect for sharing!		 $25.75
Fried Shrimp Basket
Sixteen Yuengling-battered shrimp served with a full-sized order of fries, a dish of cocktail sauce, and coleslaw		 $20.50
Seafood Bake
Seafood bake for two (or more) seasoned with your choice of cajun or lemon pepper. $48
Each bake is served with:
1 pound of mussels
1/2 pound jumbo shrimp
1/2 pound scallops
2 ears of corn
1 pound of salt potatoes
Lemon wedges
A pool of butter		 $48.00
Kids Grilled Cheese
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!		 $7.25
Kids Mac ‘N Cheese
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!		 $7.25
Kids Chicken Tenders
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!		 $7.25
Kids Chicken Wings
Kids’ Meals are served with a side of french fries, a fried Oreo, and a drink!		 $7.25
Baked Ziti
Ziti with pasta sauce and mozzarella cheese baked till melted, served with garlic bread		 $9.50
Chicken Tender Parmesan
A bed of penne topped with chicken tenders, pasta sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese—served with garlic bread		 $15.50
Three Cheese Mac ‘N Cheese
Mix in any one of our chicken rubs or sauces for a bit more bang!		 $10.00
Buffalo Chicken Mac ‘N Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with Frank’s Red Hot, chicken, and a scoop of blue cheese dressing on top		 $13.00
Taco Mac ‘N Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with our own taco-seasoned beef, topped with lettuce, tomato, and a dollop of sour cream		 $13.00
Cheeseburger Mac
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with burger mixed in and topped with lettuce, tomato, and onion		 $13.00
BBQ Ribs Mac ‘N Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with a healthy scoop of pulled barbecue pork rib meat mixed in		 $13.00
Philly Cheese Steak Mac
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese with shaved beef, roasted red peppers, and onions mixed in		 $13.00
Roadhouse Mac ‘N Cheese
Our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese topped with a generous portion of onion rings and drizzled with barbecue sauce		 $13.00
Cheese Pizza
Pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, and seasoned to perfection		 $10.25
Pepperoni Pizza
A Cheese Pizza but with pepperoni on it!		 $12.75
Cheeseburger Deluxe Pizza
A pizza with a Thousand Island base covered in mozzarella cheese, ground beef, pickles, lettuce, tomato, and onion		 $14.00
Beef On Weck Pizza
A pizza with a horseradish sauce base and Weck crust covered in mozzarella cheese and roast beef		 $14.00
Meat Lover’s Pizza
A pizza covered with pepperoni, sausage, and ground beef		 $16.50
Veggie Supreme Pizza
A pizza covered in onions, mushrooms, olives, and roasted red peppers		 $13.50
Taco Pizza
A pizza with a taco sauce base, mozzarella, ground beef, lettuce, tomato, and sour cream on top		 $13.75
BBQ Chicken Pizza
A pizza with a barbecue sauce base, mozzarella cheese, chicken, and a sprinkling of Mill Steak Seasoning		 $13.00
Bruschetta Pizza
A white pizza covered in diced tomatoes and seasoned to perfection		 $11.25
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza
A white pizza covered in shaved beef, roasted peppers, and onions		 $15.75
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
A pizza with a ranch dressing base, mozzarella cheese, diced bacon, and chicken on top		 $14.00
Pesto, Cheese, And Tomato Pizza
A pizza with a pesto base, mozzarella cheese, and whole slices of tomato		 $14.00
Wedge Salad
A half-head of lettuce, several slices of tomato, onion, blue cheese dressing, and blue cheese crumbles		 $10.50
Buffalo Chicken Salad
A bed of fresh greens with Buffalo chicken bits, mozzarella cheese, tomato, onion, and blue cheese dressing		 $10.50
Chef Salad
A heaping mound of lettuce, tomato, onion, turkey, ham, black olives, banana peppers, Swiss cheese, Parmesan cheese, and croutons—served with choice of dressing		 $13.75
Grilled Cheese Platter
Two grilled cheese sandwiches, a bowl of tomato soup, and a bag of potato chips		 $9.50
Deli Sub
Build your dream sub on an 8” Costanzo roll. Select your hand-sliced meats, cheese, veggies, and whatever else floats your boat for a fresh and delicious sub-venture.		 $10.00
Cheese Steak
Shaved beef with provolone cheese covered in sauteed onions and peppers on a sub roll—add cheese sauce on top for .75 more		 $11.25
Chicken Tender Sub
Chicken tenders on a sub roll with your choice of sub toppings, and have your tenders tossed in any of our wing sauces!		 $11.25
BLT
A sub roll with a bunch of bacon, lettuce, and tomato		 $10.00
Side Of Mac
A side order of our Three Cheese Mac ‘n Cheese		 $4.75
Tomato Soup (Cup)
Its a cup of tomato soup.		 $3.25
Tomato Soup (Bowl)
Its a bowl of tomato soup.		 $6.00
Soup Of The Day (Cup)
Ask us about our soup of the day!		 $3.25
Soup Of The Day (Bowl)
Ask us about our soup of the day!		 $6.00
Coleslaw
Cabbage and carrots shredded in-house and tossed in our homemade slaw dressing		 $4.00
Mac Salad
A side dish of our house made pasta salad		 $4.00
Side Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, croutons and your choice of salad dressing		 $4.00
Potato Chips
A bag of potato chips		 $2.00
Soup And Salad Combo $10.50
Cottage Cheese $4.00
Corn $2.50
Boneless Wings Party Box (5 LB) $60.00
3 Chicken Tenders $7.50
5 Chicken Tenders $12.50
8 Chicken Tenders $20.00
Chicken Tenders 5lb. Party Box $63.00
Cannoli
Two crispy and crunchy cannoli piped to order and dusted with confectioner’s sugar		 $7.50
Fried Dough
A heaping pile of our pizza dough fried golden brown and tossed in sugar		 $5.50
Smores Pizza
A pizza covered in butter, marshmallows, melted chocolate, and crushed graham crackers		 $11.75
Apple Pie Logs
Three Apple Pie Logs covered in sugar and drowned in caramel sauce		 $7.50
Fried Oreos
Three Oreos wrapped in fried dough and covered in powdered sugar with your choice of chocolate, salted caramel, or white chocolate sauce		 $6.50
Sauce/Dip $0.00
BEVERAGES
Glass Bottled Drink $3.00
20 Oz Drink $3.00
Red Bull $4.00
Gosling’s Ginger Beer $2.50
Chocolate Milk $2.50
Americano $1.50
Cappuccino $4.00
Cafe Latte $5.25
Cafe Mocha $4.00
Hot Chocolate $4.00
Espresso $1.50
Long Espresso $1.50
Cortadito $2.50
RETAIL
Roast Beef $12.00
Turkey $8.00
Ham $5.00
Swiss $8.00
Provalone $6.00
Pepperoni $8.00
American Cheese $5.50
Dill Pickle Spears (Quart) $6.50
Banana Peppers (Pint) $4.00
Jalapeno Peppers (Pint) $4.00
Sub Rolls (6) $6.50
Paper Plates (100) $5.00
Dinner Napkins (150) $6.00
Old Mill Inn Mill Steak Seasoning $5.00
Dough Ball (10 Oz) $1.75
Cottage Cheese $4.25
MERCH
Hoodie $40.00
Long Sleeve Tee Shirt $19.50
Short Sleeve Tee Shirt $15.00
Crew Neck Sweatshirt $35.00
SPECIALS – Steaks
12 Oz Strip Special $23.75
10 Oz Rancher $19.75
16 Oz Ribeye Special $32.50
SPECIALS – Weds.
Baby Back Ribs $29.50
Full Rack (NO SIDES) $25.00
Corn Bread (3) $5.50
Mill Rib Sandwich $12.75
SPECIALS – Friday.
Fish Fry Battered
Battered, broiled or grilled haddock served with a roll and butter, plus choice of two sides!		 $14.50
Fish Fry Grilled
Battered, broiled or grilled haddock served with a roll and butter, plus choice of two sides!		 $14.50
Fish Fry Broiled
Battered, broiled or grilled haddock served with a roll and butter, plus choice of two sides!		 $14.50
Stuffed Haddock $16.50
Fried Fish Sandwich $7.50
Party platters
1/2 Pan Baked Ziti $42.50
1/2 Pan Toss Salad $27.00
1/2 Pan Chef Salad $36.00
Veggie Platter
1 lb carrot, 1 bunch celery, 2 bell pepper, 1 cucumber, 8oz ranch dressing		 $32.00
Mac N’ Cheese (1/2pan) $42.50
SPECIALS
Burger Of The Day $11.50
Mill Rib Sandwich $12.75
Cuban Sandwich $14.25
Cheese Cake $8.50
Fried Puff Ball App $7.50
Buff Pasta Bake $15.50
Corn Dinner $11.50
Chicken Bowl $12.75
Pan Seared Salmon $17.50

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Sean Grohman
It’s been a few days since we’ve been to The Old Mill Inn, and I’m still thinking about the wings. They were excellent! The menu had a great variety of food and the restaurant itself has cool, what we call “I Spy” items on the wall and on shelves. There’s also a pool table and arcade upstairs. With Alfred State and University close by, The Old Mill Inn is definitely a great place to eat.

… more

Jason Somers
Got the Cheesesteak Mac. It was very good, but the portion was very small for the price. (a small bowl for $13)

… more

Christina Ferdinand
I came here with a very large group of diverse graduate students and enjoyed my visit. I had wings and fries, which were both good. I thought the service was top-notch. The waitress was super sweet and knowledgeable. The bartender was nice, and we didn’t wait long for a drink, and everyone was just way nicer than I thought they would be. The place was smaller than we thought, and they couldn’t really accommodate a large group inside, so they pulled some picnic tables together for us outside. It was a nice day, so it was fine, but that’s something to think about if your group is large. Lastly, we were surprised about how affordable the meal was. Not including our drinks (which we ordered at the bar), our group of 16 contributed about $20 per person which included tax and tip! Thats a steal! I would come back here.

… more

Belinda Thompson
We came never having heard of The Old Mill Inn but they were open on a Monday while so many other places weren’t.

… more

John Wilson (Best by Ethan)
The Old Mill keeps getting better, new upstairs dining area is very nice. Can’t wait for their deck to open!

… more

ChevelleCarcass
If your son or daughter are attending Alfred State or University, just take a little drive 10 minutes away to this cute place. Had a couple beers, watched the game and gulfed down one of their delicious burgers. The staff was very friendly and were on point with bringing out our food. We will definitely come here again, great place!

… more

Jim Moore
My two sons set up a birthday surprise party for me at The Old Mill on Saturday. Noah and his crew did a fantastic job taking care of all our needs. There were around 20 people at the party, and our waitress (Holly) should be commended. She made sure everyone was satisfied all the time while waiting on other customers. Anyone searching for a place to have a party, business meeting or the like, should consider The Old Mill.

… more

J Mac
The Old Mill is more than just a Mill that is Old. Once you walk through the front door you are transported to a place known to many as “Flavor Town”. There is such an awesome variety of food and drink that one could dine in this fine establishment weekly and it would take 231 weeks to try it all. It would be the best 4.125 years of your life.

… more

Perk’s Care
Ordered 9 dozen wings, and they were delivered to the table in 10 min. All flavors were excellent. The new deck is a nice place to sit for drinks and chat with friends. A++

… more

Georgia Sgroi
Lively. Huge liquor and beer selection. Mr.Bartender was a blast and had us cracking up the whole time. Regulars were friendly. All around a vibrant place to grab a bite to eat 🙂

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch