Tiberio’s Pizza Menu – Lancaster, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Lancaster, OH

Based on 98 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery

Tiberio's Pizza 43130

Address:
416 N Columbus St, Lancaster, OH 43130

Phone: (740) 808-8222

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Wednesday 11 AM–9 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9 PM
Friday 11 AM–10 PM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 4–8 PM
Monday 3–8 PM
Tuesday 11 AM–9 PM

Menu

Pizza
8″ Pizza (Personal)
Delicious original Tiberio’s sauce and crust recipes. Feeds 1 person.		 $6.50
12″ Pizza (Medium)
Delicious original Tiberio’s sauce and crust recipes. Feeds 2-3 people.		 $14.00
14″ Pizza (Large)
Delicious original Tiberio’s recipe. Feeds 3-4 people.		 $17.00
16″ Pizza (X-Large)
Delicious original Tiberio’s recipe. Feeds 4-5 people.		 $19.50
Gluten Free 12×5
Pamper yourself with our Gluten-Free crust, made with seasoned Cauliflower Flatbread. Not only is our gluten-free crust suitable for those with gluten sensitivities or celiac disease, but it is also Vegan, Vegetarian, and Keto friendly. Build-your-own gluten free pizza starting with Tiberio’s original sauce and choosing from a wide range of fresh ingredients, creating a delightful pizza experience for you to enjoy.		 $12.50
White Pizza
Our White Pizza is a culinary delight! Start with our perfectly baked pizza crust which serves as the canvas for this rich blend of flavors. Next, luscious Garlic Butter spread and handcrafted Pesto add a burst of vibrant freshness. Finally, dollops of creamy Ricotta and freshly shredded Provolone make each bite an exceptional taste experience.		 $7.50
Buffalo Pizza
Indulge in a mouthwatering symphony of flavors with our Buffalo Chicken Pizza. This savory sensation combines the tangy kick of Bob’s Backyard BBQ buffalo sauce and slow smoked chicken atop of their BBQ Ranch, topped with bacon, tomatoes, and provolone cheese. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of heat, smokiness, and savory satisfaction.		 $11.50
Four Meat Pizza
Our Four Meat pizza is a savory masterpiece that will satisfy even the heartiest of appetites. It is topped with slices of zesty Pepperoni, succulent Sausage, flavorful Ham, and crispy Bacon, served up with freshly shredded Provolone cheese melted to perfection, sure to satiate your palate.		 $11.50
All The Way Pizza
It all starts with our secret recipe pizza crust topped with Tiberio’s original sauce and freshly shredded Provolone Cheese. Zesty Pepperoni and seasoned Sausage deliver bold, savory notes, while sweet Onions and green Peppers provide a crisp bite. Mushrooms bring an earthy richness and mild Banana Peppers add a hint of heat. Together, making our All-The-Way pizza an incredibly delightful and gratifying choice for your taste buds.		 $14.00
Veggie Pizza
Crafted with care using premium ingredients, our handmade crust provides the perfect foundation, while our Tiberio’s original sauce infuses each bite with a tangy yet sweet zest. Topped generously with creamy Provolone cheese, earthy Mushrooms, sweet Onions, briny Green Olives, crisp Green Peppers, and Mild Banana Peppers, this pizza is a medley of fresh and vibrant vegetables. Savor this delicious combination of wholesome ingredients.		 $11.50
Stromboli
Small Build Your Own Stromboli (1 Sauce)
Starts with cheese & add up to 4 of your favorite toppings! Serves 1-2 people		 $7.50
Medium Build Your Own Stromboli (2 Sauces)
Starts with cheese & add up to 4 of your favorite toppings! Serves 3-4 people		 $18.50
Large Build Your Own Stromboli (3 Sauces)
Starts with cheese & add up to 4 of your favorite toppings! Serves 5-6 people		 $22.50
Traditional Stromboli
This Stromboli is a Tiberio’s classic that combines the rich flavors of Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Ham and Provolone cheese, all wrapped in a crispy and chewy, made-in-house pizza dough, served with our original recipe pizza sauce.		 $11.50
Large Extra Sauce
Our signature Tiberio’s original recipe pizza sauce.		 $1.50
Subs
Pizza Sub
A mouthwatering delight, our pizza sub brings together the classic flavors of pizza in the form of a sensational sub. It’s the perfect combination of pepperoni, provolone cheese, and Tiberio’s original, signature pizza sauce.		 $9.50
Ham And Cheese Sub
Layers of thinly sliced premium ham take center stage in this sub. We add creamy slices of provolone and melt it in the warmth of the oven. Fresh lettuce, juicy tomatoes, and Italian dressing are then added to bring a burst of freshness and crunch to the sandwich.		 $9.50
Veggie Sub
Our fresh baked bun serves as the perfect foundation for this veggie extravaganza. Our veggie sub is packed with a medley of colorful and flavorful ingredients. Crisp lettuce and ripe tomatoes add a refreshing crunch and burst of juiciness. Thinly sliced Mushrooms and Onions bring an earthy note and subtle sweetness. Then the sub is adorned with briny Green Olives, vibrant Green Peppers and Banana Peppers bringing a mild heat. Finally, the sub is topped with provolone Cheese and Italian Dressing, creating a symphony of flavors that bring out the best in every ingredient.		 $9.50
Italian Sub
A Tiberio’s classic, our Italian Sub is a delightful combination of Italian-inspired ingredients. This sub features thin slices of savory ham and zesty pepperoni, creamy provolone cheese, mild banana peppers, topped with crisp lettuce and juicy tomatoes, then finished with our tangy Italian dressing.		 $11.50
Meatball Sub
This sandwich combines the hearty flavors of our original handmade meatballs using the cherished Schorr family recipe, creamy provolone cheese, and Tiberio’s signature marinara sauce.		 $11.50
Loaded Ham & Cheese Sub
Our signature ham and provolone cheese sub is loaded with fresh Lettuce, juicy Tomatoes, Mushrooms, sweet Onions, Green Olives, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, and Italian dressing to bring a burst of flavors and freshness to this tantalizing sandwich.		 $11.50
Chicken Parmesan Sub
This sub combines the satisfying crunch of a fried chicken filet with the bold sweet flavors of our signature marinara sauce and melted provolone cheese.		 $12.50
Salads
Italian Salad
Crisp Hearts of Romaine, Spring Mix, juicy Tomatoes, Green Olives, Black Olives, mild Banana Peppers, Salami, sweet Green Peppers, nutty Parmesan Cheese, and fragrant Basil.		 $11.50
Chef Salad
A satisfying combination of Crisp Romaine, Spring Mix, Provolone Cheese, Tomato, Pepperoni, diced Ham, Mushrooms, Green Pepper, Banana Peppers, and Green Olives.		 $12.50
Tossed Salad
Crisp Hearts of Romaine, Spring Mix, juicy Tomato, sweet Onion, zesty Pepperoni, and Provolone cheese.		 $6.00
Simple Salad
A refreshing and straightforward combination of crisp Hearts of Romaine lettuce, Spring Mix, grated Parmesan, a hint of Pepper and a zesty dressing made with Olive Oil and Lemon Juice.		 $6.00
Fried Chicken Salad
A hearty combination of crisp Romaine lettuce, Spring Mix, a tender Fried Chicken filet, juicy Tomatoes, sweet Onion, and Provolone cheese.		 $13.50
Extra Dressing $0.75
Pasta
Lasagna With Salad And 1 Breadstick
Tiberio’s original recipe with hearty layers of meat sauce, noodles, ricotta, parmesan, and provolone cheeses, served along side a mouthwatering breadstick, generously coated in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese, and your choice of a simple or tossed salad, OR a steaming cup of the Soup of the Day.		 $14.50
Spaghetti W/Marinara, Salad And 1 Breadstick
A generous portion of spaghetti topped with Tiberio’s original pesto-flavored tomato sauce, served along side a mouthwatering breadstick, generously coated in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese, and your choice of a simple or tossed salad, OR a steaming cup of the Soup of the Day.		 $11.50
Spaghetti W/Meat Sauce, Salad And 1 Breadstick
A generous portion of spaghetti topped with Tiberio’s original meaty tomato sauce, served along side a mouthwatering breadstick, generously coated in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese, and your choice of a simple or tossed salad, OR a steaming cup of the Soup of the Day.		 $11.50
Baked Ziti
Creamy ricotta & Tiberio’s original marinara mixed into ziti noddles & topped with provolone, served along side a mouthwatering breadstick, generously coated in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese, and your choice of a simple or tossed salad, OR a steaming cup of the Soup of the Day.		 $14.50
Chicken Parmesan
Spaghetti topped with Tiberio’s original marinara, fried chicken breast & melted cheese, served along side a mouthwatering breadstick, generously coated in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese, and your choice of a simple or tossed salad, OR a steaming cup of the Soup of the Day.		 $14.50
Appetizers
French Fries
Golden sticks of potato deep fried to perfection.		 $3.50
6 Fried Cheese Ravioli
Served with Tiberio’s original signature pizza sauce		 $6.50
3 House Made Meatballs
The Schorr Family recipe served in Tiberio’s original signature marinara.		 $6.00
Garlic Bread
Our fresh sub bread with a slathering of garlic butter, toasted and served alongside Tiberio’s original signature pizza sauce		 $5.00
5 Mozzarella Sticks
A classic that combines gooey, melted mozzarella cheese with a crispy golden brown coating. Served with Tiberio’s original signature pizza sauce.		 $7.50
3 Breadsticks
3 Breadsticks with a crispy crust and soft interior, layered with garlic butter & sprinkled with parmesan cheese, served with Tiberio’s original signature pizza sauce		 $5.00
Dressed Fries W/Olive Aioli
To elevate your French fry experience, we offer a side of our delectable homemade olive aioli. Our aioli is crafted in-house using the finest ingredients, ensuring a burst of flavor with every dip.		 $6.00
Garlic Bread W/Cheese
Our fresh baked Sub bread generously slathered with creamy garlic butter, topped with provolone cheese, then carefully toasted and served with Tiberio’s original signature pizza sauce		 $7.50
Soup Of The Day W/Breadstick
Indulge in a steaming cup or hearty bowl of our special recipe Soup of the Day. Served along side a mouthwatering breadstick, generously coated in garlic butter and sprinkled with parmesan cheese. Call us now to inquire about today’s irresistible creation!		 $4.50
Large Extra Sauce
Our signature Tiberio’s original recipe pizza sauce.		 $1.50
Garlic Butter $0.75
Small Extra Sauce $0.75
Drinks
20oz
Quench your thirst with our carefully selected range of Pepsi beverages, each offering a unique and invigorating experience.		 $2.00
Magic Slushie $3.50

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

kelsy nye
First time here and I am not disappointed. Everything from the appetizers to my personal pizza was delicious. And the portions were very generous. Would definitely come back when in town in order as delivery

… more

Keenan Shumaker
Great pizza place. We got a pizza and stromboli. Besides the minor hick up in the kitchen, which they made right, food was awesome. Topped nicely and crispy crust. The steomboli was filled generously. Their marinara is sweeter and seasoned with herbs which balance the sweetness out.

… more

The Real Pimp Roy Lee
Customer service was outstanding!

… more

Austin Hossfeld
Tiberio’s Pizza is a family-owned and operated business that has been serving Lancaster, Ohio for a long time. They are known for their delicious pizza, made with fresh ingredients and a traditional recipe.

… more

Matthew Crosby
Loved this pizza before. Since it changed hands, the pizza isn’t the same. They need to Not roll the crust so thin, put a little bit more sauce, and less cheese. I never order light cheese from anywhere bc I like cheese, but too much makes the pizza very greasy. All I can taste is the cheese. I wasn’t to taste the crust and sauce too.

… more

Doug L
We threw our food away. Ordered a traditional Stromboli. There was enough ham / toppings to make 2 large sandwiches, the dough was PAPER THIN and flavorless. The cheese almost choked me because it was so chewy for some reason.

… more

Melissa Grannon
I really loved the pizza at the other location. While not a bad pizza (and I really want emphasize that) it was decidedly different in taste than the pizza from the other location. The sauce was not as good and the crust was different too. Was it bad? Not at all just not the same and a little lacking in flavor arena. Pretty much just okay pizza that you expect from here in Lancaster. Our server was tops I will say that he kept our drinks full and checked on us frequently. I just felt it lacked variety and flavor. Maybe as the business makes tweaks it will get a bit better. I will check back in the summer.

… more

Resa Tobin
Wonderful food with fast and friendly service (when you are there and they are not swamped). They are honest with how long your order will take so you can plan accordingly. LOVE the sauce and it will make you come back. They do not skip on the filling or toppings.

… more

Greg Hawkins
Me and may family went there tonight on 4/17/23 and we was greeted very well. We ordered a XL pizza and two order of cheese sticks and our server was awesome and the gentleman that came an asked us how everything was and he made our night by going above and beyond. I haven’t had this type is service from a restaurant in a while. Keep it going and we will definitely be back. We would recommend this place to anyone looking for a great atmosphere and service and not to mention the food.

… more

Scott Grensted
My personal experience was absolutely amazing. My food was great. The people were friendly. The restaurant had a makeover. Had a huge wall that opened up like a garage door and basically turned it into a indoor but outdoor seating. It was pretty nice. I’ll go back.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch