Casual menu with pizza plus pasta, subs & wings served out of a straightforward, take-out joint. Based on 332 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
2047 Oakland Ave, Elkhart, IN 46516
Phone: (574) 293-3683
Website: https://saylors-pizza-more.business.site/
Hours
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nick Ludlow
First time trying Saylor’s. Called in and asked for a Medium – the person recommended a Large for .40 more. We went with the Large – with sausage.
… more
Vern Nissley
I must admit that I always liked the meaty pizza but tonight I LOVED it!
… more
Julie Riddle
I ordered a special pepperoni pizza request for my friend Cindy’s birthday & had it delivered to her for lunch as a surprise. I spoke with Barry on the phone he went above & beyond to help make it a successful birthday with joy! Who doesn’t like pizza on your birthday?! I appreciate his willingness to assist & for the small town hospitality he offered. Thanks Barry & Saylor’s Pizza, you’re the Best!
… more
King Leroy Williams
Saylor food is trash, I purchased a gyro plater with 2 pita bread there meat was from Costco and it wasn’t enough to even have 2 pita bread only gotten 7 thin slices meat with a tiny cup of tomatoes, lettuce, and sauce. The fries was soggy and half cook and had the nerves to charge an extra dollar for a pita bread which totaled out to be $15.50. I WILL NEVER EVER ORDER EAT ANYTHING FROM THEM EVER AGAIN. I see why they have ONLY ONE Saylor’s Restaurants.
… more
Chris Wells
Small place with big taste! I love the baked spaghetti and the chicken parm (pasta)! Add meatballs (2 for $1)!!! Baked spaghetti with 4 meatballs, $9.00 I did a pick-up order for 4, was done in 25 min. Friendly people. Good food.
… more
Jeanette Waltz
Pizza is really good, but they’ve changed the pizza sauce, not fond of it. They use real cheese, meats.
… more
Brittany Kobza
Loved it. The guy was the sweetest! We got pulled over on the way and he was closing and we got there right as he was guna close up but I called n he gladly waited on us!! Thank you will def b back jus cuz of that alone!!
… more
Melanie Archer
Absolutely love this place. Top notch pizza and the dinners are amazing! The bbq beef tips are super tender and the portions are huge with great prices! Definitely recommend!
… more
Rosalin
The pizza looked good, but after a couple bites i realized it wasn’t good. There’s barely any sauce, the cheese was just bad, the mushrooms looked like they had been sitting in the fridge for days. The dough was chewy and unpleasant, same goes for the breadsticks. The fries were limp and soft, making fries frozen from the store gets you better results. I would not recommend this to anybody. Little Caesar’s 5$ pizza is better than their large pizza with two toppings.
… more
Judi H
Ordered a Gyros sandwich, JUST under $10.00. To begin with, it was 4 slices of PROCESSED Gyros meat, and they added lettuce (I have never seen lettuce in a Gyros before). It was terrible, they should be charging $3.00. If this is the quality of their food, I will never return. As a 1st time customer, you never have a second chance to make a first impression!!!
… more
… View more