Based on 98 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
34 Mill St, New Buffalo, PA 17069
Phone: (717) 834-6565
Website: http://www.milliespizza.com/
Hours
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
lifting18
Great place to eat, I ordered a boil no peppers, no onions. They got it wrong the first time, but the second time got it right, along with a hand written note apologizing. You don’t get that type of service from any pizza shop. Food is top notch, boil’s, subs, and pizzas are all great, I’d recommend the garlic hot wing pizza, it’s great.
… more
Google user
I’ve been eating from this restaurant for nearly two years and I really like the owner he’s very nice and his food is really good , thank you Millies Pizza
… more
Summer Lynn
Millie’s is the epitome of small town pizza shop subs… But so much better! You can’t get what they offer at Subway or any chain sub shop! I’ve been ordering for a few months and I have never been disappointed! The value to price comparison can’t be beat! I am forever a loyal fan! Keep up the great job guys!
… more
Elijah Lentz
Very versatile good pizza I was pleasantly surprized
… more
Vickie Ahl
We tried for a he first time Thursday. The 2large extra cheese and mushroom pizzas were really good as were the large Fry’s. We will be ordering again. Thank you.
… more
Jon Bailey
Millie’s is my absolute favorite in the area and in the running for tip of the top and that is saying a lot in my book.
… more
Brittany Ryan
Best pizza around!!!!! We drive from New Bloomfield any time we want pizza! Love the Engle family!
… more
Alvin Owens
I drive a truck and they delivered this awesome pizza right to me @ the truck stop up the road where I’m staying. This is their Steak Lover’s Pizza. Very nice people.
… more
Honey Keiser
This is the best little pizza shop we have ever found. Top quality ingredients, fair prices, friendly owner and staff. Highly recommend Millie’s Pizza!
… more
Keiser PvP
Highly recommend …… We drive 30 miles just to get the best pizza @ Millie’s! …… our church Gods missionary church in Duncannon loves Millie’s for youth group occasions as well!
… more
… View more