Smyth Tavern, a bar and restaurant from the Mercer Street Hospitality Team features an American Tavern style menu highlighting steaks and various meats, pastas, fish and a specialty burger. The dining room designed with Meyer Davis is heavily clad in Mahogany wood panels, leather booths and artwork curated from local galleries that will rotate bi-annually.
Based on 90 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
85 W Broadway, New York, NY 10007
Phone: (646) 813-9090
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 7 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–10:30 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–10:30 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–10:30 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | 7 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Reviews
April Turner
Stumbled upon this gem while looking for dinner without a reservation and was PLEASANTLY surprised from the moment we walked in! The lighting certainly set the mood for the moment to finally relax after a long workday and our waitress, Tish, took care of us til the moment we left. The food was delicious, ordered the burrata- heirloom tomato special and branzino st. tropez; as well as the drinks, got the Barbie cocktail. Tish also treated us to one of their amazing desserts, the chocolate 7 layer cake and freshly baked chocolate chip cookies . Can’t wait to go back!
… more
Luke S
As I walked in I was immediately cared for and brought right to my table. As I strolled through the restaurant the decor was breath taking and I felt like I was in a upscale modern tavern. As I began with the fried calamari it was delectable and I could not eat it fast enough. The service was absolutely thrilling. My water glass was always filled and the waiter left us with the perfect amount of time to make our food choices. I opted for the Bash Burger. My taste buds were absolutely tickled. I was left smiling and satisfied. I will definitely be dining at this fine establishment again very soon.
… more
Bobby
It’s such a shame a good kitchen is being let down by poor service. We took 8 guests to dinner and the food was good but it seemed like the servers had better things to do than look after us properly. They were pushy about taking orders befor we sipped our for cocktails then they didn’t seem to understand starters come before main course the worst was our wine finally arrived after we had finished our main course.
… more
Noa Gamliel
Went here for the first time last week and had the most incredible experience. It is such a cozy restaurant with a great atmosphere. The food was absolutely incredible, every single thing we ordered was amazing, cooked to perfection with delicious flavors. And what truly made the entire experience was the staff. The general manager was the kindest, sweetest, warm person and she’s funny too! Our server, Janelle was also so so so great and also had the best personality and provided amazing service. From now on, every time I visit NYC I will not be missing the Smyth Tavern.
… more
Alexa V. Morales
To start, our server Tish, certainly deserves a promotion. She went above and beyond to set the tone for an unforgettable dinner. In our opinion she would be much better suited in a higher capacity. Not only was she well versed on the entire wine list, she also recommended the best dinner dishes. To top it off, the added dessert was the cherry on top. She was charismatic, warm and welcoming. Thank you Tish for making our evening one to remember! – A&C
… more
Ashley Turner
Best dining experience I’ve had in some time. Tish was so attentive and recommended the best drink (Barbie-inspired) and delicious plates. The ambiance and soundtrack was the cherry on top! I can’t wait to return with more friends and loved ones.
… more
Reina Flower
Wonderful dining experience! From the great food to the exceptional service. My mom wanted an item from the dinner menu and was accommodated with the chef making sure it was to her liking. Tish@smythtavern provided exceptional service, Juan kept our water replenished and Dawn the manager made it extra special with her friendliness!! Highly recommend to anyone looking for a special afternoon dining experience
… more
Meag F
Saw the pasta on Mike Chau’s story and needed to try — it tasted even better than it looked. The burger also looked delicious, but besides the sesame bun, it tasted pretty average, and wasn’t serviced with anything other than ketchup; fries were underdone/floppy. Service was a bit off but I think this place just opened, so no big deal. Drinks were mostly ice. 10/10 would go again for the lobster pasta.
… more
Fransisca Maria
It was truly THE BEST place we have ever eaten, amazing people. Amazing chef and an amazing atmosphere…They truly value their customers and take the time for you. We had the chef special pasta and it was the best pasta we ever had. . .
… more
Joy McGivern
We are guests at the hotel and wandered into the tavern. Much to our delight, we were greeted kindly and served by the beautiful and effervescent TISH who warmly provided a lovely dining experience complete with sweet surprises and she didn’t even know it was our anniversary. We are so grateful. And the cheesecake- wow!
… more
… View more