Neighborhood eatery serving up pizzas, wings & other fare in utilitarian surroundings. Based on 240 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
707 Fairmount Ave, Jamestown, NY 14701
Phone: (716) 484-2107
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 3–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mandie
Super excited to write this review! We decided to go here for the first time for a late dinner and check it out as we love pizza and we were not disappointed at all! Small and cozy and clean with literally the “Perfect Pizzas “ We ordered the white pizza with tomato n onions and a regular pizza with pepperoni and mushrooms. We also ordered deep fried mushrooms, lemon pepper chicken wings and tangy boneless wings. Everything was absolutely delicious and cooked again with perfection! The owner was our server and she is an absolute sweetheart! She checked in with us throughout our meal to ensure everything was to our liking. At the end of our meal she took the time and talked with us and asked our names which she remembered at the end of our night! We had to take some food home since we ordered a lot to try and she helped box it all up! She let us know the hours of operation as well and we talked about where everyone was from! Super comfortable conversation and it was great to talk to the owner like we were all old friends! Perfect Pizza will be the only place we get pizza from around here!
… more
André La Crout
This place is a little “hidden” in a plaza where it can easily be missed, but it certainly deserves more attention!
… more
Becky Hemmis
The owner/waitress was very welcoming and even remembered us. It was a nice family vibe.
… more
Jennifer Davis
Our 1st pizza from here. We thought it was good. Sauce wasn’t too sweet, the crust was perfect, not too chewy not too hard. We’ll be back!!
… more
Carmen Greco
Stopped here on our way home from a weekend away. The food was delicious and the portions are generous. Not only that, but the prices were great too! The ambiance made me feel like we were having a pizza party and we enjoyed ourselves. Thanks!
… more
Joseph D
So we have ordered from here twice and have to say the pizza and (especially the Italian ranch parm) wings are very delicious! The ONLY reason we didn’t give a 5* was because the customer service was very awkward. It almost seems like they don’t want your business. To start, online it says they’re open 4p-9pm on Tuesdays. We called at 730 thinking we had plenty of time and we’re told they close at 8 so they refused our order. So Wednesday we were sure to call at 630 to place an order to be picked up right at 8. When we got there to pick it up at 740 they already had their closed sign up and seemed very anxious to get out of there. Only being open 4hrs in one night and not offering delivery you’d think they would at least take orders and be open the WHOLE 4hrs. It just felt like the ordering and picking up was burdensome to the employees, which is a real shame because the food was great. And the order was accurate
… more
Gregory Styne
Love Pam & her husband; great Pizza and wings. Our family has been coming here for years
… more
M Zhu
Their gluten free pizza was delicious! I didn’t expect much as a lot of gluten-free pizza has a pretty bland crust. But this crust was crispy on the edges with a light and slightly springy middle. It was baked to the right consistency with all the tasty toppings I selected. Yum!
… more
MTV SLIME
I want for the first time yesterday 1/22/23 with my fiancée. Expecting it to be decent at least. Not even that pizza was undercooked no season at all tomato sauce was very bland and green worst I spent almost $40 got home to taste it and was very disappointed. You folks are better off getting that $6 dollar pizza from little Caesars or even dominions pizza is 100% better.
… more
Scott Covert
I always have a great experience with this place it shocks me when I see some really bad reviews the owners are always nice if there are others who work there who are rude and don’t make the food right it should be rectified because you’re a good place
… more
… View more