Allendale Steakhouse Menu – Allendale, NJ

Type : Steak house

Location : Allendale, NJ

Based on 286 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Allendale Steakhouse 07401

Address:
95 W Allendale Ave, Allendale, NJ 07401

Phone: (201) 962-9797

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 4–9:30 PM
Wednesday 4–9:30 PM
Thursday 4–9:30 PM
Friday 4–10 PM
Saturday 4–10 PM
Sunday 2–8:30 PM
Monday Closed

Photo Gallery

Order and Reservations

Reservations: opentable.com

Reviews

Ed Mattingly
Highly recommend reservations as this is a well known and intimate establishment with smaller seating area. BYOB was a huge plus for my wife celiac Annie and I, as it helped keep the bill a little lower vs. usual. Nice wine store immediately across the street. Great service and amazing cuts of meat. Even my wife’s fish was on point. Love the atmosphere.

… more

Adam Arciola
Great experience eating at this steakhouse. Didn’t catch or waiters name but he had glasses on. He was awesome! Served our large group perfectly and gave us great recommendations. I had the the bone-in ribeye . Lobster Mac n cheese stole the show!!!! It’s BYOB just for your information. Can’t wait to go back.

… more

Jeannie Baez
Delish! Every single item ordered was spectacular: Steak for 4, mashed potatoes, Lobster Mac n Cheese, spinach, scallops with bacon, prawn cocktail, bacon chunk (I don’t remember the name), lobster tails… amazing! A bit pricey, but worth it, especially since you can bring your own bottle. Highly recommend!

… more

Alexandra Reinoso
Steak order M if perhaps you like “MW”…

… more

Yasemin Ustunluk
Amazing service. Great group of staff. Stuffed mushrooms were excellent. Our server (blonde, tall) forget his name – was the star of the show. Complimentary dessert was delicious. Definitely returning!

… more

Patricia F Schwartz
This is a BYOB steakhouse, outdoor and indoor dinning and attentive service. The portions were large and many take a leftovers home. The steaks were tender and properly prepared.

… more

Dave Naimaister
Went there with a friends who are regulars. Loved it..Had the Porterhouse for 3 and it fed 4 of us easily..with leftovers..You want a good steak in Northern Bergen county, go there…and the service was great..BYOB!!!

… more

Mark C.
Ordered the crab meat cocktail appetizer, not very fresh. My filet mignon entree, ordered medium and received super well done. Overall very disappointing.

… more

Olga Rodland
Stay away. The restaurant was highly recommended. I am not sure where to start about this lackluster place. The only good thing was a perfect temperature of San Pellegrino. Caesar salad was wilted, smelled of fish (I guess I am not just a fan of anchovy dressing). We returned it. We ordered medium Sirloin ($50). On the first try it came just rare to raw. On the second try it came out as medium rare to rare. The waiter told us that we don’t get the idea as it was prepared 5 star chef and we shouldn’t doubt it. This comment stands out as quite rude. We didn’t touch the meat. Asked for a check. Any decent place I have been at least would try to make up for the horrendous experience, but not them. Just stay away, you can get a better steak and service in any steak chain.

… more

G F
4.5/ 5 – Went for dinner service on a weekend. There is limited restaurant parking but street parking is available. BYOB with a liquor store across the street. Reservations are highly recommended. Service was ok. Only had the Porterhouse, which was great and I would order again. Price point is fair for the quality of steak. Possibly the best steak I’ve had in the area.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions